Agenda item 2 is consideration of the section 22 report, “The 2017/18 audit of Scottish Social Services Council”. I welcome to the meeting our first panel of witnesses, who are Lorraine Gray, chief executive, and Maree Allison, director of regulation, Scottish Social Services Council. I understand that Lorraine Gray wants to make a short opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Section 22 Report
“The 2017/18 audit of Scottish Social Services Council”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Lorraine Gray Scottish Social Services Council 94
- Jenny Marra Lab 74
- Alex Neil SNP 53
- Paul Johnston Scottish Government 37
- Anas Sarwar Lab 33
- Maree Allison Scottish Social Services Council 28
- Willie Coffey SNP 25
- Colin Cook Scottish Government 25
- Michael Chalmers Scottish Government 25
- Colin Beattie SNP 23
- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 21
- Liam Kerr Con 13
- Bill Bowman Con 12
- Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland 1
- Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland 1
The record
465 contributions · showing 1–200The Scottish Social Services Council has successfully delivered its digital transformation programme, which went live on 11 February. The programme was an upgrade to existing systems and a move to the cloud in order to modernise our systems. We are already seeing the benefits of the upgrade from stakeholder feedback and in financial terms, as we will make an annual saving of £416,000 from next year.
As with any programme of work, we recognise that there are areas in which we could have done better. We have taken forward the recommendations in the external audit report that was completed by Grant Thornton. However, we do not accept all the criticisms that were levelled by Audit Scotland or the comments that were made by this committee on 7 February. There are errors and misunderstandings in the evidence that was presented and in the conclusions that the committee came to.
We welcome the opportunity to put forward evidence that demonstrates that, overall, this was a well-managed programme of work, which is already delivering significant benefits to internal and external stakeholders.
We continue to have substantial shared services with the Care Inspectorate and to work closely together to deliver those services. We have had shared services with the inspectorate since we were established in 2001, but, as the committee will see from our written submission, the SSSC has transformed since that time from a small organisation with few registrants to a much larger organisation. The shared infrastructure was preventing us from realising our strategic priorities so, as the committee is aware, we established our own information and communications technology service.
During this morning’s meeting, I believe that we can provide reassurance that that was the right decision to ensure that the SSSC continues to effectively regulate the social service workforce and, thereby, protect some of the most vulnerable people in Scotland. The work was critical to our fulfilling our statutory function of protecting the people who use social services. The systems in question hold the personal information of nearly 130,000 registrants, and the case management system manages the more than 2,000 cases that we are investigating. That is our primary purpose and those are our most important systems. If they fail, we fail.
The audit has given us the opportunity to reflect on the areas in which we could have improved. We realise that we were too solution and delivery focused, which, on occasion, has been at the expense of governance. In future, we will ensure a more stringent programme management and governance approach.
We have carried out a health check review with the Scottish Government’s programme and project management centre of expertise, and we received its draft report yesterday. I am pleased to say that it has given us a green/amber status, although there are a number of recommendations, which we can share with the committee.
We could have done better in relation to some of the areas that are outlined in the section 22 report. However, there has been a successful outcome to the programme of work, which is down to the hard work and dedication of the staff at the Scottish Social Services Council.
Thank you for that opening statement.
Before we move to questions, I will make a couple of remarks, just for clarity. We have a submission from the former chief executive of the Scottish Social Services Council, which is included in the public papers. She was due to attend today but, unfortunately, she is not able to do so.
I also point out that we are in a highly unusual situation, as I think that this is the first time this session that a public body that is being investigated has rejected or taken issue with Audit Scotland’s findings. I therefore intend to take a couple of questions on that issue, after which we will move on to the substantive findings of the Audit Scotland report.
link
Our witnesses will appreciate that the committee is not here to adjudicate between the Auditor General and the SSSC, but the situation is extraordinary. This is the second time that I have been a member of the committee, and we have never before had such a situation arise. How was the situation allowed to get to this stage? Why were there not the usual discussions and agreements before the Auditor General’s report was issued?
We received the section 22 report on 26 November 2018. It was a bit of a surprise to us—the external auditor had warned us about it the day before. We had a telephone conversation on 5 December with the auditor’s office and we then submitted some of our evidence. Substantial changes were made to the report, and then we received the final version.
Until the committee meeting on 7 February 2019, we had accepted many of the points—we accepted that we could have done better and that there were issues with governance. We submitted a letter to the committee for that meeting, outlining what we plan to do in taking forward the recommendations. However, at the meeting on 7 February, one of the statements that was made was that we brought in no outside expertise. However, as page 3 of our submission shows, we had significant external expertise. Those are not matters of opinion; they are matters of fact.
link
Given that, it is extraordinary that the discussions did not seem to come to the point at which such dissent was noted in the Auditor General’s report. I would have expected that to have been done, but there is nothing there.
I ask Maree Allison to respond to that.
My recollection of the section 22 report is that the issue of external expertise was not highlighted as an area of huge significance. When we responded to the draft section 22 report, we provided Audit Scotland with a detailed note of our comments on it. On the first page of that note, we highlighted the external expertise that we had brought in. We said that we had brought in Scottish Government procurement officials to assist with the procurement and that we had brought in the Scottish Government digital transformation team to assist with the procurement and selection of a new supplier; to give specialist advice on our technical architecture survey, current-state analysis and digital strategy; and to assist with specialist technical expertise during the first six months of the contract. We also brought in a digital transformation lead—an external consultant—to take forward some of the work. The note also referred to the fact that some of the project was reviewed by the office of the chief information officer. We highlighted that to Audit Scotland, which is why it was a surprise to us that, in its evidence to the committee, that became an area of criticism for us.
link
I have a couple of specific questions on the Auditor General’s report that relate to that issue. The Auditor General said that there was no clear business plan at the start of the project. Is that correct?
That is one of the misunderstandings. The project started because we were coming out of the contract for what we called our Sequence system, through which we held all the records of our registrants and managed our fitness-to-practise cases.
link
Did you have a business plan?
At that point, we were doing a lift and shift. We asked the Scottish Government digital transformation team to carry out two pieces of work for us: a current-state analysis and an infrastructure review. The findings from those provided the information that helped us put together the invitation to tender. We had two big documents, but I accept that we should have pulled the findings from them into a much more coherent business case.
link
There was no business plan, as such.
There was an overarching business plan at the very beginning of the process.
link
But not for the project.
The beginning of the project was a relet of a contract.
link
Was there a separate budget for the project?
The money came from our existing budget. We were given money from the Scottish Government to upgrade and relet the Sequence system, but that was part of our overall grant. You will find the figures on page 5 of our submission.
link
Did you have a risk register for the project?
Yes.
link
The Auditor General said that you did not.
We did.
We provided Audit Scotland with copies of the risk register for the project, which evolved over time. My recollection is that the Auditor General’s report criticises how we managed risk, but I am not sure whether it says that there was no risk register. There certainly was a risk register, which evolved and was reviewed during the project.
link
What about the benefits that would come from having a risk register? It would have been part of the business plan but, on top of that, you should have looked at the quantitative and qualitative benefits. Did you do that?
If we had not progressed with this piece of work, we would not have had a register for the 130,000 people whom we register. We had a system. The contract was coming to an end, so we needed to get a new supplier. We were lifting our system and shifting it to another supplier. That was the benefit. If we had not done that, we would have come out of contract, and the system that holds—
link
With respect, that is not the point. A process needs to be followed, from the business plan to looking at the benefits and so on. Did you follow the process?
Was that information set out in a business case? The information on what we were aiming to do and why we had to do it was set out in our current-state analysis and in our invitation to tender.
I want to pick up the point about the budget. Colin Beattie asked whether there was an item-by-item budget for the lift and shift project. Lorraine Gray said that there was a budget, but it was within the bigger budget. Was there a detailed budget for this discrete project?
Yes. When the project commenced, we went out to tender to procure a new supplier. The tenders came back with the figures on how much it would cost us to do the lift and shift. We had funding specifically for the project, and the digital budget and what we were spending—or were anticipating to spend—on specific items were detailed separately in our budget reports. A criticism that has been levelled is that the funding was included in different sections in overall budget papers and that the individual funding should have been separated. We accept that that would have been clearer.
Where do you want to go from here, in terms of the rift—if I can put it that way—with the Auditor General? It seems as though it continues, and that you are still not satisfied that you have been correctly represented. Today, both sides have the opportunity to air their views. My experience of Government is that officials get a draft report from the Auditor General, primarily for them to check that the facts are correct and that the balance and context are accurate. Were your comments on the draft report not incorporated sufficiently to satisfy you? What do you want to happen?
It is an overstatement to say that there is a rift. We accepted the section 22 review, overall, but we did not agree with all of it. Factual inaccuracies were corrected, but we have differences of opinion. We are more than happy—I sense that Audit Scotland will feel the same—to sit down and have that discussion.
Carrying out the health check review over the past three days has allowed some of the challenges around programme management to be crystallised for us in a much clearer way. We want to have that discussion and to learn the lessons, because we are not disputing that there are lessons to learn. However, we would like recognition that we have delivered the project successfully and that it is doing what we want it to do.
09:15
There was one particular comment in the health check that clarified for me the reason for certain comments in the section 22 report. That comment was:
“There was a strong sense of cohesion and trust amongst SSSC EMT, Council and the operational management teams. Organisational leadership, from the CEO and Directors, was very strong and had a clear focus and engagement”
on digital transformation.
“The Review Team held a strong opinion that that these strengths engendered an over-reliance on ‘business-as-usual’ relationships and business decision processes. Programme roles and responsibilities were not clear”.
Because of all those things, we probably did not go into change mode and take a programme management approach. Maree Allison and I have discussed that, and what we are now clear about is that the two of us had too many hats on. That is what I mean when I say that we were driven to achieve the outcome. At times, we should have paused; I do not think that our decisions would have been different, but at times, we were too focused on delivering the project.
So you have learned the lessons.
Yes.
If you ever had to do something like this again, you would abide by those lessons.
Yes.
I presume that they are very well documented now, so a future generation can look back and see what mistakes they should avoid making.
Yes.
Finally, can you confirm your total grant from the Scottish Government in the current year?
Are you talking about the digital budget funding?
That, and your total grant.
The grant-in-aid that we received for ICT development in the financial year that is just coming to conclusion was £953,000, and we received a total of £15.7 million in grant-in-aid.
Did you say £15.7 million in total?
Yes.
That is a big grant. What do you do with all that money?
I will let Maree Allison tell you that.
Our primary focus—indeed, our statutory public protection requirement—is the registration and regulation of the social service workforce. We have quite a substantial staff group of, I think, 270, whose focus is on registering, as Lorraine Gray has said, nearly 130,000 people. That number is going to grow to about 160,000 in the next couple of years. Very large numbers of people are applying for registration, and staff are processing and assessing those applications and dealing with inquiries.
We also have to investigate any fitness-to-practise concerns that might arise about what is a small percentage of the workforce, and we hold in our offices evidential hearings that are akin to employment or regulatory tribunals, with an independent panel hearing evidence and cases being presented by solicitors. The majority of the staff in the organisation deal with that core statutory function.
We also have staff involved in workforce development, which is another prime focus of the council, and they are developing tools and improving the workforce’s capacity and capability.
Thank you.
Picking up on some of the evidence that has just come to light and the discussion that we have had about the difference between factual inaccuracy and opinion, I note that Lorraine Gray said that the factual inaccuracies had been corrected, but there remained a difference of opinion between the SSSC and what is in the Auditor General’s report. In her submission, the former chief executive said that she wanted to
“correct some factual inaccuracies relating to the evidence session on 7 February”.
Were there factual inaccuracies, or differences of opinion?
We corrected factual inaccuracies in the draft section 22 report, and there were additional inaccuracies at the committee meeting on 7 February. Maree has highlighted—
But were those inaccuracies in the evidence from Audit Scotland or in our conclusions on that evidence?
It was in relation to bringing in expertise. When the Auditor General was asked about that, she suggested that we had not brought in expertise. That was inaccurate.
Thank you very much. I will bring in Willie Coffey.
Good morning. If you do not mind, I will focus on the software development project that was at the core of all this. Are you familiar with Audit Scotland’s “Principles for a digital future” guidelines, which were issued in May 2017?
Yes.
Would you say that you applied those guidelines to the project?
Yes, but I will ask Maree Allison to speak in more detail about that.
The guidelines were highlighted to and discussed with us by one of the technical architects from the Scottish Government’s digital transformation service, who went through them with us in September 2017, and they were also formally discussed at one of our programme boards. At that point, the architect highlighted to us an area around governance that, to my recollection, was about supplier management and risk management, and we were due to bring in a digital transformation lead to assist with improving those areas. There was a review of and a focus on the matter, and looking at the matter now in light of the work that we have undertaken and what Audit Scotland has highlighted, I think that there are areas that we absolutely complied with and did a very good job on and other areas where, as we have already said, we accept that we could have done better.
Did you apply a project management methodology, and if so, which?
At the beginning, this was a small project about moving a contract. However, it got bigger, and we have set out the reasons for that. We aim to try to manage successful programmes—that is our methodology—but we accept that we did not follow that, and we are now looking at how we bring into the organisation additional expertise with regard to managing a programme office. We do not have that; we brought in some of it, but it is definitely something that we need to look at strengthening in the SSSC.
You said a moment ago that you applied the guidelines, but you are now saying that you did not apply any formal methodology. Is that what you are saying?
The aim was to apply them, but the reality, as set out in the health check, was that we operated too much in a business-as-usual mode.
With regard to the software upgrade, at what point was it discovered that the original source code that would have enabled the upgrade was lost, and what has the organisation done to recover it?
The source code was not about the upgrade, but about the move. When we appointed the new supplier, it carried out due diligence for us to ensure that everything was ready for the move, but it established that the source code was missing. I am not a technical person, but it was described to me as the DNA of our whole system. The challenge for us, then, was to decide whether to continue and put the system at risk or to rebuild the system, but I will ask Maree Allison to tell you what we did about that.
The issue was uncovered in summer 2017. The contract was awarded towards the end of May, and when the new supplier came in and started the due diligence of the system that was being hosted by our original supplier, it was discovered that the software in question was missing. The original supplier had subcontractors who were responsible for the software, but over the lifetime of the previous contract, those subcontractors had been taken over by another company and all the original people had moved on. Our supplier undertook a huge amount of work to identify where the software was, but it could not find it.
We considered legal options under the contract, but because we knew that we were moving to a new supplier and that the whole system was going to be looked at, we decided that it would not be appropriate to take any legal action. The supplier had carried out as much work as it could, but the software could not be identified or located.
Basically, you had to build a new system from scratch, because there was no original source code to upgrade.
Yes.
There were missing bits. It was not clear how critical those bits were, so doing a straightforward upgrade would have been really risky.
It probably would have been impossible, if you did not have the source code.
About a year into the project plan, you decided that you needed your own technical network infrastructure to deliver the project. That seems a bit late in the day to realise that you needed your own infrastructure to hang your system on. Why did it take so long to come to that conclusion?
The picture was evolving. The new infrastructure was not required in order to access Sequence, which is our registration system—it would have been possible to achieve that on the existing network. However, when we understood that we had to completely rebuild Sequence because of the missing software, we realised that we had to deal with the case management situation.
Sequence, as a customer relationship management system, was dealing with our fitness-to-practise work but not effectively, and that had been highlighted as a real risk. We knew that we wanted to address that. However, it appeared to us that if we were to pay to build into Sequence the functionality that effectively dealt with the fitness-to-practise work, we would subsequently end up having to spend more money to purchase a proper case management system. We did not want to spend money twice. At that point, we said that we needed to deal with the case management system and look at purchasing a new one.
The system that dealt with the critical issues most effectively was one that had more challenges regarding running it on the existing network. It was stated in the previous evidence-taking session that the case management system that we purchased would not run on the existing network. That is not correct—it would. The issue was discussed at one of our programme board meetings. It is minuted that when we made the decision to purchase the system, we knew that there were challenges, but that it would run if we hosted it in-house on the premises. At that point, we were trying to find a cloud solution, and challenges arose regarding how we would access it.
The issue arose as the project evolved; it was not something that we were anticipating at the beginning, when we were just looking to lift and shift Sequence.
To put in your own network infrastructure at a later stage to support Sequence must have added to the overall cost of delivering the project. How much did it cost to deliver that?
The cost of the network, including its nuts and bolts and the bits and pieces to run things, is £441,000.
It is important to state that, if we did not have our own network, we would have had to pay for lots of workaround solutions. Those could have worked, but they would not have been ideal.
External contractors—presumably software engineers—were deployed on the project. A series of three of them came and went, usually on six-month contracts. That issue is mentioned in the Audit Scotland report. Is the most recent contractor, who is still with you, due to leave at the end of a six-month contract?
No.
How do you get the continuity of service from those contractors?
That challenge is one that everybody faces, not just us. One of our challenges is being based in Dundee. The first contractor left because there were so many challenges around shared services. The second contractor, who came from the west, left when they were offered a position in an organisation. The contractor that we have now will stay with us until we bring in a permanent solution next year, for which we now have the budget.
Do you own whatever source code you are deploying at the moment? If you do, you will be able to upgrade the network at a later stage, should you wish to do so.
Yes.
Why is being based in Dundee a challenge?
As you know, Dundee is a beautiful city, but so many of the people whom we have tried to get for our project are in the central belt. The first person was from Dundee, but it seems to be more challenging to find people in Dundee, because a lot of people are based in Edinburgh and Glasgow.
09:30
link
I would like to pick up on something that Lorraine Gray raised. The Auditor General was critical about the late stage at which the SSSC brought in external expertise. However, you stated earlier and in the submissions that you asked the Scottish Government for support early on. Can you recall when you sought that support from the Scottish Government, what its extent was and how you asked for it? Also, did you get all that you asked for?
We first met the Scottish Government’s digital transformation service on 2 June 2016, when we were beginning to look at the project. We knew how important the systems were to the organisation. In June 2016, we asked for a statement of work setting out how the service could support us and what some of the challenges would be—that was after a number of face-to-face meetings. We then met the service in the organisation and two people from the service were appointed. They helped us with the invitation to tender and the current-state analysis, and their advice was very good. We had a really good working relationship and got exactly what we needed.
Looking back, we probably needed more advice about programme management, which was one of things in the health check, but the technical advice was excellent. We also worked with the Scottish Government procurement service as we went out to tender. We brought in expertise from the beginning of the project, before anything started, so that we did not make technical mistakes and got it right.
link
To be clear, a department of the Scottish Government effectively signed off the project at an early stage and you were comfortable that it had given you all the support that you needed to go live. Is that correct?
No. We are talking about a period of two years. The Scottish Government digital transformation service came at the beginning to advise us. We did not want a system that would not take us to the future; we wanted to think about where we wanted to be and what future we imagined. The advisers outlined where we were and where we needed to get to. They then helped us with some of the technical matters and came to our programme board, and they were with us until February 2018, which is when we employed an agency for the digital technical expertise. The Scottish Government digital transformation service was not involved in the decision about whether we were ready to go live. That was a decision of the organisation. We were ready on 11 February, and it was very successful.
link
You referred to previous evidence that this committee has heard. In response to a question that I raised in that previous session, I heard that the SSSC was
“aware of all the guidance, the tools and some of the checklists, but those ... were not used.—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 7 February 2019; c 17.
By way of clarification, is that one of the factual inaccuracies that you refer to? Is that statement incorrect?
As Maree Allison said in reply to Mr Coffey’s question, we did refer to and use “Principles for a digital future”.
link
So, in your view, the statement that the committee heard is not correct. Did you use the checklists?
Yes, we used those checklists. We discussed them at a programme board meeting and that was minuted.
link
Moving the conversation on slightly, Maree Allison said that you have had a lot support throughout the project from the various agencies that have been listed. If so, what is your view of how the issues arose? Clearly, there were issues. You said that there was a lot of support and Lorraine Gray talked very favourably about the Scottish Government support, so what went wrong? Whose support was inadequate, or was did the problems arise at the SSSC end?
I think that we received really good support. I go back to the point that we have delivered the project in this financial year within our budget. When we look at other organisations, we see that people in roles like Maree’s and my previous role have often been taken off business-as-usual work to work only on a programme, but we continued to do our business-as-usual work while we worked on the programme. That was what went wrong, and that is what came out of the health check.
What has also come out of the findings is that there was a lack of clarity of role. In the health check, staff were asked who was the programme manager, who was the senior responsible officer and who was something else. They said, “Oh, that was Lorraine,” but I could not have been all three things. That highlighted that lack of clarity, which was the result of us being too involved in too many aspects. Part of that was to do with trying to manage the costs.
If we were to do this again, we would say that we need a programme manager who oversees the work and is not necessarily involved in all the business-as-usual work. I am sure that some members here have excellent experience of programme management, and they will agree that that is a lesson that should be learned. As I said, directors were perhaps too involved in some of the operational work that was going on.
link
Earlier, you talked about the money for the project that came as part of your grant from the Scottish Government. Did the Scottish Government sign off on something that said, “We will give you £3.1 million as part of your grant in relation to this project”—I think that the figure was £3.1 million, more or less—or did it just say, “There’s your grant money; crack on”?
Our sponsor team receive our budget request every year. It sets out in detail the funding that we are seeking and what it is to be used for. The digital funding was awarded to us as a result of the team reviewing our budget submissions in which we set out the funding that we were looking for in relation to digital and why we were looking for it.
link
So, the Scottish Government reviewed what you submitted and said that it looked worthy of a budget allocation of £3 million or so and agreed to advance that money as part of the budget.
Yes, over a two-year period.
I wish to explore a point that Liam Kerr just raised. It is about the interaction with the office of the chief information officer. I think that you said earlier that the Auditor General said on 7 February that you did not engage with external support. Is that correct?
That is what was said. We did engage with the office of the chief information officer, and I would be happy to set out that timeline.
I have the Official Report in front of me and, over the past 20 minutes, as I have been listening to you, I have been reviewing what was said. On 7 February, the Auditor General said:
“You are right to say that the council engaged with the office of the chief information officer at a late stage.”—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 7 February 2019; c 3.
She did not deny that there was an interaction with the office; she simply said that it occurred late.
I suppose that what is considered late is a matter of opinion. Our first interaction was in September 2017—
I am concerned about the veracity of information and evidence that is being presented to committee. I feel that the Auditor General’s comments were misrepresented earlier in your evidence. On 7 February, she said that you engaged with the office of the chief information officer “at a late stage.” I do not think that she said that there was no engagement at all.
I beg your pardon if I have given that impression.
We also have a letter from the Auditor General, dated 8 March, that says:
“The Scottish Government’s digital team were represented on the SSSC’s programme board, but only from September 2017 to January 2018.”
Is that correct?
The very first programme board took place on 5 September 2016, and the Scottish Government’s digital transformation service was at that meeting. We had engaged with the service in June 2016.
If the Government’s digital team was at that meeting a year earlier, there is no evidence of that in minutes, because the audit found that there was only evidence of it being involved from September 2017.
I have to disagree with that. The minutes state who attended the meetings, and those minutes were available.
I will need to double-check this, but I think that those minutes were all provided to Grant Thornton as part of its work on the accounts. With regard to the section 22 report, we were responding to the specific criticisms in the draft report. This issue was not in the draft report, so we provided Grant Thornton with a selection of minutes that were relevant to the issue that was raised in the original draft section 22 report. The point about when we engaged the digital transformation service was not in that draft report, so those specific minutes were not provided.
We said to Audit Scotland that that was not all the documentation in relation to the project and that if the auditors needed anything further, they should let us know. In our submission to Audit Scotland, we said that we brought in external expertise at key points and that we talked about the Scottish Government digital transformation service assisting with the procurement and selection of the new supplier and providing specialist advice.
Audit Scotland never came back to us to ask about when, specifically, all that happened, which is why it was a surprise to us when the Auditor General, in evidence to the committee, commented on her concern regarding the accountable officer not saying at the outset that she needed to get in expertise. I think that what Lorraine Gray was trying to say is that that is the point that we disagree with, because the accountable officer did bring in expertise, right at the very outset in 2016.
Do you accept that anyone watching this would think that there is a real lack of clarity and, therefore, governance in your organisation?
I hope that what they are hearing is us explaining why there are issues of disagreement and providing answers.
I will explore some governance issues later. Anas Sarwar will continue the questioning.
To follow up on the convener’s question, are you saying that the external support element is the only inaccuracy, or are there other inaccuracies from our meeting in February that you want to challenge?
In evidence, there was discussion about the SSSC purchasing a case management system that it knew would not run on the Care Inspectorate’s network. That is inaccurate. Meeting minutes, which were provided to Audit Scotland, recorded that there was a discussion about whether the system would work on the Care Inspectorate’s network and that there was confirmation that it would.
So you are saying that there are two inaccuracies. Is there a third?
Those are the two inaccuracies.
You said earlier that you accept that you had too many hats on and that, looking back, although you would have divvied up the roles differently, you would have made the same decisions. Do you stand by that? Would you still make the same decisions?
Yes.
What failure do you accept?
The review said that there was a lack of clarity when it came to roles and who did what in relation to the programme management, but I do not think that there was criticism of the decisions that we made. We accept that we operated too much in business-as-usual mode, because we had a clear idea of where we wanted to get to. Quite simply, we should have—
Just to clarify, it sounds as though you are saying that you wish that there had been more people to make decisions. You would have divvied up the decisions that were to be made, but you would have made the same decisions and had the same outcomes. Is that right?
I believe so.
What lessons have you learned?
We recognise now how difficult it is to evidence our work, which was highlighted through the audit. We have had a slightly different outcome through the review. If I could go back, there would be a number of areas on which we would have written down more stuff.
So you are saying that your mistake was to not write down enough stuff, but there were no flaws in the decisions that were made and you would do the same thing again.
We made the right decisions to get to where we needed to get, to have a system that met our statutory needs, to have modern systems, to ensure that our staff were able to do their jobs properly and to achieve efficiencies. The outcomes were right, but the process could have been vastly improved.
That is why Colin Beattie’s point from the start of the meeting has stuck with me. I have been on the committee for less than six months, but I have never before heard anyone challenge an Audit Scotland report in the way that you have done this morning and in your written evidence. It sounds as though you are saying, “We could’ve written some more stuff down and divvied up the responsibilities a bit better, but we did the right thing and we got it right—they are wrong.” I am not sure that that reflects well on your organisation or the individuals who lead the organisation. Do you accept that?
Perhaps I am describing the situation in too simplistic a manner. We have delivered a system that meets our needs and we are being criticised about governance and transparency—that is what the audit report is about.
Lots of organisations can say, “We have delivered the system,” but if it went £20 million, £40 million or £60 million over budget, that still means that mistakes were made. It is necessary to accept the mistakes that were made.
We accept that mistakes were made on governance issues and programme management, that there should have been a better business case at the beginning and that there should have been more detailed reporting to the council. Those were the main issues in the section 22 report.
09:45
I want to follow on from Liam Kerr’s questions about the interaction with the Scottish Government. Would you describe the interaction with the Scottish Government as a high level of interaction that involved a high level of oversight? You mentioned that there were minutes from 2016 that recognised that the Scottish Government was in the room. Being in the room then and being in the room a year and a half later does not sound like hyperactive involvement or big oversight. How would you describe the level of oversight and the level of interaction with the Scottish Government?
The digital transformation service’s role is not an oversight role; it is a support role. It was in formal meetings in rooms, but it also supported us through the delivery of the programme. It was involved in the evaluation of the tenders and in helping us to deal with the technical side, which we did not have expertise in. When the contract was awarded, it was incredibly supportive of how we dealt with issues such as the missing software, and how we would take assurance and make decisions when there were real technical questions from the supplier on the table. It was heavily involved and very supportive, but there was not always oversight.
Was it highly involved or sporadically involved, or was there arm’s-length involvement in the project from the start? Was it heavily involved?
It was heavily involved at the start.
Was the level of detail and frequency of the involvement high or low?
High. After the contract was awarded, there was a decrease in involvement, but that was appropriate because we were moving into the delivery stage. The involvement was higher at the outset.
Okay. So the level of detail was high and the level of involvement was high.
Yes.
Was the involvement high from the start? Was it high or medium towards the end?
I would probably class it as high at the start and moving into medium when we were in the delivery phase until the project ended in 2018. Lorraine Gray can correct me if I am wrong, but I think that that was due to resources in the digital transformation service moving into other, much more high-risk and high-priority areas.
Does Lorraine Gray agree with that?
Yes.
So you think that the team was fully engaged and fully involved and knew exactly what was going on.
It was often based in our office, but it is important to say that the advice was technical. It was fully engaged in the technical advice and the technical decisions that we were making.
It knew what was going on.
Yes.
Liam Kerr has a supplementary question on that point.
link
So the Scottish Government was totally involved and accepted the lack of a business case, the lack of a budget and the lack of a cost benefit analysis. Is that correct?
If we go back to some of the—
Is that correct?
That is correct.
Good morning. I want to build a little on Anas Sarwar’s comments. I have seen interactions between organisations and auditors. If I understand things correctly, the documentation for some things that you say that you did exists somewhere, but it is not nicely set out and you have to hunt to find it, and there are some aspects of what you did that could have been done better. Is that correct?
Yes.
There is the mantra that, if something is not documented, it was not done. Has that been put to you?
Yes.
Is that the situation behind some of the comments?
Yes. It is about where the documentation is and how to find it. Maybe decisions were made in too many different places. We are not saying that we did it all right; we accept that we did not. We did not document things properly in some areas.
Do you think that, if you had documented in a more standard and formal way, you would have done things differently, or better?
Some of the decisions would have been the same, but the process would probably not have been so stressful for staff. I think that it would have taken us longer but, on reflection, we should have taken longer and not rushed to get to the finish date.
To follow up on Mr Sarwar’s comment about budgets, did you do the work within your budget?
Yes.
So the budget costs did not run away.
We did not have to go back and ask for any more money.
ICT projects are notorious for being expensive and complex, so why was internal audit not involved in the process?
There was an internal audit, but it was of our digital strategy, which set out the overarching principles. That was done on 13 May 2018. However, we are considering our internal audits for the next two years, and the issue will be prioritised. I accept that we should have had an internal audit to get that reassurance.
So Audit Scotland is correct in saying that the ICT project was not included in the internal audit.
That is correct.
I think that the expenditure on the project was roughly £4 million. Is that correct?
Overall, it was £4 million.
You told Mr Neil that your overall budget is £15.7 million, so £4 million is a substantial chunk of that. Why on earth would the project not be included in the internal audit plan?
I just point out that it was £4 million over two years.
That is still a substantial amount of your budget.
Yes. It was not included in the internal audit plan—
Why?
I cannot comment on that.
But you were heading up the organisation.
I was not.
You were not the accountable officer, but I think that you were next in line.
Yes, I was one of the members of the executive management team. The matter was not included in internal audit. The honest answer is that I do not know why. It will now be included in the next year. We are setting that out just now.
But the money has already been spent.
Yes.
So the question is one for the former chief executive, who we hoped to hear from today.
Yes.
The Audit Scotland report raises issues about governance of the SSSC and joint governance arrangements with the Care Inspectorate. Can you explain, briefly and in layman’s terms, the governance arrangements in your organisation?
We have a council that is made up of council members, who are appointed by the Scottish Government. We then have a resources committee and an audit committee, which are made up of council members. The chair of the Care Inspectorate also sits on our council, and our convener sits on the Care Inspectorate board. On our executive management team, we have a director of corporate services—at the moment, it is the head of shared services—who is 70 per cent Care Inspectorate and 30 per cent SSSC. That is how the shared services are dealt with at executive level. As I say, the chair and the convener sit on each other’s boards.
Are the governance arrangements fit for purpose?
The governance on shared services has not been fit for purpose, and there is now a focus on that. The arrangements have been too informal. I think that, because we share the same building, we have allowed the arrangements to become too informal, which has led to some of the challenges that we have faced. That is now a priority for us to deal with.
Is there a plan to reform the governance arrangements?
We have been discussing the issue with the Care Inspectorate and we feel that we need expert advice on that. We have asked the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy to carry out a review of the governance of the shared services, which will be delivered at the end of June, although we hoped to have it a bit sooner. We are meeting relevant people in the Care Inspectorate to look at the shared services strategy and the shared services risk register.
I want to say to the committee that the relationship between the SSSC and the Care Inspectorate is good, and we still have substantial shared services.
I will follow up the convener’s questions by asking about the role of the chair. Who is your chair, by the way?
Professor Jim McGoldrick is our convener.
What role did the chair and the council members play in overseeing the project?
The resources committee, which is made up of council members, made the decision to agree the tender for up to £5 million for the new systems—Interruption. Excuse my coughing. I will ask Maree Allison to finish the answer.
Take your time.
As Lorraine Gray said, the resources committee, which is made up of council members, made the decisions on the award of the contract for Sequence, on refreshing and upgrading our hardware, our laptops and our Microsoft Office 365 operating systems, on creating our own network, and on pulling out of the ICT shared service. The resources committee and council members made those critical decisions.
I presume that they took those decisions on the basis of recommendations from full-time staff.
Yes.
As a matter of interest, did the resources committee reject any of your recommendations at any time?
No.
What role did the committee play in monitoring the project?
We accept that that is one of the areas in which there could be improvement. There were reports to every council meeting. There was a bit of information in the chief executive’s report, and there was a bit in the budget report. We have now pulled things together, so that one report contains all the information. We accept that monitoring could have been better so, since October, our system has changed.
Did council members play a proactive part in monitoring the project?
Although they accepted our recommendations, they asked many challenging questions about the risks, about whether we could afford the project and about other options that we could have looked at. There was challenging scrutiny.
Once approval was given to the project and its budget, did council members proactively monitor progress and ask questions? Clearly, there must have been issues that arose. Were they referred to council members? Did they monitor the project closely?
They did, because the key decisions were made over a period of time. The decision on the original contract was made in 2017. The next key decision that the resources committee was involved in was made in December 2017, so there was scrutiny of the project at that time. The next decision was made in March 2018, and that involved scrutiny of the whole project. The final decision that the resources committee was involved in was in August 2018. As you can see from that timeline, the resources committee had oversight and the opportunity to ask challenging questions. However, as Lorraine Gray said, we did not ensure regular standardised reporting on the project’s progress, which would have allowed for more frequent scrutiny by the resources committee.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Mar 2019 →- 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 465
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.