I thank the committee for inviting me to give evidence in support of the affirmative instruments that are needed to introduce the victim surcharge and the victim surcharge fund. First, I acknowledge that it has taken longer than anticipated to lay these instruments. The time taken has been necessary to ensure that the scheme is administratively efficient, legally competent and enforceable, and—important—that it will provide help to victims of crime at the point of need.
The work that was undertaken to get us to this point included seeking an order under the Scotland Act 1998 to enable recovery of the surcharge through a deduction from an offender’s benefits. The order came into force in July this year, enabling us to lay these regulations now. We also had to address an issue whereby the surcharge could potentially have been interpreted as a fine. If we had left that matter unresolved, it could have resulted in the imposition of the surcharge being challenged—for example, where there are maximum fines in place for specific offences.
We are committed to putting victims at the heart of our justice system and making sure that their voices are heard. Building on the positive measures that were introduced through the Victims and Witnesses (Scotland) Act 2014, we have delivered a range of initiatives to support victims and witnesses. For example, we introduced the Vulnerable Witnesses (Criminal Evidence) (Scotland) Act 2019, which ensures that more child witnesses are able to pre-record evidence ahead of jury trials. We have also set up a dedicated task force, as the committee knows, to listen to victims’ experiences, and we are investing in a new service to provide dedicated support for families that are bereaved by crime.
Over the past five years, we have invested more than £155 million to improve support for victims and their families and to provide compensation to victims who have sustained a criminal injury in Scotland. That includes funding for Victim Support Scotland’s victims fund, which provides practical support to victims in the aftermath of crime.
With regard to the victim surcharge, we know that experiencing crime can be an isolating and frightening experience, and it is only right that criminals should pay towards helping victims to recover and move on with their lives. The instruments before the committee today will enable that to happen. The victim surcharge will be imposed on individuals who are sentenced to pay a court fine. The amount of surcharge imposed will be proportionate to the value of the fine. The surcharge will be collected by the courts in the same way as fines and compensation orders are collected, and transferred to the Scottish Government to be banked in the victim surcharge fund. As set out in the regulations, no awards will be made from the fund until after 25 May 2020, in order to allow time for money to accumulate.
Victim support organisations will be able to apply to the Government for a share of the fund to cover the costs of providing short-term and practical support such as new windows and locks for victims of housebreaking or funeral expenses for families of murder victims.
This model, whereby the Government administers the fund, will ensure that victim support organisations can focus on doing what they do best—supporting victims of crime in communities across Scotland. The model also ensures that victims can access quick support at the point of need from those best placed to help them.
In terms of likely income from the surcharge, we estimate that around £100,000 could be collected within the first 12 months of the surcharge being in operation. That could reach a steady state of around £800,000 per year after four to five years of operation.
The regulations also state that we will prepare and publish guidance for applicants on the operation of the fund, which will cover topics such as assessment criteria for awards and what the fund can and cannot be used for. This has been shared with victim support organisations, to seek their feedback and to ensure that the application and award process is as efficient and effective as possible. That engagement will continue as we move towards finalising the document, which we will publish no later than May next year.
The support that will be provided through the victim surcharge fund will mean that victims and their families have one less thing to worry about at what is already a traumatic time. In supporting these regulations, the committee will ensure that the money raised through the surcharge can make a real difference to victims and their families. As always, I am happy to take questions.