Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Scottish Budget

Members’ Virtual Question Time Finance and Economy

Thursday 14 May 2020 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 2 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

2 contributions
Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The Cabinet Secretary for Finance will be aware that the Scottish Fiscal Commission identified that there will be a £1 billion black hole in the Scottish budget by 2023. That, of course, was before the coronavirus crisis, so the position will probably be worse. However, there is an immediate concern for this year’s budget. Land and buildings transaction tax is likely to be down, and spending on social security is likely to be up. Does she consider that there is enough money in the Scotland reserve and through remaining borrowing to cover the budget variation?

Kate Forbes SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance · Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

That is another very good question. One of the top agenda items for my next conversation with the Chief Secretary to the Treasury is on exactly that point: the fiscal flexibilities that the Scottish Government needs in order to resolve some of the uncertainties that Jackie Baillie has flagged.

The Barnett consequentials that we have received over the past few weeks have been very welcome. I have placed on record the constructive conversations that I have had and my gratitude for them. We will ensure that every penny at our disposal is spent on safeguarding Scotland’s interests, but it goes without saying that the consequentials do not cover the need, so we have had to work very quickly to look at ways to meet that need across the budget. I will introduce a summer budget revision for the Parliament to scrutinise, so that it can look at how we have ensured that the budget meets that need.

Jackie Baillie mentioned the longer-term issues about flexibility in relation to reconciliations. We need more fiscal flexibility and powers in order to resolve those uncertainties, and I hope that I can count on cross-party support on that. The cross-party Finance and Constitution Committee also flagged the issue, so she will know that, given our powers on borrowing and the reserves, we will be left struggling to cover reconciliations next year if the United Kingdom Government does not provide additional flexibility. I hope that it will.

  1. Finance and Economy Questions · 1
  2. Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme Questions · 2
  3. Business Support Questions · 2
  4. Scottish Budget Questions · 2
  5. Business Support (Tax Havens) Questions · 4
  6. Business Support Questions · 2
  7. Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (Extension) Questions · 4
  8. Business Support Questions · 4
  9. United Kingdom Government (Taxation and Expenditure Plans) Questions · 2
  10. Key Workers (Pay Rise) Questions · 2
  11. Crisis Support for Small Businesses Questions · 2
  12. Scottish Newspaper Industry (Support) Questions · 2
  13. Youth and Outdoor Education Organisations (Funding) Questions · 2
  14. Digital Economy Questions · 3
  15. Lifting Lockdown (Under-50s) Questions · 9
  16. Health and Sport Questions · 1
  17. Cervical Cancer Screening (Self-test Kits) Questions · 3
  18. Independent Medical Sector (Treatment Provision) Questions · 5
  19. Care Homes (Reproduction Number) Questions · 4
  20. Covid-19 Testing (Care Homes) Questions · 4
  21. Cervical Cancer Screening Questions · 2
  22. Guidance for Hospices Questions · 2
  23. Support for Sport Questions · 6
  24. Mental Health Support (Health and Care Staff) Questions · 2
  25. Covid-19 Antibody Testing Questions · 2
  26. Personal Protective Equipment (Face Masks) Questions · 2
  27. Covid-19 Test Kits (Care Homes) Questions · 2
  28. Covid-19 Testing (NHS Grampian) Questions · 2
  29. Covid-19 Testing (Care Workers) Questions · 6
  30. Social Care Workers (Living Wage) Questions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.