Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Private Criminal Prosecutions (PE1633)

Tuesday 5 February 2019 Justice Committee About 10:00 Petitions 12 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The next petition is PE1633, by Bill Alexander, on private criminal prosecution in Scotland. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament

“to urge the Scottish Government to change the law to give the people of Scotland the same legal rights as the rest of the United Kingdom by removing the requirement that the Lord Advocate must first give permission before a private criminal prosecution can be commenced in Scotland.”

Before today’s consideration of the petition, the clerk sought views from the petitioner and from the Lord Advocate. I refer members to annex B of paper 4, which contains the responses. The committee is asked to consider the responses and decide what further action, if any, it wishes to take in relation to the petition. The options available include: keeping the petition open; keeping it open and taking additional action; or closing the petition. I seek members’ views.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I declare an interest, in that the petitioner is a constituent of mine.

There is definitely an issue. I read the Lord Advocate’s letter to the convener and I understand the points that he makes. However, of the six questions that the petitioner poses in his submission, I think that it would be reasonable to follow up questions 1 and 4. The Health and Safety Executive is a reserved body. In question 1, the petitioner asks:

“If the Health and Safety Executive will not be accountable to the Scottish parliament, then can the relevant committee at the Westminster Parliament be asked to enquire from the Health and Safety Executive why they have adopted a different policy in regard to risk assessments and reporting injuries for sporting event workers from all other workers, and what evidence they have to support their decision.”

Question 4 asks whether the Lord Advocate can clarify

“whether or not the policies of the Health and Safety Executive in regard to sports workers being considered in a different manner to all other workers is compatible with Article 2 of the Human Rights Act.”

Obviously, there are other questions, but those are the ones that I thought that it would be most pertinent for us to follow up. I think that the matter is worth pursuing, but I am open to comments from other members.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Certain issues around health and safety may indeed be reserved, but that does not preclude this committee from writing to the HSE and cutting out a middle committee. Asking about the policy position with regard to that specific group of workers is a reasonable—indeed, neutral—question. I suggest that, rather than writing to a Westminster committee, we simply write to the HSE ourselves. I am sure that we will get a courteous answer; if, for any reason, we do not, I am sure that we can follow that up.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I seek some clarification. It is my understanding that the petition was originally set out on the basis that the Lord Advocate had to give permission before a private prosecution could go ahead. However, if my understanding is correct, the Lord Advocate has now clarified the position and has stated that he will give a view but that he does not have a veto, and that there can be an appeal. Effectively, that means that he does not have to give permission, although obviously his opinion carries great weight. Is my understanding correct?

Stephen Imrie Clerk
link

The original terms of the petition covered whether the permission of the Lord Advocate was required for a private prosecution. We have set that out in various papers, and the Lord Advocate’s letter to the committee touches on that point, too.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Yes. The difficulty for me is that we have been given a petition whose premise has not proved to be the case. Therefore, I have some difficulty with carrying on and making inquiries. It seems to me that perhaps a new petition should be submitted if there are other issues that people want to follow-up. Of course, I will defer to members’ views, but had you considered that point, Rona?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

As the clerk was talking, the possibility of there being a new petition was going through my mind. I do not know whether it is administratively possible to continue with inquiries in relation to this petition.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Again, the difficulty that I have is that we might be setting a precedent if we go on and look at issues that are related to a petition even though the assertion in the original petition is not correct. If we do that, where will we end up?

The question that was asked has been answered: the Lord Advocate has said that he can choose to give a view, which will carry a lot of weight, but that he cannot refuse permission. In view of what has been said, are we content to close the petition and notify the petitioner that, if he wants to bring up other issues, he could choose to submit a fresh petition?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I think that the points that the petitioner has raised with regard to the safety of sports workers are important. However, perhaps they would be better pursued through a new petition.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

Is there perhaps a middle way? I accept the points that you make, convener, about the premise of the petition and the question having been answered. However, surely if issues have been raised with us by whatever means, it is open to us to ask questions about them. We might choose to close the petition, but it might be relevant for us to pursue with the HSE the issue that has been raised, and to pursue with the Lord Advocate the issue in question 4, regardless of where the suggestion came from.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I agree with Daniel Johnson. In relation to the legislation that we are discussing, there is the potential for both criminal and civil matters to arise. When we examined the role that health and safety legislation plays in relation to fatal accident inquiries, we encountered similar issues. Out of what is, at the very minimum, idle curiosity on my part, it would be helpful to understand more about the issues, although I accept that the petition could be closed.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That might be a useful halfway house. We could close the petition and write letters to get the answers that the petitioner seeks to those questions, which are not directly connected to his petition, and ensure that he gets a response. Are we content with that approach?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. 10:00 European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 Committee business · 2
  4. 10:00 Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 10:00 Petitions Petitions · 12
  6. 10:00 Justice Sub-Committee on Policing (Report Back) Committee business · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.