It is a fraught area, so I am slightly worried about getting into it. I have written a lot of books and papers about definitions, glossaries and what words we should use in the health sector, which have been widely accepted in the world of health and healthcare. However, it is a very difficult area.
First, as I am sure the committee is aware, the concept of race is highly contested. After the second world war, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization made a major statement that said that there is no such thing as race; there is only one human species, and it cannot be subdivided into different races. Many people put the word “race” into inverted commas in order to say that we are really talking not about biology or subspecies of humans—which is the way that the word “race” was used for so long—but about social relationships. If we all agree that we are talking about social relationships, it is fine to use the word “race”. However, many people are not talking about social relationships; they are talking about colour and all the classical views about race, as if there really were subgroups of human beings with different characteristics. It is a dangerous thing.
However, the reason why I believe that we cannot get away from race is because of racism, which is largely founded upon physical characteristics. I am a great believer in the concept of ethnicity, because it is a more malleable concept that puts a heavy emphasis on culture, traditions and ways of behaviour, but it does not completely ignore physical characteristics.
Like many, I am conscious that, when we start getting into discussions of definitions and terminology, entire meetings—indeed, whole series of meetings—can be taken up, and we end up where we started. I have been on committees that spent weeks agreeing a set of words and what they mean. However, for the next two years, the committee completely ignored all that work and just went back to its original viewpoints. A lot of time can be wasted.
On the other hand, we have to be conscious of the generally agreed definitions of those kind of words, and of what they mean in law. We are lucky here in the UK, because the House of Lords has provided us with a broad concept of race and racism in which virtually anything can be included. My friends and colleagues on the continent do not have such a broad understanding; indeed, in much of the continent of Europe, they will not even use the word “race”, as they are so unhappy with it and it makes them uncomfortable. Of course, they have the legacy of the second world war at hand in a way that we do not; we were slightly distanced from it.
These are fraught areas. I suggest that, if the Scottish Parliament wanted to, it could introduce a vocabulary that is used across the Scottish Government and its partners. Such a vocabulary would not be difficult to achieve. For example, the International Organization for Migration is just one of many international organisations that have set up a vocabulary. In 2018, we held the first world congress on migration, ethnicity, race and health in Edinburgh. We had 750 delegates from more than 50 countries, and we used resources from across the world to produce a glossary, which we thought was required to permit dialogue among people from more than 50 countries. I recommend that the Scottish Parliament should have a glossary—it could use other people’s glossaries to build its own—and should require its partners to use it.