Marking national numeracy day yesterday, the Deputy First Minister declared that all of us need to have a good grasp of numeracy. I agree. Can the First Minister tell us how much numeracy attainment has improved or declined in our schools since she took office?
Official Report · Chamber
Numeracy Attainment
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ruth Davidson Con 5
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 5
The record
10 contributionsI pay tribute to national numeracy initiatives. I think that the Deputy First Minister managed to spell numeracy correctly when he promoted it this week; the United Kingdom skills minister managed to refer to “national numberacy week”.
That aside, we see improving attainment across our schools. For example, we see an increasing intake in STEM subjects—science, technology, engineering and mathematics—generally. I am more than happy to provide the specific numbers on maths for Ruth Davidson later, but I do not have them to hand right now. Across the range of subjects in our schools, we are seeing attainment rising, and we are, of course, also seeing the attainment gap closing. We want to continue that progress in the months ahead.
I thank the First Minister for that answer, but she will not be able to send me the specific numbers later, because she cannot give specific numbers. That is because the Deputy First Minister cancelled the only national survey on numeracy standards that we had, which previously allowed us to see how things were going. That means that, as this Parliament’s Education and Skills Committee declared,
“no meaningful conclusions on upward or downward trends can be reached, at a time of reform within Scottish education.”
The Deputy First Minister told us this week that it is important to have a good grasp of numeracy standards, yet, under this SNP Government, we have no grasp of how those standards are faring. Does that strike the First Minister as acceptable?
If that were true, it would not be acceptable, but it is not true. Under the achievement of curriculum for excellence levels data, which replaced the Scottish survey of literacy and numeracy, we provide more data at all levels of the system than we have ever provided before—crucially, to underpin improvement.
The problem with the Scottish survey of literacy and numeracy was that it did not provide data at school or local authority level. Ruth Davidson does not have to take my word for that. In its review of education in Scotland in 2015, this is what the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development said about that sample approach:
“The light sampling of literacy and numeracy at the national level has not provided sufficient evidence for ... use in ... evaluative activities or for national agencies to identify ... areas of strength.”
That survey was not providing the information that we needed, which is why we have replaced it with the achievement of CFE levels data, which provides that information not just at a national level but at school and local authority levels. I would have thought that that is exactly the kind of progress and improvement that Ruth Davidson might welcome.
The OECD said to improve SSLN; it did not say to cancel it.
It is clear from the First Minister’s answers that she has not actually read what the Education and Skills Committee had to say. The problem is that the new assessments, which we support at primary 4, primary 7 and secondary 3, are not comparable—[Interruption.] SNP members should listen. They are not comparable, they cannot show a trend, there is no baseline and they will take time to bed in. In the meantime, we have no idea whether standards in literacy and numeracy are rising or falling.
The committee was explicit about the fact that there is a five-year gap in our knowledge because of the actions of this SNP Government, and it is worried that we are losing the data that we need for Parliament and wider society to hold
“the Government to account for its performance on education”.
I share the committee’s concerns. Does the First Minister not share them, too?
We always pay attention to what committees of this Parliament say, and we will continue to do that.
I will pick up on something that Ruth Davidson said about assessments in primary schools. She said, very carefully, that the Tories support them at P4 and P7—of course, omitting to say that, in their manifesto for the 2016 election, they supported them at P1 as well. That is just another example of Ruth Davidson’s now legendary flip-flopping on every conceivable issue. There are no policies in the Tories, and there is not an iota of principle under Ruth Davidson either.
CFE levels data, of course, provides a trend. The information is published at school and local authority level each and every year, allowing people to look at the trend data, at improvements when they are being made and at whether there are any issues that require to be addressed. That is important progress. Ruth Davidson says that the OECD said that it wanted improvement, and we have provided that improvement to deal with the deficiencies in the survey of literacy and numeracy. There is now more data about pupil performance in our schools than ever before.
Later this year, we will also get the latest iteration of the programme for international student assessment—PISA—study. There is more information about schools’ performance than ever before, all of which—crucially—shows that we are making progress in raising attainment and closing the attainment gap, which is maybe what Ruth Davidson is a bit disappointed about.
What the First Minister does not get is that the mum of a seven-year-old now will not know whether this country is getting any better at teaching maths until her child is a teenager. [Interruption.] It is true. The reason for that is that the old national survey—[Interruption.] Members might want to listen to this. The old national survey showed that standards were declining, for which this SNP Government got the blame, and then it cancelled the survey. That is what happened, and it has left parents without any idea as to whether standards are going up or down.
Here are the figures that we do know about Scottish schools and numeracy. We have lost more than 400 maths teachers since the SNP took office, the number of vacancies has gone up in the past two years and, the last time that we measured numeracy in our schools, we found that Scottish education had gone backwards under this Government.
I think that parents deserve to know what is happening in our schools. Why has the First Minister left them in the dark?
I, too, think that parents deserve to know what is happening in their children’s schools, which is why we now publish the data at school level. Maybe Ruth Davidson should look into this just a little bit more closely. The reality is that, under the survey of literacy and numeracy, a parent had no idea what was happening in their child’s school, because that survey did not produce any data at school level. A parent therefore had no idea whether their child’s school was doing well or badly. The difference in the data that we publish now is that it provides data not just at national and local authority level, but at individual school level. Parents now have much more of an idea of how their child’s school is doing than they have ever had before.
Is it going up or down?
Ruth Davidson asks whether it is going up or down. Attainment in our schools is improving and the attainment gap is closing. Those are the facts, which Ruth Davidson does not like.
There are more teachers in our schools now than there have been at any time since 2010. There are more primary school teachers in our schools now than there have been at any time since I was at primary school. That is the reality of the progress in our education system. It is no wonder that Ruth Davidson is so furious about it.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 May 2019 →- Fife Ethylene Plant (Reports) Questions · 11
- Adult Mental Health Services (Tayside) Questions · 4
- Social Work Services (Funding) Questions · 4
- Planning (Local Decision Making) Questions · 8
- First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Housing and Property Chamber Questions · 5
- Sauchiehall Street (Glasgow School of Art Fire) Questions · 8
- Numeracy Attainment First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Mental Health Services First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Vale of Leven Hospital (Out-of-hours Service) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Mohammad Zahir Zazai (Visa) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Child Poverty Levels First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Climate Challenge Fund (Cut) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Mental Health Services (Waiting Times) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Brexit First Minister’s Questions · 2
- College Lecturers (Pay Dispute) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Brexit (Travel Companies) First Minister’s Questions · 3
- Mental Health Awareness Week First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Specialist Heart Failure Nurse Services First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Community Pharmacy Scotland Members’ business · 14
- Justice and the Law Officers Questions · 1
- Temporary Release Questions · 6
- Community Payback Orders Questions · 8
- Divisional Police Officers Questions · 4
- Police Officers Questions · 6
- Police Officers (Ayrshire) Questions · 6
- Family Courts (Children’s Interests) Questions · 4
- Victim Support Service Questions · 4
- Brexit (Impact on Food and Drink) Debate · 77
- Decision Time Decision time · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.