Good morning and welcome to the 15th meeting in 2019 of the Health and Sport Committee. We have received apologies from David Stewart MSP—Anas Sarwar MSP is attending the meeting as his substitute—and Miles Briggs MSP. I ask everyone in the room to please ensure that mobile phones are switched off or to silent mode and are not used for photography or recording.
Agenda item 1 is consideration of the proposed draft Scottish Public Services Ombudsman (Healthcare Whistleblowing) Order 2019, which is subject to the super-affirmative procedure. That means that an additional stage of scrutiny—today—is required in which Parliament considers a proposal for a statutory instrument before the instrument is formally laid. The procedure is used for instruments that require a particularly high level of scrutiny.
We invited John Sturrock QC, Sir Robert Francis and a representative from Unison to give evidence today, but they were all unable to attend, for various reasons. However, I am delighted that we are joined by Rosemary Agnew, the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman; Rhona Atkinson, non-executive director, vice chair and whistleblowing champion at NHS Grampian; Alison Mitchell, non-executive board member and whistleblowing champion at NHS Lothian; and Bob Matheson, the head of advice and advocacy at Protect, the whistleblowing charity.
We will move directly to questions. I encourage colleagues to indicate to me when they wish to ask about any aspects that are raised in the evidence. I look forward to hearing what the witnesses have to say.
Clearly, it is important that we get the draft order right. Although it has been understood for some time that the independent national whistleblowing officer would be located within the purview of the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman, it was not as widely anticipated that the two roles would be held by the same person. What are the witnesses’ views of the draft order and of the benefits or disbenefits of the two roles being carried out by the same person?

