Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Covid-19 (Testing)

Members’ Virtual Question Time

Friday 17 April 2020 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 5 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

5 contributions
Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link

The Scottish Government appears to have been a Covid-19 test sceptic from day 1 and, in the light of Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport Jeane Freeman’s answer to Willie Coffey, it seems that it remains so. Does the cabinet secretary stand by the Scottish Government’s decision not to follow World Health Organization advice to carry out widespread community testing, and will she give a clear and unequivocal commitment to publish immediately the advice of her advisors that informed that decision?

Jeane Freeman SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport · Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

We have been through this many times. I would not describe the Scottish Government as a “sceptic” on testing, at all. We are busy ramping up our testing capacity.

The advice that we have had has always been about the purpose of testing, which is threefold. Initially, as Neil Findlay will recall, the purpose of testing related to the test, trace and isolate approach. At this stage of the path through the pandemic, we have moved to the three purposes of testing. One relates to clinical treatment of patients in hospital. Initially, it also related to clinical treatment of residents of care homes, but we are now widening testing out to all symptomatic residents of care homes.

Another purpose of testing is community surveillance, which is based on the surveillance measures that are well in place for flu that we have used for years. The third purpose is to assist key workers to get back to work. That remains the case.

I am sure that members will have heard the First Minister talk yesterday and again today about the matter. The numbers that are coming through seem to suggest that all the sacrifices and efforts that people have made in following public health guidance—on staying at home and going out only for very restricted purposes, on social distancing of 2m, and on people from different households not meeting—are being successful, at this point, in suppressing prevalence of the virus in the community. That is fragile, at this point: we need to do a bit more. Hence, there will be continuation of the measures for another three weeks.

However, we are planning how we might use testing in any situation in which we begin to lift one or other of the restrictions. The testing capacity will be significantly increased by then, in order to ensure that we can bring into our toolbox—if you like—a much-enhanced test, trace and isolate approach. We would be going back to containment, but on a much bigger scale.

From the evidence that we have seen and the advice that we have been given by our scientific and medical advisors, not just here in Scotland but across the United Kingdom, I believe that all that complies with the advice of the World Health Organization, which is content with the approach that we are taking.

Of course, there is always more to learn, and we are very open to that learning, but that is the approach that we are taking now. We are doing that planning in order to help with the decisions that will come down the line about how we rebalance suppression and containment of the virus, so that our health service can cope with it, while we try to take greater steps towards normalisation of how we live our lives.

Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link

I specifically asked the health secretary whether she will immediately publish the advice that her advisors have given to her—or, indeed, whatever advice she has been given—on the WHO advice on testing, which we have not followed. Will she publish that advice?

Jeane Freeman SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport · Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

The advice of the scientific advisory group for emergencies is made public. I am quite happy to send Neil Findlay the name of the website where he can find it.

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

I thank all the cabinet secretaries and members for their participation this afternoon.

Parliament will resume at Holyrood at 2 pm on Tuesday 21 April. Until then, I thank you very much for joining us.

Meeting closed at 15:25.

  1. Members’ Virtual Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Covid-19 (Personal Protective Equipment) Questions · 3
  3. Covid-19 (Personal Protective Equipment) Questions · 2
  4. Covid-19 (Business Support) Questions · 2
  5. Covid-19 (Personal Protective Equipment) Questions · 2
  6. Covid-19 (Domestic Abuse) Questions · 2
  7. Covid-19 (Second Homes) Questions · 2
  8. Covid-19 (Personal Protective Equipment for Police Officers) Questions · 2
  9. Covid-19 (Shielded and Vulnerable People) Questions · 2
  10. Covid-19 (Business Support) Questions · 2
  11. Covid-19 (Investigation and Enforcement Powers) Questions · 2
  12. Covid-19 (Business Support) Questions · 2
  13. Covid-19 (Rent Issues) Questions · 2
  14. Covid-19 (Business Support) Questions · 2
  15. Covid-19 (Testing in Care Homes) Questions · 2
  16. Covid-19 (Bereavement Support) Questions · 2
  17. Covid-19 (Prisons) Questions · 2
  18. Covid-19 (Personal Protective Equipment) Questions · 2
  19. Covid-19 (Oil and Gas Sector) Questions · 2
  20. Covid-19 (Barnett Consequentials and Business Support) Questions · 5
  21. Covid-19 (Business Support) Questions · 2
  22. Covid-19 (Testing) Questions · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.