Members will recall that the committee took evidence on the Conservation (Natural Habitats, &c) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2019last week from the Scottish Government and Scottish Natural Heritage. Does anyone have any comments?
I would like to let the committee know that I intend to lodge a motion to annul the regulations. In other words, I object to their being laid in the first place, and wish to pursue that objection, because I do not think that the case has been made for reintroducing beavers. Certainly, the harm that they do is becoming more and more apparent.
Obviously if our colleague lodges a motion to annul the instrument we will discuss that at the appropriate time. However, the regulations have nothing to do with the reintroduction of beavers, but are about managing the reintroduction that has already taken place. I see in our briefing note a long list of things that will not have any impact. The few that will, including
“Removing older dams ... Destroying lodges and chamber barrows ... Trapping and relocating beavers”
and
“Lethal control”
are already covered by existing cruelty to wildlife legislation. We will have the debate in due course, but I suspect that when we look at the effect of the regulations, we will see that they are simply systematising the existing situation. Right now, one cannot exercise lethal control of beavers haphazardly, randomly or cruelly, and the regulations merely create a framework within which lethal control can be operated as it is at the moment. I am therefore less than certain that I wish to support John Scott’s proposal.
I am disappointed to hear that there will be an attempt to stop the regulations becoming law. We have waited three years for protection of beavers to come in, and in that time there have been disastrous attempts to manage beaver populations by shooting pregnant animals and kits. Some serious welfare issues have arisen in connection with the matter, and there has been some strong lobbying to prevent the protection from being introduced, which has delayed things even further. I would not want the regulations to be delayed, especially given that we are in the middle of the kit-dependency season and there are—I am sure—interests out there shooting and killing animals as we speak.
I welcome clarification that the committee has had from SNH in the past couple of days on transparency in the proposed licensing regime. Quite frankly, we have a free-for-all at the moment, so I welcome the fact that there will be data based on local authority areas and the activities that will be permitted. The regime cannot be just a free-for-all; things have to be well understood and well controlled, and people must know that anyone who breaches the regime will be committing a wildlife crime.
I add that the data needs to be made available quarterly, given stakeholders’ concern that we will see the continuation of highly inappropriate lethal control, particularly during the kit-dependency season. If the data that SNH has committed to providing were to be made available quarterly, we would be able to assess whether a close season was in operation, which would be in the best interests of animal welfare. That is the missing bit that I want to see. If there is any way of getting more clarity from SNH on that matter, I will take that into consideration when we come to our final debate and—I hope—a successful vote to introduce the protection.
I thank everyone for their comments. We will continue our consideration of the instrument at a future meeting.
That concludes the committee’s public business. At its next meeting on 19 March, the committee will hear from the Scottish Land Commission on its current work programme.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.