Thank you, convener. We are very grateful for the opportunity to come and give evidence to the committee this morning. DAS is something that we can all be proud of, and you will know that the rest of the United Kingdom is trying to copy it. However, three main concerns are consistently raised with us about it. First, not nearly enough people benefit from the scheme. Secondly, it can be confusing for the debtor to know whom to turn to between us as the regulator, their money adviser and the payment distributor. Thirdly, the current fee system means that how long it takes a person to clear their debts, how much they pay and how much their creditors receive differs depending on who their money adviser and payment distributor are.
The draft regulations target those issues. They have been in preparation for more than two years, with three public consultations. All elements received overwhelming support in the consultation that closed earlier this year and at our annual round of stakeholder events, held in May.
Our first target is to drive up capacity. You might be surprised to learn that Fife and Moray generate far more DAS cases per head than Glasgow. That is surprising, until you look at the number of advisers offering DAS in those areas.
You will have heard last week about the pressures facing the free debt advice sector. Any large increase in provision relies, at least to some extent, on expanding the involvement of the fee-charging sector. One in four of the current DAS case loads is administered by private firms; the figure rises to one in three if you look at cases that have started this year. Those firms charge for their services through a mixture of an up-front fee and a percentage of the monthly payments that are made by the client. On average, that adds around 15 per cent to the payment towards debt, but sometimes the amount can be much higher. In a Glasgow case from a couple of months ago, those fees meant that the client would be making repayments for an extra 77 months.
Draft regulation 4 removes the right for firms to charge any such fees. In the future, clients who enter a DAS could focus on the debt payments. There would be no fees and charges from their adviser alongside the existing protections that stop their creditors adding interest or charges. That would be the same regardless of whether the adviser came from the free or the paid sector.
Removing a source of income is not a good way of encouraging private firms to offer the scheme unless we take other action. Regulation 4 also increases the fee within the DAS to 20 per cent, and brings new opportunities for anyone with the right licences to deliver payment distribution. The 20 per cent—which I know the committee questioned last week—is set at a level that matches the current average adviser fee of 15 per cent, which I have spoken about, and the current average payment distribution fee of between 5 and 6 per cent. That moves the cost of providing both the advice and the on-going service from the debtor to the creditor. From looking at cases from the past three months, we can see that, on average, those who entered a DAS with a private provider would have been debt free at least a year earlier.
Regulation 4 also allows for all organisations that wish to be both a money adviser and a payment distributor to be so, so that most clients will in the future have a single point of contact throughout the life of their plan.
Finally, regulation 4 introduces the power for my agency to act as a payment distributor of last resort to ensure that, if a provider falls over, there is someone who can step in and look after the client to ensure that their plan keeps going.
There are other benefits to the changes. We understand that one of the big constraints in the free sector is that it often takes around six weeks to get an initial face-to-face appointment. That must partly explain why clients still go to private firms and agree to pay fees although they could otherwise get the same product for free from their local citizens advice bureau. Clients who currently choose the free sector because they cannot afford up-front fees will have the choice of going to other firms, because there will no longer be any up-front fees.
By providing a level playing field in that way, there is scope to have the free and private sectors working together and each doing what they are best at without the client facing any difference in fees, whichever route they go down.
Regulation 4 delivers a single point of contact throughout the payment plan. It tackles fees by making them the same, regardless of who the adviser is, and creates the scope for new players to come into the market. It puts the interests of the person in debt front and centre, and it means that more people should be able to access debt relief, more people will be able to get access to the debt payment arrangement scheme, and more people will pay off their debts quicker.
I can expand on any of those points or answer questions on any of the other issues that were raised with the committee last week. The convener asked me to keep my opening remarks brief, so I will stop there, unless members want me to go on to explain the link between regulation 4 and the discussion about funding for the free sector, on which the witnesses who gave evidence last week concentrated.