I say that it does. I am fairly well engaged with the AIB; whenever I have gone to the protected trust deeds team with something that I have come across, they have been incredibly helpful. However, there needs to be a system, because companies will not address the matter until it is raised with them.
The committee discussed fees last week, when Richard Dennis said that it is enough for the insolvency practitioner to provide evidence of a cost. I might be wrong, but that was my understanding of what he said. However, there is a requirement: the Insolvency Service report on the monitoring of RPBs said that
“Under SIP 9, IPs are ... required to explain how all their fees are fair and reasonable.”
Therefore, the standard is that fees should not have just happened but should be “fair and reasonable”.
I will give examples of typical fees. As far as I am aware, it is an on-going trust deed. There is a courier charge of £114, but there is no requirement in any rule that couriers need to be used to send paperwork relating to trust deeds. There is an anti-money-laundering check for £72, an identification verification for £48 and a personal payment insurance—PPI—search fee of £360, which was from a while back and would not apply now.
The credit union sector is subject to anti-money-laundering rules. We do not recognise the quoted costs of carrying out the necessary checks in relation to money laundering, in which the fees came to about £6,000, from about £7,000 that the individual was due to pay back through the trust deed.
I do not agree that it is good enough if a receipt is produced. There should be a judgment about why fees are applied in the first place. What third parties are companies using if they are unable to negotiate deals such as those that the credit union sector—which is not of their scale—can negotiate? We do our anti-money-laundering checks for a couple of pounds per case, but other companies are charging hundreds of pounds for one case. I do not understand that.