Thank you, convener. I am pleased to join the committee to discuss the draft Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2019.
Providing care with safety, compassion and dignity should daily be central to every health and social care interaction that happens throughout Scotland. However, there are rare occasions on which those who provide care betray that position of trust.
Part 3 of the Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016 contains provisions to allow the criminal justice system to hold individuals and organisations to account when they are responsible for serious and deliberate neglect or ill treatment in the course of providing health and social care services.
It is important to understand that those offences are not about pursuing organisations or individuals when mistakes are made. The offences are designed to deal with situations in which someone has intentionally set out to neglect or mistreat a person or persons in their care.
There are two main offences in the 2016 act: an offence that applies to care workers, as set out in section 26, and an offence that applies to care providers, as set out in section 27. The offences are intended to provide a penalty for the worst types of behaviours, such as those of the individuals who were convicted for abuse at Winterbourne View care home in Gloucestershire, where vulnerable residents were subjected to cruel and callous behaviour by staff who were supposed to be caring for them.
It is important that there is access to justice for victims when a care worker has wilfully neglected or ill treated people. It is also important that the disclosure regime contains sufficient protections, so that people who have a legitimate interest—such as potential employers in the health and social care sector—can access the information that they need in order to understand the background of a care worker who has been convicted of something serious.
The 2016 act made amendments to the state disclosure regime under the Police Act 1997, which mmeans that a spent conviction for ill treatment or wilful neglect by a care worker must be disclosed on a higher-level disclosure certificate that is issued by Disclosure Scotland, unless a sheriff orders otherwise.
The draft instrument will make changes to the self-disclosure regime to provide an added layer of security. Its main effect will be that when a person is required to disclose their spent convictions in applying for certain trusted positions or roles—work as a medical practitioner or work in provision of a care service—they must divulge that they have a spent conviction for ill treatment or wilful neglect, under section 26 of the 2016 act. That will be the case unless they have applied successfully to a sheriff for the spent conviction to be taken off their higher-level disclosure certificate.
The draft order will also have the effect of ensuring, when no such successful application has been made, that it is permissible to dismiss or exclude a person from certain trusted offices, professions, occupations and employment because of their spent conviction for the offence, or their failure to disclose it. That means, for example, that when a person is applying for a position of trust in a health or social care organisation, the organisation will have access to information that it needs from the applicant in order to decide whether it would be appropriate to employ them, and it will be able to take that information into account.
I consider that the instrument strikes a balance between protecting the public from risk from people who might reoffend and allowing people who have made mistakes in the past to be rehabilitated and to make a contribution to society.
I am happy to answer the committee’s questions.