Thank you for making your position clear.
As no other members want to comment, I will make a few remarks before the cabinet secretary sums up. I take seriously my role as convener in scrutinising the Scottish Government’s work on the delivery of social security. I hope that that was clear from the extensive questioning that I allowed Mr Griffin, given his specific interest in the issue.
I am sympathetic to an evidence-led methodical approach to considering what measures should be used to uprate thresholds and levels for benefits and entitlements. If the committee wishes to carry out work on that, we absolutely should do it. However, the details of the uprating of carers allowance and carers allowance supplement were provided to the committee on 12 December 2018, some 11 weeks ago, and it was not until the past couple of days that particular issues were raised.
I read the cabinet secretary’s letter when we received it, including the section on “Uprating in future years”, which clearly states that, when we move from carers allowance to carers assistance and the Scottish Government and Social Security Scotland take control of the benefit, the Scottish Commission on Social Security will have a statutory role. That seems an absolutely appropriate time for the committee to have a substantial look at the level of benefits and how they are uprated. That is the appropriate way for the committee to do our business, particularly given that we have had that information from the Scottish Government for the past 11 weeks.
The situation is disappointing, given that we are considering an investment of an additional £37 million that will go into the hands and pockets of carers, who do an amazing job. If we want to talk about the level of benefit, let us have that discussion, but that should be at budget time, when we can consider the consequences of any financial asks to the Government from back benchers or Opposition parties.
The figure that we have been given is that using the RPI would put an additional £3 million into the pockets of carers. If we are going to have a political discussion about how best to put £3 million into carers’ pockets, let us have a frank discussion about where that money comes from and the best way to spend it. Is that through changing the uprating mechanism, extending the young carers grant or looking at respite care for carers? We could consider a wider package to improve the lot of carers.
The committee absolutely has to continue to scrutinise without fear or favour in relation to the level of benefits and how they are uprated but, in my opinion, opposing an affirmative instrument when that opposition would, if successful, in effect mean less money and not more money for carers is an irresponsible way of doing business.
Ironically, I commend Mark Griffin for raising the wider issue. There are underlying discussions to be had in areas of scrutiny that our committee should engage with.
Others have had the opportunity to say where they stand in relation to the debate; that was my opportunity to put my thoughts on the record. It has been a high-quality debate and the cabinet secretary now has the opportunity to sum up.