Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Construction Industry

Members’ Virtual Question Time Local Government and Communities

Thursday 30 April 2020 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Jeremy Balfour Con Lothian
link

My question is for Aileen Campbell. The construction industry in England is starting up again next week. When will the Scottish Government allow construction work to continue in Scotland? As she will be aware, many firms are struggling financially and houses are not being built. What will it take for the Scottish Government to relax the rules in Scotland so that they align with those in the rest of the United Kingdom?

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Although your question was addressed to the cabinet secretary, Mr Balfour, I believe that the matter comes under Kevin Stewart’s responsibility.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning · Aberdeen Central
link

I thank Mr Balfour for the question. I chair the construction leadership forum as well as its restart group, which looks at [Temporary loss of sound.] sites again as we move forward. Ministers will made decisions that are based on the evidence that we receive from medical and scientific experts, before we move forward.

I am very grateful to the many companies that have been helping to formulate guidance on how a safe return to work can take place and on the phased return that we may have to deal with. I am also grateful for the help of all those who are taking part in the numerous talks that we are having on what the restart might look like.

However, the key point for the Government in all of this is [Temporary loss of sound.] the spread of the virus, on which we will be guided by the evidence presented to us by the medical and scientific experts before we make such decisions.

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Mr Balfour would like to ask a brief supplementary.

Jeremy Balfour Con Lothian
link

Could the minister either publish or let us have today any evidence that he has that is different from that in the rest of the United Kingdom? In saying that the construction industry cannot be open, what scientific evidence is he relying on that is different from what is available in England?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning · Aberdeen Central
link

Not as many sites are operating south of the border as some would think. Beyond that, we should not look just at what is happening south of the border; we must look at what is happening in the rest of the world [Temporary loss of sound.] before we look at the rest of the UK. For example, my understanding is that Italy has yet to allow any construction work—apart from the most essential work—to take place.

We have to be guided by the advice that we receive from the medical experts on ensuring that we keep the reproduction number well below 1. When we reach the stage at which such experts think that the time is right, ministers will take those decisions. Today and previously, members will have heard the First Minister speak about getting that balance absolutely right. The Government will continue to look at all the advice. However, I repeat that stopping the spread of the Covid-19 virus is key to everything that we are doing.

Joan McAlpine SNP South Scotland
link

Dumfries Timber Company, which is a builders’ merchant business in my constituency, very responsibly closed its doors to all customers except those working on essential infrastructure, as per the Scottish Government’s guidelines. However, it has found that the big national chains are not doing that; indeed, they are providing non-essential items such as garden landscaping materials, which is taking business away from that responsible local company. Can any minister advise how the regulations might be enforced in relation to companies that act in such a way? There seems to be a lack of clarity, in that different messages are coming from the Scottish and UK Governments.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning · Aberdeen Central
link

[Temporary loss of sound.] Ms McAlpine to send me the details of the situation that she describes, and we will look into it.

Essential works to ensure people’s safety are going on across the country. Yesterday, along with a number of the trade bodies, including SELECT, I appealed to the general public to treat folks who are going about their business entirely within the rules and are helping others with the respect that they deserve.

If Ms McAlpine wishes to send me the details of the situation in her area, I will certainly have a close look at it and get back to her as soon as I possibly can.

  1. Local Government and Communities Questions · 1
  2. Voluntary Sector (Support) Questions · 2
  3. Local Government Funding Questions · 4
  4. Local Government Funding Questions · 2
  5. Business Support Questions · 2
  6. Local Government Funding Questions · 3
  7. Local News Media Questions · 9
  8. Fuel Poverty Questions · 2
  9. Construction Industry Questions · 8
  10. Emergency Free Meals Questions · 3
  11. Travel to Second and Holiday Homes Questions · 2
  12. Business Support Questions · 4
  13. Business Support Questions · 5
  14. Contact Tracing (Councils) Questions · 2
  15. Fly-tipping and Recycling Centres Questions · 6
  16. Planning Questions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.