I have said recently that, given the stalemate in the UK Parliament, a referendum seems to be the obvious way forward. I will expand on that slightly, as it is important. Had the negotiations been approached differently, with different or lesser red lines on the part of the UK, a softer Brexit might have had a consensus in Parliament. At the moment, the difficulty with a softer Brexit such as a Norway-plus solution—although we might still end up with that—is that it would need to be enacted through the existing withdrawal agreement or something like it. The withdrawal agreement would not need to be modified substantively. There could be a political declaration that changed the direction of travel on the future framework, in essence saying that there were no longer red lines on freedom of movement and that we hoped to end up with Norway plus.
The problem with that is that, because the political situation in the UK is so unstable, the EU27 would wonder who would actually be in charge of the negotiations following approval of the withdrawal agreement. If, for instance, there was a Prime Minister who was much more on the Brexit side of the Conservative Party, there would be no guarantee on where we would end up. Therefore, such a commitment is more difficult now whereas, if we had begun on a route of European Economic Area plus two years ago, we might have ended up with that. That is why people like me are saying that, given the stalemate, a people’s vote may be the only way to try to reverse the result of the referendum in 2016 and break the deadlock.
However, Akash Paun is absolutely right that there is no clear majority for any alternative at the moment. The situation is very fluid and we will see what happens next week. As Claire Baker says, the referendum would need to be framed appropriately, and again that depends on the parliamentary majority. One possibility is that the Prime Minister says, “Parliament has rejected the deal that we have negotiated, but there is no consensus on what the alternative might be, so I will go to the country with my deal.” Logically, at that point, the alternatives would be her deal and remain, which of course would create difficulties for those who believe that there should be a harsher withdrawal deal.
That is where the issue gets really complicated. We are in the hands of what happens in Parliament. I accept what Akash Paun said about the timing of the referendum. However, the sense that I get in Brussels from EU27 Governments is that, of all the possible scenarios around the extension of article 50, a new referendum, especially given what the polls indicate, is the one that is most likely to result in a sympathetic hearing of a request for an extension. A possible reversal by the people of their decision in 2016 would be seen as the best way forward and, as a result, the EU27 would try their utmost not only to grant an extension but to find ways around the European Parliament issue that we discussed a moment ago.