Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2019 (SSI 2019/121)

Tuesday 30 April 2019 Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee About 09:30–09:45 Subordinate legislation 33 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

33 contributions
Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Welcome to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee’s 13th meeting in 2019. I remind everyone to switch off their mobile phones or to put them in silent mode, because they might affect the broadcasting system.

Under agenda item 1 the committee will take evidence on the Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2019. I am delighted to welcome Dr Tom Russon, who is the legislation team leader in the Scottish Government’s decarbonisation division, and Andrew Mortimer, who is a statistician in the office of the chief economic adviser. Good morning to you both.

Am I correct in thinking that you will make an opening statement?

Dr Tom Russon Scottish Government
link

I have not been advised to do so, but I am happy to speak briefly to the purpose of the Scottish statutory instrument, if that would be helpful to the committee.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Yes—that would be good. Thank you.

Dr Russon
link

The instrument is one in a fairly long series—I am sure that members remember the previous iterations; I will leave you to decide whether you do so fondly—of Scottish statutory instruments on reporting on annual targets under the Climate Change (Scotland) 2009 Act.

All the emissions reduction targets under the 2009 act are based on emissions that have been adjusted to account for operation in Scotland of the European Union emissions trading system. The adjustment forms part of the statutory reporting requirements on the targets, and the calculation rules by which the adjustment is performed each year need to be set in legislation. That happens through carbon accounting scheme regulations.

The original set of regulations—the Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2010—which were passed shortly after the 2009 act, contained provisions to undertake the adjustment calculations for the annual target years 2010 to 2012, which corresponded to phase 2 of operation of the EU emissions trading system. During phase 3 of the ETS—all the annual target years from 2013 to date—amendment regulations have been required annually in order to introduce a new set of calculation rules for each year’s adjustment calculation. Annual SSIs have been needed because data for the new EU ETS is available only year to year: we cannot pre-empt data and set out all the rules for future years, as would probably have been preferable.

I will highlight one other point, of which I am sure the committee is well aware. A lot of the dates can be quite confusing, because everything is, in effect, happening two years after the event. That is simply to do with the timescales for availability of emissions data. For example, it is expected that the next set of emissions statistics will be published in June and will cover emissions during the calendar year 2017. It just takes that long for the data to become available and be published.

The accounting rules in the SSI that the committee is considering today relate to emissions during the calendar year 2017. In essence, the purpose of the SSI is to allow for full statutory reporting on the 2017 annual target under the 2009 act, once the statistics become available later in the year.

I hope that that is helpful.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I want to get a handle on what is going on. Do we know how many participants in the ETS there are in Scotland?

Do we even have—I see the witnesses’ body language—an approximate figure? I understand that, broadly speaking, there are certainly no more than 100, and the number may be substantially fewer than that. Could you give us a description in broad terms of who participates, so that we can understand a little bit more what is going on in what is a highly technical area.

09:45

Dr Russon
link

I am very happy to do the best that I can to answer that question.

We will have to write back to the committee on the exact number of participants: we will be happy to do that. The operation of the EU ETS in Scotland covers fixed installations; I think that Stewart Stevenson’s question relates primarily to them. My best understanding is that about 100 participants is the right first-order approximation but, as I said, we will write back with the exact current figure.

The installations are large ones that emit significant quantities of greenhouse gases. Prime examples are large industrial facilities, such as power stations—although, obviously, there is no longer significant coal-fired power in Scotland. If we want to think about the sectors in “Draft Climate Change Plan—the draft Third Report on Policies and Proposals 2017-2032”, for example, we are primarily talking about heavy industry and parts of the power sector.

Aviation for destinations within the EU is also covered by the EU emissions trading system; operators of those flights also report under the system.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

That is kind of what I thought. What effect does the system have on operation of those large industrial facilities? I am sure that my colleague Angus MacDonald will be interested in the Grangemouth refinery, which I am quite confident is one of the 100 or so participants. I am also thinking about aviation, because there is a lot of that. Does the system mean that there are cash outflows, because those businesses have to buy credits? Are other businesses in Scotland net contributors in providing credits that can be bought? In broad terms, who are the parties in the trading that goes on? I am not looking for absolute detail.

Dr Russon
link

As I understand it, the thrust of the question is to do with functional operation of the EU emissions trading system. I say, as a significant disclaimer, that that is not my policy area, but I would be happy to ask colleagues to provide a more detailed written explanation.

Perhaps Andrew Mortimer could talk about auctions and free allowances for installations first. I will then come back to the SSI.

Andrew Mortimer Scottish Government
link

Auctions are run approximately 12 times a year, and data that relates to auctioning of United Kingdom emission allowances under the EU ETS can be picked up on the Intercontinental Exchange. That is one part of the system.

The national implementation measures are another part of the system. Industries that are at significant risk of carbon leakage to outside the EU are, in essence, given a free allowance.

The new entrant reserve is another part of the system. Essentially, that reserve is drawn from as and when a new business or industry comes into being that would qualify for a free allocation of allowances, but does not have one at the time of its set-up, because it has no historical reference data.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

My final question might be the most important one. Roughly—again, I am not expecting exactitude—what percentage of our total emissions are covered by what the SSI is trying to do? To be blunt, if the figure is a tiny one to the right of the decimal point, our concerns will be comparatively modest but, if it is 10 or 15 per cent, we might be more interested. It would be helpful to know that.

Dr Russon
link

The percentage is definitely more of the latter magnitude. Again, I will have to confirm the exact percentage, but about 25 per cent of Scotland’s total emissions are currently traded under the EU ETS.

I emphasise that the SSI does nothing in terms of the on-the-ground operation of the emissions trading scheme; it simply reflects the operation of that scheme when it comes to calculation of emissions for reporting on climate targets.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

You will probably have a short and straightforward answer, but I would like clarity. We have the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill—as you know, the stage 1 report has been published. Am I right in thinking that, unless there are amendments, the bill will not make changes to what happens annually and that that will just flow from the 2009 act? Is that correct or are there any implications?

Dr Russon
link

I think that I have understood the question correctly, but please tell me if I have not. The need for the current SSI stems from the fact that the bill’s provisions are not yet agreed, let alone in force. Until such a time as an act is in force, in whatever form Parliament eventually agrees, the 2009 act’s requirements remain in legal force. The SSI flows solely from the 2009 act’s requirements.

In terms of what the bill will mean going forward, if the relevant parts of the bill were to be agreed in the form in which they stand, future climate targets will be set and reported against on the basis of actual emissions from all parts of the economy. That will have a range of consequences, one of which is such SSIs will no longer be needed.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Can you clarify whether we are talking about net emissions in which we take sequestration into account?

Dr Russon
link

I can assure you that that is an area of absolutely notorious complexity, even within the Government. The term “net” is, problematically, used in slightly different ways by different parties. We use it in the same way as the convener is using it, which is to refer to emissions sources minus emissions sinks. In that regard, absolutely nothing will change through the SSI, the bill or anything else that is being discussed at the present time.

In some of its previous advice, the UK Committee on Climate Change has sometimes used the word “net” in the way that, in my opening remarks, I used the term “adjusted”, to refer to emissions net of operation of the emissions trading scheme. Our preferred terminology—obviously, it is a matter of preference—is to refer to that as the distinction between adjusted emissions and actual emissions. In my previous answer, I intended to refer to the actual levels of emissions from heavy industry and the power sector, rather than the pro rata share of EU-wide emissions that is used under the adjustment calculation.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Thank you for clarifying that.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

I have a relatively modest and uncomplicated question. I want to know about aviation activities and caps and whether those caps have been exceeded or undershot. I have not read it, but the clerk’s note mentions that

“A paper setting out how the ‘aviation cap’ and the ‘fixed installation cap’ for 2017 have been determined has been published”.

I am afraid I have not seen that. Could you tell us how that has turned out?

Dr Russon
link

I defer to Andrew Mortimer on how the various components of the cap are calculated.

On the initial part of your question on the outturn performance comparisons to the cap, I do not have figures in front of me, but I am happy to write back to the committee with them. All of that information is available through the official statistical bulletins that are published each year.

Andrew Mortimer Scottish Government
link

As with all such calculations, calculation of the aviation cap is consistent with EU practice and UK practice—it follows them. The calculation is based on Scotland’s share of EU aviation emissions in the reference period 2004 to 2006. We replicate in Scotland the approach of the EU target, which is to reduce, in phase 3 of the ETS, aviation emissions by 95 per cent, from 2010 aviation emissions.

John Scott Con Ayr
link

My understanding from the aviation industry is that it is on track to meet the targets. Is that correct?

Andrew Mortimer Scottish Government
link

I do not have that information to hand, but I can write with it, if you wish.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

To close this off, it might be useful if I give my description of the ETS to see whether it is reasonable. I understand that, under the ETS, heavy industry is given allowances that relate to its presumed emissions. If a company emits less, the allowances have value, because they can be sold to somebody who has insufficient allowances. The economic value from being able to sell allowances to someone else creates an incentive for those that have allowances not to emit as much as their allowances permit, and there is a disincentive for those that emit more than their allowances permit, because they have to pay out money for that. Is that a fair description of what the whole thing is about? It is about trading the allowances.

Dr Russon
link

I repeat the caveat that the issue is not within my immediate policy expertise, but that sounds like a reasonable description of a cap-and-trade scheme such as the ETS.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How is radiative forcing taken into account in relation to aviation? Is the science on that changing?

Dr Russon
link

That falls outside the scope of the present SSI, but I am happy to do my best to explain how it fits into the wider legislative framework. Section 16 of the 2009 act incorporates a fair share of the emissions from international aviation in the scope of Scotland’s targets. The committee will be aware that Scotland was the first country to do that; we were joined by Wales late last year and, to the best of my knowledge, Scotland and Wales remain the only countries to include international, as well as domestic, aviation emissions in their domestic target frameworks.

Through an entirely separate piece of secondary legislation, which I think was made in 2010 or 2012—I will confirm the year later—section 16 sets up rules for determining a Scottish share of international aviation activity. As part of that, section 16 refers to an aviation multiplier, which is called “the radiative force factor” in the SSI—to the best of my understanding, they are the same thing—to which you referred. That multiplier applies to such emissions to reflect the additional effects of non-CO2 emissions at altitude.

The 2009 act required ministers to seek advice from the Committee on Climate Change on the appropriate level for the multiplier. In whichever year the SSI to which I referred was made—I believe that it was 2011—the CCC advised that the most appropriate level, on the basis of scientific understanding at the time, was a multiplier of 1, which is in statute. I am certainly not an expert on where scientific understanding of the issue has got to; I am aware that studies have been published that suggest values other than 1, but I am not aware of whether there is a consensus about an alternative value.

Under section 16 of the 2009 act, ministers have the power to introduce further sets of regulations to amend the rules. If they wished to do to so, ministers could seek further advice from the Committee on Climate Change on any aspects of that before they introduced further regulation.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

In essence, the SSI is about calculating whether the carbon units from net emissions are credited or debited. That is the narrow focus of the SSI.

Dr Russon
link

The SSI relates solely to the EU ETS adjustment calculation for 2017.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I make the observation, which I hope will be helpful, that when the UK Committee on Climate Change was asked for advice on the radiative forcing multiplier, it was unable at that time to find robust evidence to suggest that the multiplier would be anything other than 1. That was the advice that I received.

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

I thank the witnesses for their time and for giving such helpful evidence. We will consider the instrument as part the committee’s next agenda item. I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to get on with the rest of their day.

10:01 Meeting suspended.

10:01 On resuming—

Gillian Martin SNP The Convener · Aberdeenshire East
link

Under item 2, the committee will consider two negative instruments. As no member has any comments to make on the Carbon Accounting Scheme (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2019, which we have just discussed, does the committee agree not to make any recommendations on the instrument?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 33
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  3. 09:45 EU Exit and the Environment Committee business · 191
  4. 12:30 European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 Committee business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.