Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

NHS Centre for Integrative Care (PE1568)

Tuesday 19 February 2019 Health and Sport Committee About 11:45 Petitions 14 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The second petition before us is PE1568, in the name of Catherine Hughes, on funding for, access to and promotion of the NHS centre for integrative care. The petition was lodged on 12 May 2015.

Members will be aware that, as is detailed in today’s public papers, the committee agreed at our meeting on 15 November 2016 to invite the Scottish Health Council to give oral evidence on its general input and approach to consultations of the type being run in this case, as well as on its involvement in the classification of major service changes. I wrote to the chief executive of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde on 28 November 2018 to request an update on the centre and on whether any further changes to the service were anticipated. The response from NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is included in today’s papers, along with letters in support of the petition from Elaine Smith MSP, the British Homeopathic Association and other concerned parties, including the petitioner herself.

I invite comments from colleagues.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

I thank the petitioners, the campaigners and those who have sent us correspondence. Catherine Hughes and her mother are here today; I know that they have not been well over the winter, so it is good to see them here.

There is a lot of important work that we still need to take forward. I am a co-chair of the cross-party group on chronic pain, and I know that Elaine Smith’s correspondence raises on-going issues relating to the variation in treatment available across Scotland. As the Friends of the Centre for Integrative Care has outlined, keeping the petition open would allow time for correspondence to continue and investigations to take place, so I would be reluctant to close it. I look towards the work of the cross-party group, but also towards any work that our committee could undertake on the matter.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Further to Miles Briggs’s comments, I chair the cross-party group on arthritis and musculoskeletal conditions, which does quite a lot of work with the cross-party group on chronic pain. As always seems to be the case, there is—without question—a much bigger piece of work to be done. A much bigger outcome is possible; the question is how to fit it in and whether it should be dealt with by cross-party groups or by our committee.

Alex Cole-Hamilton LD Edinburgh Western
link

Unlike PE1611, PE1568 will not be followed by a glut of similar petitions to the Public Petitions Committee; it relates to a stand-alone issue. I am anxious about closing it, because that would suggest that the issue had been resolved. I am not sure that we are at that stage yet, or anywhere near it, so I endorse Miles Briggs’s recommendation that we keep the petition open.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

As I said earlier, I have been involved in this area with others for around the past 10 years. It concerns me that the petition was lodged in 2015 but has just come to the Health and Sport Committee now, four years down the line. That alone is a concern for me.

Many issues have been raised. One person says that the out-patient service is still open whereas somebody else says that it is closed. We need evidence of exactly what is happening.

I refer to what Brian Whittle said. In the evidence session earlier, we talked about the integration of health and social care. The issue should be part of that. There is a much bigger issue.

I do not know how we can move on with the petition. Miles Briggs mentioned the cross-party group on chronic pain, which I know about. Dorothy-Grace Elder has also been involved in it. Perhaps the issue could be discussed there.

I am pretty loth to close the petition, but I do not know where we can go with it. It is not just about the centre at Gartnavel; it is about much bigger integration. A counselling and dietary service is mentioned. Surely that should be provided in every health authority.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For clarity, the petition was lodged in 2015 and referred to this committee, and the committee took evidence in 2016. We pursued the issue last year, as well. Therefore, the petition has not arrived at the committee for the first time.

The committee has to decide whether there is anything further that it can add to the consideration of the specific matter.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

Over the past couple of years as an MSP, I have attended many events in my constituency and in the Parliament that have been related to different aspects of pain management, myalgic encephalomyelitis and fibromyalgia, which are related to the petition. My main focus is on evidence-based approaches to the delivery of best care, whether in the community or health service settings, and I am reluctant to simply close the petition without seeing a resolution. I am interested in a way to ensure that we have the wider ability to look at all the other issues that have come forward in the past couple of years.

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Like other members, I, too, have served on the Public Petitions Committee for a number of years. I praise the work that Catherine Hughes has done in the petition and endorse the thorough letter that Elaine Smith has issued, albeit at the 11th hour. She has made a very strong point. She said that it is

“vital that this petition remains open so that we can put patients first”.

She also stressed that the problem is Scotland wide and not just to do with a local area.

I agree with the comments that colleagues have made.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

There must be some way in which to pull together the work that various groups have done on the topic into something a little more cohesive. There is not much point in repeating the work that has already been done. I would look for the committee not necessarily to do a great bit of investigation but perhaps to be a catalyst to pull together a lot of the work that has been done into something a bit more solid and cohesive.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

The Scottish Government has outlined an advisory group that is meant to be undertaking work on postcode lottery issues, so there is an opportunity. That information has not been made available to the cross-party group. I welcome the fact that the cabinet secretary will come to our cross-party group to outline some of that work, but there is an opportunity to use what the petition looks at to ask the Scottish Government what it will do with what comes out of the advisory group. It is important for the outcome of the petition to find out where the future of the centre for integrative care sits. That would be useful for the petitioner to see whether there are questions in the petition that we could take forward with the Government.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Emma Harper should be very brief.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

I will be.

I am reminded that, the week before last week, I attended an event about migraines. How we support people with migraines is a postcode lottery. That issue is along the same lines. We should consider a whole, integrated approach that supports people throughout Scotland.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It is clear that the committee does not wish to close the petition. However, rather than coming back to the petition again in a year’s time to ask what has happened in the previous 12 months, I suggest that we write to the cross-party groups that have an interest in the matter—at least two such groups have been mentioned—to say that the Health and Sport Committee is keen to understand what they can do to advance the issues that have been raised, and to ask them to report back to us. On receipt of those replies, we can make a judgment on what we can usefully add. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We move into private session.

12:15 Meeting continued in private until 12:29.

  1. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  3. 10:00 “Ministerial Strategic Group for Health and Community Care, Review of Progress with Integration of Health and Social Care—Final Report” Evidence session · 92
  4. 11:45 Petitions Petitions · 9
  5. 11:45 Petitions Petitions · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.