To start with, you are absolutely right about the foundations. In this case, as in other cases that I have reported on, the foundations were not there. I say in paragraphs 7 to 9 that there was no clear business case that set out what the SPPA wanted to achieve, the scope, the likely costs, the governance arrangements and so on.
There was a paper for the senior management team in September 2014 that outlined three options. There was the option that it went for—the highest risk one—of a fully integrated, bespoke system; the option of separate solutions for pensions administration and member services; and the option of separate systems for all the things that the SPPA wanted to do. That paper set out the advantages and disadvantages of each option, but it did not go through a proper options appraisal, which we would expect to see, and I imagine that you would as well. The paper was not presented to the management advisory board for consideration. Like you, my sense is that people were making decisions without fully understanding what they were signing up for and what risks were involved.
As we said at the beginning of this session, there were significant changes at both the chief executive level and the senior responsible officer level, which made it harder to keep the oversight and challenge of what was going on. When alarm bells were sounded, for example around the procurement process and the abnormally low bid from Capita, those warnings were not acted on, and that carried on all the way through.
As we explained to Mr Beattie, the chief executive at that point was on the management advisory board, the senior management team and the programme board. That is important because it meant that there was not the degree of distance and separation that we might expect, which would have made it easier to challenge what was happening. It was not until the new chief executive came along, took a step back and looked at the progress—or lack of it—that decisive action was taken.
I cannot comment on the reasons for Capita’s inability to deliver on what it promised, beyond what we know about the abnormally low tender. However, the fact that the settlement that was reached with it after the legal process included a payment of £700,000 from Capita to the agency tells me that there was some admission of liability in there.