Unofficial exclusion is, obviously, a difficult area to research, because it goes on under the radar, as it is unlawful. A school is not allowed to send a child home in those situations or say to parents that their child can come to school only if the parents will be around at break and lunch times—that has a devastating effect on parents’ ability to work.
There have been some freedom of information requests on what is called flexi-education, which seems to be growing in Scotland. Parents are told, “Please keep your child at home for three quarters of the week and we will call it home education.” The local authority passes responsibility to the parents for that proportion of the week. Clearly, there is absolutely no evidence of what is happening for those children. It is worrying—we just do not know, as there has not been any research.
My view on the special or mainstream education debate is that we certainly need special schools. There has not been a huge change in Scotland. The data shows that about 1 per cent of children have been in some sort of special setting for the past 50 years, so there has not been a mass dumping of children from special schools into mainstream education. There is sometimes a misapprehension about that. The issue is the capacity of mainstream schools to support children. As we have a reduction in additional support needs expertise in schools and in the number of classroom assistants, we will have more and more difficulties.
We must also acknowledge that some really good work is happening in Scotland. For example, most secondary schools now have special units attached to them called, for example, departments of additional support. When those are running well, children can move between mainstream and special education in a way that works well for them and for the other children in the class, who also have to be considered. When it does not work well, the child spends all their time in the special unit and could spend more time in the mainstream class. We need to learn from best practice and the local authorities that are doing a good job.
There is a tendency to say, “If we got rid of all these troublesome children and put them in special schools, all would be well,” but we must remember that some of the problems have been to do with what happens in special schools. You will remember that, before Christmas, there was a lot of concern about what was happening in a special school in Edinburgh for children with autistic spectrum disorder. The teachers were saying, “We can’t teach these children,” and the local authority said, “We’re sorry, but it’s in your contract to teach them.”
Many exclusions of children with additional support needs are from special schools, not mainstream schools. It is not simply a matter of thinking that, if we get rid of these troublesome children by putting them in special schools, all our problems will be over—that is absolutely not the case. We need the special and mainstream systems to work together and we need the mainstream system to be properly resourced.