Mr Lyle raises some really important issues, although I would not want to suggest in any way, shape or form that they have not been confronted before.
We are trying to address the long-term investment needs of the fleet. As I said to Mr Finnie, I am very conscious of the impact on his and other members’ constituents of the disruption that is caused by unexpected maintenance issues on vessels. They are working hard and many of them have been in service for many years. That is not unusual, and there has always been a replacement cycle for vessels, but with the road-equivalent tariff and other measures being implemented, the demands on the ferry fleet are probably greater than they have been at any time in their history. The assets are being worked hard, which is a good thing because they are providing good services for communities, but it means that we have to look to replace and renew the fleet as we proceed.
We are concerned to ensure that we address the concerns of local communities, particularly those in the islands, who depend on them for lifeline services, and they are set to benefit from the deployment of the two new vessels that we have discussed. We share the frustrations about the delays, which members have mentioned. CMAL continues to search the second-hand market to see whether there are appropriate vessels that we can bring into service. So far, that has been challenging, because vessels in many theatres of operation are inappropriate for the waters that we have. They may have the wrong centre of gravity for the wave environment that they would face, or the depth of water. The shallow draft that we need for some of our ports and harbours is a challenge, too.
In the vessel replacement and deployment plan and the ferries plan, we are looking at how we can standardise vessel design to address the cost of vessel fabrication. In general, the first of class loses a yard money and the yard subsequently makes money in building the second, third, fourth and successive vessels. That is challenging if we procure vessels on a bespoke basis for bespoke routes, so we are looking seriously at how we can perhaps standardise vessel design. That might mean investment in ports and harbours and dredging to ensure that we have interoperability of vessels and, when one goes out of service, another can take its place and provide the same service on that route.
CMAL is engaging closely with the operator, CalMac, and working with officials in Transport Scotland and CalMac to develop a programme for major and small vessels with the aim of achieving that increased standardisation, although that also has to take account of the many and varied CalMac routes that are served.
As always, we look to learn from previous ferry designs and apply that experience to new vessel projects, such as the forthcoming Islay vessel. The design for that, which is under way, is likely to be based closely on the Finlaggan, which is already in service, to minimise reinventing the wheel. We will engage with stakeholders to try to come up with vessels that are more resilient for the Gourock to Dunoon route, and we will consult with communities, trade unions and the operators in doing that.
We are trying to refresh the approach that we take, but it is worth noting that the ferries that we deploy need to be appropriate for the conditions in which they operate.