It is a really good question. A lot of work has been done in that arena. The steering group’s approach has been twofold. We have participated in the big international conference of the Basic Income Earth Network, which brings together people with an interest in basic income interventions, including academics. We have been interacting with the networks around that and we have had a lot of correspondence with others who want to learn from us, and vice versa. Through that, we have had a lot of contact with, for example, the people who ran the pilots in Finland and Ontario. I am using the royal “we”.
Wendy Hearty, who was unable to be with us today, is one of the authors of a large scoping review that was done with What Works Scotland and the University of Glasgow, which synthesises the literature from previous basic income experiments across the world and across time. I am sure that the committee is aware that there is a long history of such experiments, which goes back to work in Gary, Indiana and various other towns across the USA and the Alaskan experiment. There are also more recent experiments that are still to generate evidence, such in the Netherlands. I can run through some of the key learning that we have drawn from those experiments.
It is important to be clear about the aim of a basic income pilot. In the Finnish experiment, the aim was about helping people back into work, so the only eligible group comprised people who were on unemployment benefit. The basic income was not universal in the way that we are discussing in the Scottish work. It is important to be clear that different pilots and interventions across the world have different aims and scopes.
We are also keen to learn about the need to get a broad level of support across society for pilots. In a number of experiments, the learning has been lost because the experiments finished early. For example, in Ontario, there was a change of government and the experiment did not get finished, so a lot of the learning and research was lost. It is important that there is broad agreement about the undertaking of pilots and that they are seen through to the end so that the research can be completed.
There is a lot of learning on design. Some pilots have been undertaken at a local level, by municipalities rather than national governments, which has limited the scope to switch benefits on and off and change conditionality. Again, if that is one of the key aims of a pilot, it needs to have political implementation at the right level.
There has been a lot of learning on the impacts on particular groups. For example, there has been a lot of interest in whether people are more or less likely to withdraw from the labour market if they receive a basic income. We see from the evidence that, where that happens, the effect is small and it often involves those who want to stay on in education for longer and improve their skills. That has led to some interest about the potential for increased productivity in the future. Again, however, the extent to which we can generalise on that from pilots that took place 30 or 40 years ago might be limited, particularly if they were in a North American context.
The final thing that we need to learn is the importance of clear communications. In Finland, the global media descended on individuals and small communities where piloting was taking place, which created a lot of stress and pressure for the people who were taking part, and it might also have interfered with the true effects of the pilots. We would need to take care with all those factors, including media attention, if we were to go ahead with piloting in Scotland.
10:45