To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to ensure that the primary school system is fit for purpose. (S5O-03273)
Official Report · Chamber
Primary Schools
Portfolio Question Time Education and Skills
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 3
- Michelle Ballantyne Con 2
- Iain Gray Lab 1
The record
6 contributions
Our national improvement framework for education contains a wide range of actions to ensure that children leave primary school with the knowledge, skills, attributes and capabilities that are necessary for their next phase of learning. That includes our investment in leadership and professional learning for primary teachers, robust arrangements for inspection and improvement, support for regional improvement collaboratives, investment in the primary school estate and our continued support for Scottish national standardised assessments in the primary sector.
Last September, the Parliament voted by 63 to 61 to halt Scottish national standardised assessments for primary 1 pupils. As a result, an independent review of P1 testing is due to report this month. Is the cabinet secretary committed to implementing that review’s findings? Can the parents of children who are due to start P1 in August expect the evidence-based approach that he promised last October?
I am committed to implementing the review’s conclusions. As Michelle Ballantyne knows, we said that we would listen carefully first to the P1 practitioner forum that I established, which set out a number of recommendations that we are taking forward for implementation.
I expect to receive the report of the independent review of P1 assessments from David Reedy shortly. The Government will reflect carefully on the evidence that that demonstrates. As I have maintained throughout the discussion in which Parliament has been involved, I am interested in the evidence, which I will follow.
Figures that the Government released last week in response to a freedom of information request show that almost 80 per cent of the SNSA tests that primary 1 pupils sat were conducted in a single month—March. Surely that makes a mockery of the cabinet secretary’s claim that the tests are diagnostic and should be taken when the teacher believes that they are right for the child, does it not?
It does not, because the assessment period that Mr Gray referred to is not the only period in which the assessments are carried out. He cited information about a limited time; I would expect further assessments to have been carried out throughout April, May and June. We will judge the assessments’ effectiveness in making an impact on teacher judgment, and in enabling teachers to undertake the diagnostic assessment that is essential in all the analysis, which will ensure that we support young people by enhancing and developing their learning.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 21 May 2019 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Air Pollution (Childhood Cancers) Questions · 14
- ScotRail (Compensation for Delays and Cancellations) Questions · 15
- Government Business and Constitutional Relations Questions · 1
- Glasgow City Council (Funding for No-deal Brexit) Questions · 4
- Glasgow City Council (No-deal Brexit Resilience Planning) Questions · 9
- European Union Law (No-regression Principle) Questions · 8
- Brexit (Immigration Discussions) Questions · 4
- International Treaties (Devolved Matters) Questions · 5
- Citizens Assemblies (National Governance) Questions · 4
- Citizens Assembly (Costs) Questions · 4
- Heritage Celebration (Support) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh International Festival (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Tourism (European Union Countries) Questions · 4
- Dance School of Scotland (Musical Theatre Course Showcase 2019) Questions · 4
- Tourism (Impact of Ending Freedom of Movement) Questions · 8
- Tourism and Culture (Resources) Questions · 4
- Waverley Paddle Steamer Questions · 7
- Construction Apprenticeships (Access to Funding) Questions · 4
- Primary Schools Questions · 6
- Teachers’ Mental Health Questions · 4
- Support for Youth Employment (Almond Valley) Questions · 4
- Additional Support Needs (Co-ordinated Support Plans) Questions · 4
- Skills Development Scotland Employability Fund (Stage 4 Qualifications) Questions · 5
- Colleges (Support) Questions · 7
- Menopause Debate · 34
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
- International Museum Day 2019 Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.