To ask the Scottish Government whether acquiring a gender recognition certificate gives a prisoner any new legal rights regarding the decisions that are made by the Scottish Prison Service about their accommodation. (S5O-04001)
Official Report · Chamber
Prisoner Accommodation (Gender Recognition Certificates)
Portfolio Question Time Justice and the Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Humza Yousaf SNP 3
- Johann Lamont Lab 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 1
The record
7 contributionsAcquiring a gender recognition certificate does not and will not give a prisoner any new legal rights regarding the decisions that are made by the Scottish Prison Service about their accommodation.
Decisions as to the most appropriate location to accommodate transgender people are made on an individualised basis after careful consideration of all relevant factors, including risk. Such decisions seek to protect the wellbeing and rights of the individual and the welfare and rights of others around them, including staff and inmates, in order to achieve an outcome that balances risk and promotes the safety of all.
No changes are planned to that part of the process as a consequence of the proposed reforms on how a person can obtain a gender recognition certificate.
The justice secretary might be aware of serious concerns among some people who have direct front-line experience of working with women prisoners about the implications of the proposals for changes in the gender recognition certificate process. Does he agree that women prisoners are among the most vulnerable women in our society? What reassurances can he give that a full assessment will be carried out of the impact of any changes to the rules on prisoner accommodation on women prisoners and their wellbeing? Is he willing to meet women who have direct experience of working with female prisoners, who will be able to underline the seriousness of the concerns, ahead of final decisions being made on the Scottish Government’s proposals?
These are, of course, sensitive matters. I appreciate that the debate is a live one, so we should stick to the facts.
I hope that I can reassure Johann Lamont and anybody else who has concerns—women on the front line and others—that proposed reforms to obtaining gender recognition certificates would not make a material difference to the existing process, because they do not give any additional rights in relation to the decisions that are made on transgender prisoners.
I again reassure Johann Lamont that a decision about where to accommodate a transgender prisoner is made based on the balance of risk and safety for inmates. A decision on a transgender woman wanting to move to a female prison involves consideration of the welfare of the female prisoners in that prison. Consequently, some such moves have been refused by the Scottish Prison Service because they would have caused risk to the physical or psychological wellbeing of female inmates.
This year, the SPS is reviewing the process and protocols that are in place for such situations. I have told the SPS that it should consult MSPs on the matter: Johann Lamont is welcome to contribute to that consultation.
I call Kenny Gibson. You will have to be brief, because that was a long answer.
link
I have been advised by a recently retired governor that there is at least one female prison in which anatomically male prisoners and female prisoners are expected to shower together. Can the cabinet secretary advise me whether that is the case? If it is, what will be done to remedy the situation?
I do not know the answer to that question, although it is the case that transgender women are in the female prison estate. As I said, some requests by transgender women to transfer to female prisons have been refused because of the risk that would be posed to women in them.
Of course, prisons have in place processes to protect women. I would be surprised if the situation is as Kenneth Gibson has suggested, but I will look into his concerns. As things stand, processes exist to ensure that we protect vulnerable women in the prison estate. That will not change, regardless of the gender reforms that the Government chooses to bring forward.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 16 Jan 2020 →- Alcohol and Drug Services (Evaluation) Questions · 8
- Foundation Apprenticeships Questions · 4
- Mesh-injured Women’s Fund Questions · 4
- Accident and Emergency Departments (Waiting Times) Questions · 4
- US Military Action in Iran (United Kingdom Involvement) Questions · 4
- Royal Hospital for Children and Young People Questions · 4
- First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Curriculum for Excellence Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Allan Marshall (Fatal Accident Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Trans Women in Prisons First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Penman Engineering (Administration) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Fatal Accident Inquiry (Milly Main) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Care Sector (Mistreatment of the Elderly) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Scottish Welfare Fund First Minister’s Questions · 2
- NHS Grampian (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Citizens’ Rights First Minister’s Questions · 5
- “Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland” First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Motor Neurone Disease (Drug Trial) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Proposed International Commission First Minister’s Questions · 2
- City Region Deals First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Independence Referendum First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Erasmus Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Wild Salmon Stocks First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Police Scotland (Compensation Payments) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Sustainable Development Goals Members’ business · 9
- Prisoner Accommodation (Gender Recognition Certificates) Questions · 7
- Women’s Community Integration Unit (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
- Prisoners (Early Release and Breach of Licence) Questions · 7
- Court Buildings (Crime) Questions · 5
- Sexual Offences Guidelines Questions · 4
- Inverness Justice Centre (Access and Communication Provisions) Questions · 7
- Parole (No-body Murder Cases) Questions · 5
- Police Scotland (Digital, Data and Information and Communications Technology Strategy) Questions · 4
- Disclosure (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 41
- Disclosure (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 1
- Direct Payments to Farmers (Legislative Continuity) Bill Bill debate · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.