Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Education

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 30 January 2020 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con Eastwood
link

Yesterday, the Scottish Government demanded an urgent debate about which flags should be flown on the pavement outside this building. Will the First Minister support my demand for a statement next week on why her Government is failing to meet its own target to improve education in Scotland’s most deprived schools?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

It is for the Parliamentary Bureau to decide the business of Parliament, but I am very happy—[Interruption.] I am very happy for this Government to give statements on the work that we are doing to improve education.

The attainment fund points, at national level, to an improving system. For example, the gap between school leavers from the most and least deprived areas is narrowing, as we have covered many times before in the chamber. More young people are leaving school with highers, more are leaving with five highers and more are leaving with national 5 qualifications.

Yes, there is work to do, but we are getting on with that job. I am sure that the Deputy First Minister will always be happy to advise the chamber on that progress.

Jackson Carlaw Con Eastwood
link

I am pleased to have the First Minister’s support for a statement next week, and I am sure that the Parliamentary Bureau will have taken note of that.

However, this week, it has been all too clear what the First Minister’s priority really is—and it is not raising the standard of education in our schools. Her Government has set out a range of targets that need to be met to help close the attainment gap between pupils in our wealthiest and poorest communities. Those include targets that, by the end of this school year, 68 per cent of primary pupils from the most deprived areas should meet the required standards in literacy and 75 per cent should meet that standard for numeracy. On the basis of the most recent figures available, will those targets be met?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Our schools across the country, backed by education authorities in our local councils, are working with teachers to meet those targets. It is right that we set stretching, ambitious targets—and that is what we have done. I think that it is wrong to say that our schools are not working right now to meet those targets.

As I said in my original answer, if we look at the situation across the country, we have evidence already that points to the improvements in the system. If we look at the gap between those from the most and least-deprived communities, we see that it is narrowing.

We now have full-time attainment advisers in place in each local authority, working in a focused way with our schools to make sure that we meet the targets. Last December, we published the most comprehensive set of data and evidence on performance in education through the national improvement framework. We will continue to set out that detail, and we will be held to account on it.

I back our teachers to get on with the job of making the improvement that we are seeing across Scottish education.

Jackson Carlaw Con Eastwood
link

Well, that sure sounds like a First Minister getting in her excuses early. We all have a profound respect for the work done by our teachers, but it does the First Minister no credit to hide behind their hard work to mask her Government’s failures.

From analysis published this week, there is little cause for optimism. The University of Glasgow says that there needs to be a tenfold increase, in just one year, on the progress that has been seen in the past three years. Progress—where it exists at all—is taking place with nothing like the urgency required. There is next to no progress in closing the attainment gap in primary or secondary school when it comes to literacy and numeracy. Today we learn that, since the introduction of the Scottish National Party’s botched curriculum for excellence in 2015—[Interruption.]

Ken Macintosh The Presiding Officer · West Scotland
link

Order, please. Let us hear the question.

Jackson Carlaw Con Eastwood
link

We have learned today that the pass rate in 32 of the 46 Higher subjects has dropped, including in English, maths, chemistry and history. Is that progress? First Minister, is any of that in any way acceptable?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I will address all those points.

On the direction of travel in Scottish education, whether in exam passes—I will come back to that in a moment—or the narrowing of the attainment gap, if Jackson Carlaw does not want to take my word for it, I will quote the international council of education advisers. They said:

“Scotland is heading in the right direction and taking the right approach to improving education”.

That is what we will continue to do.

I turn to the pass rates that Jackson Carlaw talked about. As I have said repeatedly, overall, more young people now leave school with highers. Two thirds of young people get at least one, which compares with fewer than half when we took office. Thirty per cent get five or more highers, which compares with 22 per cent in 2009.

Let us look at the 32 subjects that Jackson Carlaw talked about. We have committed to publishing our analysis of the exam results, and it is absolutely right that we look at the reasons why exam pass rates are falling. I am not for a second suggesting that some of the subjects that I am about to talk about are not important; they are all very important. However, although classical studies, for example, is down, maths is up. Yes, drama is down, but physics and geography are up. If we look at the top 10 subjects in Scotland, most have exam pass rates that are up. Mathematics, chemistry, modern studies, physics, biology and geography pass rates are all up since 2015. I am not saying that we do not look at subjects for which the opposite is true—we are doing that—but the overall picture, as is so often the case, is not the one that Jackson Carlaw wants to present.

Jackson Carlaw Con Eastwood
link

That was lamentable. We are seeing a drop in the pass rates for 32 out of 46 higher subjects and I think that people are getting increasingly angry about the First Minister’s spin and denial of the failure of education under her Government. Being on course to miss all four of the Government’s own educational attainment targets is a definition of failure. It is as simple as that.

Primary and secondary, literacy and numeracy—those are four areas in which the SNP said that it would change things for good, but they are four areas in which the SNP is failing. There are record low scores in maths and science, missed targets on the attainment gap and, as we know today, falling pass rates in the vast majority of higher subjects.

First Minister, how many more times do we have to listen to the same lines and excuses about education being this Government’s number 1 priority, when the evidence shows that its record is one of unmitigated, continuing failure?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Jackson Carlaw has just described as lamentable the fact that, for the 10 top subjects in our education system—those for which there are the highest number of entries, as they are the ones that most pupils do—compared with 2015, which is what Jackson Carlaw is putting to me, the majority have pass rates that have improved. He might not think that that matters, but I will again talk about the subjects on which we are focusing. In maths, the pass rate is up since 2015, as it is in chemistry, modern studies, physics, biology and geography—two thirds of the top 10 subjects. That does not suit Jackson Carlaw’s argument, but that is the achievement of pupils and teachers around our country. That he might want to talk that down is what I think is disgraceful.

We will continue to make investment in and focus on where improvements are needed. I never shy away from saying that, but I will not stand here while Jackson Carlaw talks down education in Scotland in the way that he does.

  1. United Kingdom’s Exit from the European Union Questions · 4
  2. Queensferry Crossing (Traffic) Questions · 10
  3. Digital Economy (Post-Brexit) Questions · 4
  4. United Kingdom-European Union Talks Questions · 4
  5. Clare’s Law Questions · 8
  6. Rail Infrastructure (Highlands) Questions · 4
  7. Education First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Non-profit-distributing Model First Minister’s Questions · 13
  9. Property Factors First Minister’s Questions · 2
  10. Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation Statistics (Inverclyde) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. A83 Landslip First Minister’s Questions · 2
  12. Kilbowie Outdoor Centre First Minister’s Questions · 2
  13. Coatbridge Freightliner Terminal First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. Marches (Glasgow) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  15. Maternity Services (Moray) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Budget Proposal (Public Transport) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  17. National Health Service (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  18. European Arrest Warrant (Transition Period) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  19. NHS Highland First Minister’s Questions · 2
  20. Alcohol (Minimum Unit Pricing) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  21. Scottish Prison Service (Sickness Leave) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  22. Problem Gambling First Minister’s Questions · 5
  23. Public Works Loan Board Rate Members’ business · 12
  24. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  25. Social Isolation and Loneliness (Highland) Questions · 6
  26. Scottish Child Payment Questions · 6
  27. Vulnerable Older People Questions · 7
  28. Older and Disabled People (Access to Services) Questions · 4
  29. Older People Questions · 4
  30. Intergenerational Support Questions · 4
  31. Social Isolation (Rural Communities) Questions · 6
  32. Welfare Reform (Disabled People) Questions · 6
  33. European Union Exit Statement · 33
  34. Drugs and Alcohol Debate · 126
  35. Scottish Biometrics Commissioner Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 1
  36. Decision Time Decision time · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.