Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2018/19 audit of Social Security Scotland”

Thursday 10 October 2019 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 10:00–10:30 Committee business 75 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

75 contributions
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 2 is the section 22 report on the 2018 audit of Social Security Scotland. I welcome our witnesses from Audit Scotland to the meeting. Caroline Gardner is the Auditor General for Scotland, Mark Taylor is audit director, Gemma Diamond is audit director, and Kirsty Ridd is a senior auditor in performance audit and best value. I understand that the Auditor General has an opening statement.

Caroline Gardner
link

Thank you, convener. I will be brief. The report brings to the committee’s attention the appointed auditor’s qualified opinion on the regularity of Social Security Scotland’s 2018-19 accounts. They are the first accounts for that new body. It is important to be clear from the outset that the auditor has given an unqualified opinion on the information that is reported in the agency’s financial statements, which means that he is content that they show a true and fair view, and follow all relevant accounting standards and rules.

The qualification relates specifically to the rules under which the agency’s carers allowance expenditure is incurred. The auditor has qualified his opinion on the regularity of carers allowance expenditure because there is not enough evidence to determine whether the expenditure was in line with the relevant legislation. Carers allowance is being delivered by the Department for Work and Pensions, on the Scottish Government’s behalf, through an agency agreement. That means that SSS relies on the DWP’s estimates of error and fraud, which have not been updated for more than 20 years. The case load of and expenditure on carers allowance have increased significantly in that time. The estimate is also calculated only at UK level and therefore does not reflect any Scotland-specific influences.

Due to those factors, the auditor concluded that the estimate of current levels of error and fraud in carers allowance in Scotland is not reliable. The agency is using different delivery methods to administer the carers allowance supplement, and the best start grant pregnancy and baby payments: those benefits are not affected by that regularity issue. It is, nonetheless, important for the agency to understand the underlying levels of error and fraud in the reserved benefits that affect people’s eligibility for Scottish benefits, and the impact of that on the Scottish system.

I have also reported on the agency’s wider approach and processes for managing error and fraud within the Scottish social security system. Those are critical in ensuring that people get the benefits to which they are entitled. The agency has established core processes and policies, but they are at an early stage of development and there is much more to be done. It will become increasingly important for the agency to have effective and well-understood arrangements for managing error and fraud as the range and scale of benefits that it is responsible for increase over the next few years. The value of expenditure will increase substantially, and the risk of error and fraud will increase as the agency takes on responsibility for benefits that are paid regularly and that involve complex determinations of eligibility.

As always, convener, we are happy to answer the committee’s questions.

10:15

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Auditor General. Colin Beattie will open questioning for the committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Auditor General, I would like clarification on the carers allowance expenditure. In paragraph 5 of your report, you say:

“The Comptroller and Auditor General of the National Audit Office has qualified the regularity opinion on the DWP’s accounts for the last 30 years due to the levels of error and fraud in them.”

I presume that you rely on the NAO to do the audit of the area of the carers allowance that is handled by the DWP.

Caroline Gardner
link

Sort of. We do our own audit of the accounts for Social Security Scotland. Within Social Security Scotland, there is a sum of a little more than £150 million for carers allowance this year. In order to reach an audit opinion on that, the independent auditor, Mark Taylor, who is sitting beside me, looks at the arrangements that Social Security Scotland has in place for estimating the levels of error and fraud. Estimates come directly from the DWP because of how that benefit is delivered, and we do no further work to look at how those estimates are being calculated. The estimate on the levels of errors and fraud for the carers allowance is 20 years out of date and because of the amount of change in the population and the expenditure on that benefit since then, the auditor concluded that it was not a reliable estimate in Social Security Scotland’s accounts. There is a relationship with the DWP and the NAO, but it is the auditor’s own determination, based on Social Security Scotland’s accounts.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Fair enough, but given the history of the NAO qualifying its opinion on this for the past 30 years because of the levels of error and fraud, is it likely that there will be a section 22 report from you every time?

Caroline Gardner
link

Not necessarily. Mark Taylor can talk you through why that is the case.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

There are essentially two models for paying benefits. There is the pre-existing UK model, which is based on underlying eligibility criteria. As we set out in the report, if individual payments are made to people who are not eligible, those are, in effect, irregular.

In the Scottish model, which applies to the best start grant pregnancy and baby payments and some of the other benefits that will come along afterwards, as set out in the legislation, the rules are that if a determination is made—in other words, if the agency decides that somebody is entitled to a payment—that payment has to be made. Therefore, the rules apply differently in those two circumstances.

In terms of what it will mean for us in the future, we have to work out what the mix of those two things is. That mix will be quite dynamic as benefit responsibilities transfer from the UK to Scotland and as the Scottish Government takes on responsibility for some of the benefit streams that the DWP will continue to process. We will have to make judgments about that.

The underlying issue for us is to bring to your attention the non-compliance with the rules, but irrespective of which of those two models apply, the agency needs to understand error and fraud and make sure that it is managing things appropriately. There is a technical qualification issue but, behind that, there is a set of issues about how well the agency can manage the error and fraud that is now in Scottish expenditure.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have explained the concerns about error and fraud, but paragraph 37 of your report says:

“To support ease of access, less stringent evidence requirements have been adopted by the agency”

such as not requiring the same documentation to evidence a person’s identity and residency as is required for other benefits, such as housing benefit, and accepting photocopies. Is that adequate?

Caroline Gardner
link

As we say in the report, in delivering the new social security system in Scotland, the Government has prioritised dignity, fairness and respect and people’s ease of access to the benefits that they are entitled to. That is a policy choice and we understand it. However, that approach has implications for how the agency goes about safeguarding public money. Both those things need to be managed and the agency needs to understand the impact of its decisions on the possibility of error and fraud and make sure that its safeguards and investigatory capacity are sufficient to recognise the inherent risks of error and fraud in a social security system that is prioritising access.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

If the DWP is seeing levels of error and fraud with more stringent requirements, will relaxing the requirements lead to higher levels of error and fraud?

Caroline Gardner
link

As Mark Taylor said, error and fraud is inherent in a social security system and any system has to balance people’s ability to access the money that they are entitled to with protecting public money.

The problem with the DWP’s estimate for the carers allowance, which is where we started this report, is that it is now 20 years out of date. That is why we concluded that we cannot rely on that in relation to the rules for Scottish benefits. The social security agency needs to rapidly develop its own approach to managing error and fraud and make sure that it has estimates that we can use in our audit work to come to a conclusion about regularity and the overall financial statements of the agency.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

To clarify, are you saying that the DWP’s estimates of error and fraud are based on 20-year-old data?

Caroline Gardner
link

For the carers allowance, yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Still on the question of security, your report indicates that the agency has not yet developed clear guidance on the meaning of “ordinarily resident”, which seems fairly basic. It is a core criterion for benefits. Is the agency making progress on that? It is fairly important.

Caroline Gardner
link

It is central to the determination of people’s entitlement. Gemma Diamond can expand on that.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Throughout the audit process, we had a range of conversations with the agency about residency. The main assumption that the agency uses for somebody being resident in Scotland is that they have a Scottish postcode. That is a sensible assumption to make. Particularly for the best start grant pregnancy and baby payments, it is important for the people who are applying and also those people within Social Security Scotland who are making those decisions to be clear about what entitlement means. There should be more guidance about what “ordinarily resident” means, rather than just an assumption being made about a postcode.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What progress is the agency making? What methods is it using to determine residency?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We made that recommendation in our 2018/19 annual audit report on Social Security Scotland. The agency has committed to taking that forward.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Let me just check in our annual audit plan.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

If it is such a critical criterion to have, I would hope that the agency would be doing it fairly quickly.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Ms Diamond, would you like to come back to us on that point?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Yes. Sorry, I am struggling to find that. Thank you.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Gemma Diamond said that the criterion for being “ordinarily resident” is your postcode. Just to clarify, does that mean that by having a postcode in Scotland, I am “ordinarily resident” for the purposes of claiming certain benefits? Is that right?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Yes, your postcode is the main way of assessing residency at the moment.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Sticking with the issue of error and fraud, you note in your section 22 report at paragraph 39:

“The agency does not yet have an approach to estimating error and fraud levels for the benefits it delivers”

or for those benefits that it will be delivering over the next few years. Do you have any sense of when that approach might be developed and, perhaps more crucially, will the agency have such an approach in place by the time that other benefits come on board, such as the Scottish child payment?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

As we set out in the report, in its first seven months, the agency has been putting the building blocks in place for its error and fraud team and it has plans for growth within that team. It has set out a number of strategies to date and it has started looking at its investigations code of practice, for example. It is looking at how best it can estimate error and fraud levels within the expenditure limit, and also how that relates to the existing error and fraud within the DWP system in the case of some of the qualifying benefits that people will be on. It will be developing its approach over the next year and we will be monitoring that throughout the audit process.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Just to pin that down, do you expect that approach to be crystallised over the next year?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We would certainly expect the agency to be further forward with that approach over the next year, yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Further forward? Gemma, come on. When will this be done? As Colin Beattie quite rightly points out, it is pretty crucial that we have an approach to error and fraud. When will the agency get this done, do you think?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We have not had a firm date from the agency on that. We will be monitoring the progress that it makes against that over the year.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

That is something that we can pursue, perhaps.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I have a couple of questions. One is about late payments of the carers allowance supplement. Your 2018/19 annual audit report on Social Security Scotland states that the most recent scan from the DWP in April 2019 showed that in both April 2018 and October 2018, there were people who should have received a payment but did not. Do we know the extent of late payments?

Caroline Gardner
link

I do not think that we can give you that information. You may want to follow that up with the agency.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

But it is significant enough to be noted as a concern in the annual audit report.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We know that all payments were made. Each month, it scans back to make sure that anybody who missed a payment receives one in the next payment month, so we have assurance that all payments were processed.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Great, that might be something that we can take away separately.

As you can probably guess, my other question is about the workforce. The report also states that there are 17 full-time equivalent officers in the error and fraud team and the plan is to ramp that up to 47 FTE officers by the end of March 2020 and to go up to 190 FTE staff when we have a fully functional agency. What skills and expertise will be required to fill those posts? Is that train in motion and is it realistic to expect that we will recruit those numbers and find those individuals?

Caroline Gardner
link

We are always talking about a snapshot at a point in time, but Gemma Diamond or Kirsty Ridd can give you a sense of the progress that the agency has made since 31 March.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

There are highly skilled people in post at the moment, who have a background in error and fraud and are qualified to do that work.

I cannot give you an exact figure in relation to where the agency is at the moment. That would be something to check with the agency, but we will be monitoring progress throughout the year and working out what any shortfall means if the agency cannot get the skills and capacity that it requires. Certainly it has not had the same issues in getting people into the agency as the Scottish Government programme for implementing the powers has had.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I have one last question. You mentioned that the people in post have a background in error and fraud. Have those people been taken from the DWP and moved over to the new agency? Is the agency looking at people who perhaps work in the banking sector in error and fraud and recruiting from there? Has there been a direct approach of trying to get people from college and university courses and so on skilled and trained up and into the agency?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

I do not have all the details on that. We know that people from a wide range of backgrounds are coming into the agency. There are people coming in from the DWP and other UK departments and from the retail sector. The agency is recruiting from a wide range of backgrounds, but I do not have the details on the error and fraud team.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Again, that is something that we can raise with the agency.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

The second of your key messages is about error and fraud. Given our earlier discussion, can you tell us something about the audit committee? Who is on it, and how are they doing? It is their first year, so are they really getting in and about things?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

In our overall assessment of the audit committee this year, we reported that it has provided a good level of scrutiny. There are four members of the audit committee—their names are in SSS’s accounts. They come from diverse backgrounds: professional audit, the civil service and the third sector, bringing the client perspective. We have reported that they have provided a good level of scrutiny in the first year.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Could you give us an example of what they have done to keep the organisation on its toes?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

We are content that some of the big issues that feature in the section 22 report and in our wider reporting have been very much the stuff of conversations in their meetings. For example, error and fraud have featured in discussion at the audit committee.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

To go back to an earlier question from Alex Neil, do you know who appoints them?

10:30

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

It is the same appointments process that is followed with all public appointments. To pick up on the detail, the process is managed by Social Security Scotland, which identifies the sort of people that it is looking for at that level, but it uses the wider appointments process to access those people.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

I do not have the financial statement in front of me. Are they on the same remuneration bands as the—

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

Yes. There is a standard remuneration package for non-executives across Government that uses the same bands. I also do not have the figures in front of me, but their remuneration would be very similar—it would be in the £5,000 to £10,000 range for the basic stipend of a non-executive.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Auditor General, I refer you to paragraphs 31 and 32 in your report, which deal with the system design for component parts in the software delivery. From memory, the cost of the social security transformation programme is about £300 million, and the information technology component is about £200 million—it is a substantial amount of the entire transformation cost. At our last meeting on the subject, I think that we were told that all the IT systems were on track. There is a reference in your report to the agency identifying

“some operational weaknesses in its core case management system which raised the risk of error and fraud”,

and some manual processes have been adopted in the meantime. Could you give us a flavour of what is going on and whether there are any further concerns, other than what you have said?

Caroline Gardner
link

I will ask Gemma Diamond to give you a bit more detail. I will preface it by saying that we do not want to say too much in a public setting about the weaknesses that have been identified. Gemma Diamond can give you a sense of where that fits into IT development.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Those weaknesses were picked up by management and additional manual controls have been put in place to mitigate them. This has been rehearsed with the committee in previous meetings, but we know that the system design is being built incrementally and is prioritising safe and secure delivery. That means that decisions about priorities are based on what makes a deliverable product.

In our section 23 report earlier in the year, we recognised that the agency needs to have more prominence in the decisions about what should be a priority in the initial system design. What we are seeing is an example of that, in that greater priority needs to be given to some of the operational controls within the system for the initial service design. Those design fixes mean going back into the system so that the system will be improved for those areas, and manual controls will be put in place until it is improved. However, with greater agency involvement in some of those decisions, we hope that some of the operational weaknesses will be fixed in the initial service design.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I know that you cannot go into too much detail on the subject, but I would like to know whether the software that is being developed is robust enough to manage potential situations. Is there any indication that the weaknesses are being fixed soon, or will there always be a manual element to such spot checking? Are we completely relying on the software to pick up potential problems, or will there always be a manual process that sits on top?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Some of the weaknesses were around areas such as audit trails and system alerts for duplicate payments. The manual controls can mitigate an element of that, but obviously a system control is more efficient and effective. It would be appropriate to ask the agency where it is now with fixing the weaknesses in the system. That is certainly something that we will pick up through the audit process over the next year and into the system design for future benefits.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Are you keeping track of the software development components that are to be delivered for the entire project? Who is keeping track of the pace of that work for us—and for you?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We look at that issue throughout the year. There was a section 23 report earlier this year, and we are following that up in future performance audit work.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I would like to ask about the financial plan. The Auditor General said that the agency has no long-term financial plan in place. Given how much money it will be spending, that is quite worrying. Can you say a bit more about that, please?

Caroline Gardner
link

I will ask Mark Taylor to pick that up. It is covered in more detail in the annual audit report, so Mark can you give more of a flavour of that.

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

We recognise that the agency is a new body, and planning for finances and the workforce is one of the fundamental challenges facing it as it grows through time. There is a clear read-across from that to the previous discussions that we have had with the committee about where Government is, in the round, on the way in which planning works and the approach that has been taken to incremental planning. We have been clear in our view that there is a need for more transparency around the overall cost and the detail around some of those plans. That then translates into that challenge for the agency.

We have reported locally to the agency, which, as it understands what is in store for it and engages in that process, recognises that there is a need for it to build that into its own plans. There is absolutely a need for improved planning and improved insight as to when resources are required, when recruitment needs to happen and when the agency needs to put things in place. It is really about recognising the interplay between what the agency can do and what Government can do, but in the round there is a need to improve in that area.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Given the extent of Social Security Scotland’s spending, when would you expect it, as a new agency, to have that long-term financial plan in place?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

As we enter next year’s audit, we will be looking to see development around that. If there is no plan that we can point to, we will be raising that as a concern in the next annual audit.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So during your audit next year, you will look for the plan to be in development. When do you expect it to be complete?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

We would highlight it as a concern if it was not completed in the next year.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So, a year from now—thank you.

We know that there has been a bit of restructuring in the leadership team. I think that the chief executive has brought in three new senior people to support him. For a long time, the committee has been concerned about, and has discussed, leadership and leadership teams. Are you confident that this leadership restructure is the right thing to do and that the team has sufficient skills to get the right people in place?

Mark Taylor Audit Scotland
link

We understand what the agency is trying to do, which is to skill up as it grows. We understand the need for that. I do not think that we are in a position to provide a view on the competency of the leadership. Through our audit, we identify concerns and how well the organisation is being run, and we capture that across the range of our reporting. We have no specific concerns about that at the moment. Looking ahead, the picture is increasingly challenging and we will keep a close eye on how the agency is performing in relation to those challenges.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do members have any further questions or comments on the report?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Following on from my earlier comments, I have a question about the DWP estimates for error and fraud. Paragraph 22 looks at error and fraud levels in the best start grant qualifying benefits, which range from 3.9 to 8.6 per cent—I presume that it depends on which benefit you are talking about. The carers allowance is 5.5 per cent. The figures seem awfully high as a percentage of an awful lot of money.

Caroline Gardner
link

They are relatively high. As we have said a couple of times, there is an inherent risk of both error and fraud in a system that pays out sums of money to individuals. That risk increases with the scale of the benefit—the amount of money involved—the complexity of the determination of whether someone is eligible or not and how frequently the payments are made. People’s circumstances may change between payments that are made monthly, whereas a one-off payment is less prone to that. The agency needs to understand such factors for itself in relation to the Scottish benefits and to make sure that it matches whatever decisions it takes about benefits, how they are delivered and how eligibility is assessed with the checks and balances that it needs to have in place to make sure that while people get what they are entitled to, public money is also protected. That is why this matters.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The estimates are based on 20-year-old data.

Caroline Gardner
link

For carers allowance only.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay—for carers allowance only. However, 5.5 per cent is millions of pounds as far as Scotland is concerned. I am surprised that the figure is so high. I would have thought that it would have been a fraction of one per cent.

Caroline Gardner
link

I am not sure that, at this stage, there is very much that we can add to what you have said. As you said earlier, the DWP’s accounts have been qualified for 30 years. None of us wants Social Security Scotland to be in that position. More important, we want public money to be protected and people to get what they are entitled to. That is why the approach to fraud and error is so important at this point in the system’s development.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you all very much indeed for your evidence. I now close the public part of the meeting.

10:40 Meeting continued in private until 11:19.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 184
  3. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 75

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.