Good morning, convener, and thank you for the invitation to come along today. As you will all be aware, the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018 contains a number of offences that may be committed by individuals or organisations. Section 75 allows the Scottish ministers to make regulations to facilitate the investigation of those offences. I will focus on those regulations today.
Social security is an investment in the people of Scotland and the Scottish Government is fully committed to ensuring that every client is treated with dignity, fairness and respect at all times. We start from the premise that everyone may be entitled to support. However, we have to accept that attempts will be made to defraud the Scottish social security system and we have a duty to protect public funds. That said, I know that fraud in social security is low. The latest Department for Work and Pensions figures show that the total estimated loss to fraud is £2.3 billion a year. That is 2.7 per cent of benefit expenditure, excluding pensions. Of that amount, £320 million, or 0.37 per cent, is related to fraud in disability and carer benefits. When you compare that with tax evasion, which Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs estimated to be £5.3 billion in 2017-18, you can see that it is a relatively small number of cases.
However, prevention is always better than cure. As outlined in its counter-fraud strategy, Social Security Scotland is focusing on the development of preventative controls to reduce opportunities for fraud to take place, but in cases where fraud may have occurred, we must be able to investigate, gather evidence and take action where appropriate. That is entirely consistent with the principles of respect for the dignity of individuals, efficiency and value for money laid down in the 2018 act.
The regulations are proportionate and necessary. They will allow Social Security Scotland to gather information—in the most efficient and least intrusive way possible—to differentiate between those who make a genuine error and those who seek to gain assistance to which they are not entitled. The gathering of information will always be undertaken by trained professionals with the appropriate skills. They will proceed with the presumption of innocence in all cases. I reiterate that—we have been very clear about this point throughout the development of the regulations—those making genuine mistakes will never be criminalised.
As part of the development of the regulations, the Scottish Government undertook a public consultation. Since then, we have worked closely with a range of stakeholders to understand the wide-ranging views that were raised. We have amended the regulations, where appropriate, following that feedback.
A number of respondents to the consultation noted concerns about the regulatory power to acquire information, including information held in electronic formats, and were concerned about the possible negative impacts that that could have on the relationship between welfare rights organisations and their clients. Although I want to be clear that the intention was never to do that or to otherwise inhibit individuals from seeking support, we have listened to those concerns and amended the regulations accordingly. They can be reassured that they will not be expected to provide any information shared between welfare rights organisations and individuals seeking their support.
A number of welfare rights organisations were concerned that the regulations would allow their premises to be searched against their will. Again, let me be clear that that is categorically not the case. When gathering evidence, Social Security Scotland must seek permission from the occupiers of any premises before entry and before any search can take place. It may not enter any dwelling house or any part of a premises used solely as living accommodation.
Some stakeholders were also concerned that, by protecting the relationship between themselves and their clients, they may unwittingly be in breach of the provision relating to the delay or obstruction of an investigation. The regulations now make it explicit that any delay or obstruction must be carried out deliberately for that to apply. That change, combined with the exemptions that I referred to earlier, should assuage any concerns in relation to unwittingly committing an offence.
Finally, I draw your attention to section 76 of the 2018 act, which requires the Scottish ministers to develop a code of practice for investigations. The code will lay out how the regulations will be used in practice and what individuals can expect if a fraud investigation takes place. As much of the code relates directly to the content of the regulations, it cannot be finalised until the regulations have been approved by the Parliament. However, I have provided a draft copy to the committee to provide a wider context of how the regulations will be used and to aid the committee in their scrutiny of the regulations.
I am happy to take questions. Thank you.