Thank you. The report before the committee today is the latest examination of how the Scottish Government is implementing the new powers arising from the 2012 and 2016 Scotland Acts. Focusing on the social security powers that are being devolved, the report assesses progress up to the end of February, takes account of the activity that is under way and provides an update since I last reported in March 2018.
The Government has done well to deliver the commitments that it made for last year, including launching a new agency, Social Security Scotland, which will be responsible for delivery of the benefits once they are devolved. The agency, which became operational in September 2018, employs more than 320 staff so far.
The Government has also put in place the necessary systems and processes to allow it to launch the first two benefits: the carers allowance supplement, which was launched last September; and the pregnancy and baby payment of the best start grant, which was launched in December. The social security programme has laid the foundations to support the delivery of future benefits and to promote its aims of fairness, dignity and respect, and the publication of the first social security charter and the establishment of the Scottish Commission on Social Security are important parts of that.
Against that background, however, delivering the first benefits has been harder than expected. The programme has been working flat out, and the scale and complexity of the work involved have become clearer as teams plan for the delivery of individual benefits. The programme has continued to find it hard to recruit the range of skills and experience that it needs, and that has put pressure on staff and led to a greater-than-expected reliance on temporary and contractor staff.
Although the programme’s financial reporting has improved, it still focuses on spending against annual budgets, and it does not clearly monitor or report how much it will cost to fully implement all the benefits.
Delivering the second wave of benefits will be a significant challenge. Wave 2 includes the most complex and highest-risk benefits, with larger caseloads, much more complex eligibility assessments and regular payments affecting people’s day-to-day incomes. A wide range of work is under way to prepare for the next stage of delivery, including a revision of the overarching business case, a review of the governance and planning processes, and work to put in place the necessary resources, particularly staff. The programme is doing the right things, but there is a risk that the pace of work and constant delivery pressures might not allow the team the time and space to make changes quickly enough.
Critically, the Scottish Government does not yet have a clear understanding of the key things that it needs to do to deliver all the remaining benefits in the way that it intends, and my report highlights the need for the Government to develop its critical path of the actions that are needed, including a clear estimate of the overall cost to implement the social security system that reflects the decisions and commitments that have already been made.
As always, we are happy to answer the committee’s questions.