Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

ScotRail

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 7 February 2019 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 4 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

4 contributions
Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

It has been another bad day on Scotland’s railway, with power and signal failures causing disruption in Glasgow. Sadly, that is a typical experience. Over the weekend, passengers took to social media to share their experience of delays, cancellations and overcrowding. They posted pictures of people with disabilities going without a seat and of children sitting on the floor outside a train toilet. A passenger was also reported to have had a panic attack.

That is not acceptable or safe and is not what people in Scotland deserve from their railway. What action did the Government take following last weekend’s appalling performance by ScotRail? How long will it be before we have a rail service that is run in the public interest and meets the public’s needs?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Perthshire North
link

First, the Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity has made it clear to Parliament that the Government considers ScotRail’s current performance to be unacceptable. For that reason, Transport Scotland issued a formal notification to ScotRail on 24 December to require it to submit a remedial plan by 18 February. The Government will hold ScotRail to that.

We expect ScotRail to set out in that plan how it will address the performance issues to ensure that we realise the benefits of the formidable investment that has been made in recent periods in new rolling stock and new infrastructure.

Parliament is familiar with some of the operational challenges around the delay in new rolling stock, which has affected the ability of the service to operate as we would have expected. Because of that delay, there have been implications for the training of staff to operate the railway safely.

Mr Harvie raises specific examples from the past weekend. ScotRail took a number of decisions to expand capacity on a number of routes because of the expectations of higher traveller numbers, particularly because of the rugby international match in Edinburgh. However, other issues were of concern in the performance of ScotRail at the weekend. Those are the issues that the Government expects ScotRail to address. The transport secretary is, at all times, in active dialogue with ScotRail, in order to improve that performance and to require ScotRail to comply with the remedial order that the Government has applied.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

When the plan for remediation of those persistent failures is presented to us, I am sure that the Parliament will hold both ScotRail and the Government to account.

There is a need for wider structural change. For example, many of us agree that Network Rail needs to be in Scotland’s control, so that we can have a truly joined-up approach to the issues. However, we cannot wait for that; it is no excuse for not taking action now.

Three months ago, when many of the failures were already being regularly reported, the Government voted against using the break point in the ScotRail franchise next year. If the Government was not convinced then, it should be convinced now that that option must remain on the table. Surely the Deputy First Minister will not rule out that option, given that doing so would give Abellio a free pass to continue failing. The Government must work on the assumption that, from next year, a public sector bidder may be needed.

What progress is being made on the urgently needed preparation for a public rail operator that will operate the railways in the public interest?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Perthshire North
link

Some elements of Patrick Harvie’s question are more straightforward than others. On his point about devolution of responsibilities around Network Rail, I agree with him. It makes eminent common sense for that to be the case, because it would allow us to take forward the co-operation that exists within the ScotRail Alliance to a much deeper level of integration. Politics aside, there is a commonsense approach in taking that forward.

On the application of a break clause, if an operator of last resort was to replace ScotRail in 2020, that could be only a temporary measure. Under the current United Kingdom legislation, the requirement to tender the franchise would remain. That would then open up the possibility, which we have now secured as a Government, to bring forward a competitive public sector bid in that context.

Development work is under way about how to advance the concept of a competitive public sector bid. That work is being taken forward by the transport secretary, in dialogue with David MacBrayne Ltd, which we have invited to take forward some of that work. If the transport secretary has not already answered questions on that subject, I am sure that he will update Parliament on all those questions in due course.

Fundamentally, the Government believes that we must have an efficient rail network that meets the needs of individuals in Scotland, that acts in the public interest and that delivers services that members of the public are looking for. Our immediate, short-term action is focused on achieving that; we are open to developing a competitive public sector bid within the context of the existing UK legislation, within which we must operate.

  1. Bank Branch Closures Questions · 6
  2. St John’s Hospital Parking Questions · 4
  3. Energy Performance Certificates Questions · 10
  4. Cumbernauld Village Surgery Closure Questions · 6
  5. Mental Health Services Budget Questions · 4
  6. Local Councillors Pay Questions · 4
  7. Tenant Farming Commissioner (Meetings) Questions · 4
  8. Workplace Parking Levy First Minister’s Questions · 9
  9. Accident and Emergency Waiting Times First Minister’s Questions · 7
  10. O2 ABC (Demolition) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route First Minister’s Questions · 2
  12. Texas Instruments First Minister’s Questions · 2
  13. ScotRail First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Workplace Parking Levy First Minister’s Questions · 2
  15. Cannabis-based Treatment Delay First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Ramsar Sites (Protection) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  17. Musical Instrument Tuition First Minister’s Questions · 8
  18. Workplace Parking Levy (Public Sector) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  19. Children’s Mental Health Week First Minister’s Questions · 5
  20. Kilmarnock Football Club 150th Anniversary Debate · 24
  21. Glasgow Airport Access Project Statement · 43
  22. Management of Offenders (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 76
  23. Management of Offenders (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 1
  24. Decision Time Decision time · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.