Thank you, convener. I will make a brief opening statement.
The report provides a summary of the circumstances surrounding Highlands and Islands Enterprise’s establishment of a subsidiary company—Cairngorm Mountain (Scotland) Ltd, or CMSL—to take over the operation of the Cairn Gorm mountain ski resort. I intend to prepare a more detailed report on HIE’s management of the ski resort, including the funicular railway, in spring 2020.
The Cairngorms mountain range is an environmental and economic asset for Scotland, and it plays a key role in underpinning the local tourism industry and the economy. HIE, which is the long-term owner and custodian of Cairn Gorm mountain, began the construction of a funicular railway to serve the ski resort in 1999.
I apologise for the number of acronyms that crop up in the report and that will crop up as I talk. I am happy to clarify what I can.
Cairngorm Mountain Ltd—or CML—assumed operation of the funicular railway in 2001 under a lease agreement with HIE. However, CML experienced financial losses, and HIE took CML into public control back in 2008 to keep the resort open. It transferred ownership to Natural Assets Investments Ltd—or NAIL—in June 2014 following a competitive dialogue procurement process.
In September 2018, CML took the funicular railway out of service because of safety concerns. In October 2018, it requested a working capital loan of up to £1.8 million from HIE in order to ensure the continuation of winter sports activities while the funicular was closed. HIE’s board rejected the request because of concerns about CML’s ability to repay the loan and because NAIL did not offer any security for the possibility of CML defaulting. CML subsequently went into administration, and HIE established CMSL in December 2018 to take over the operation of the ski resort.
HIE’s 2018-19 financial statements make a number of references to CMSL, including an accounting provision of £9.6 million to reflect its obligation to repair the funicular.
HIE continues to develop proposals for the future operation of the funicular. That has involved in-house teams and consultancy support to consider options. The likely cost of bringing the funicular back to full working order and the development of a business strategy that will provide for the long-term sustainability of the resort are key issues. HIE intends to repair and reopen the funicular, but it is still not clear how much it will cost to do so, how that will be afforded, and what impact that will have on HIE’s financial position. That is likely to require some tough decisions to be made over the coming months.
As members know, those events and the future of the Cairngorm funicular railway have generated significant public and media interest. It is important that HIE can demonstrate that its decision to transfer CML to NAIL was robust, that it managed its relationship with CML well, and that its decision making in the run-up to the company’s administration was well founded. That will be the subject of my fuller performance report next year.
We will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.