Although the issue might seem quite technical and remote, I am quite concerned about the instrument. For members who have not followed the matter in detail, the key issue is that employer contributions will rise by 6 per cent from next month, because of the change in the discount rate. The lower the rate, the higher the level of funding that is required, and the rate is dropping by 0.4 per cent.
The key issue is whether the Scottish Government will receive a full Barnett consequential as a result of the change. I am sure that members will all have seen the correspondence, particularly from general practitioners and their practices. We are all concerned about GP recruitment and retention, and I am concerned that the instrument will particularly affect rural areas. The effect could be redundancies for GP staff. The other issue—this happens across Scotland—is that some general practices are reverting to health board control, which will result in a major problem in relation to recruiting and retaining GPs.
The issue is, of course, wider than that. My colleague Miles Briggs might want to talk about Children’s Hospices Across Scotland. There are particular issues for non-NHS employers, such as hospices, charities and universities. Just the other day, CHAS wrote to us to say that the changes will cost it an extra £350,000 per year, which is equivalent to the cost of nine full-time nurses.
I appreciate that the issues are all reserved, but they have a huge effect on the Scottish Government and on health. To set the scene, I should say that the other factor that is affecting GPs and consultants, in particular, is the changes to the lifetime allowance, which is a United Kingdom pensions restriction. Basically, the changes will have a longer-term adverse tax effect on individuals who go through the ceiling. Having gone round GP practices in the Highlands and Islands, I think that that is certainly affecting the ability of GPs and consultants to work beyond the age of 55 without reducing their hours. As we know, we desperately need full-time as well as part-time GPs.
I suspect that the committee cannot do much about the issue, but it is really important that we highlight it. After all, we can all see what is coming. We are facing a GP crisis in Scotland, and the employer contributions, the lifetime allowance and other tax matters that I will not bore the committee with are going to affect that situation.
I am also very concerned about the effect not just on GPs but on non-NHS employers, particularly hospices. I am sure that we all have hospices in our areas, and I know that the hospice in Inverness in my region does a fantastic job. I am very concerned about the extra costs. I also think that the issue is treated slightly differently in England.
I simply put those points on the table just to highlight my real concerns about recruitment and retention.