Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2017/18 audit of NHS Tayside”

Thursday 17 January 2019 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–11:00 Committee business 275 contributions · 16 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

275 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 2 is on the section 22 report “The 2017/18 audit of NHS Tayside”. I welcome our witnesses: John Brown, who is the chair of NHS Tayside; Malcolm Wright, who is the former chief executive of NHS Tayside; Alan Gray, who is the director of finance at NHS Tayside; Dr Annie Ingram, who is the strategic director of workforce at NHS Tayside; and Hazel Craik, who is the head of employment at the central legal office. I invite John Brown to make a brief opening statement.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I thank the committee for this opportunity to respond to the Auditor General for Scotland’s report on the 2017-18 audit of NHS Tayside. I also thank the convener for agreeing that our finance director and workforce director could attend to assist the chief executive and me in assuring the committee about the progress that we are making to stabilise our financial position and develop the capability and capacity to deliver the service changes that are required in NHS Tayside to improve our performance and achieve financial sustainability in the longer term.

Hazel Craik from the central legal office has been the principal adviser to the board on the handling of the departure of Lesley McLay, the former chief executive. I realise that her departure has been a matter of concern for the committee, and my colleagues and I will do our utmost today to respond to those concerns as fully as possible.

I hope that the Auditor General’s report, the report that the committee received from the assurance and advisory group and the written submission that NHS Tayside sent in last week will give the committee a good insight not only into the 2017-18 audit, but into the work of the interim leadership team since we took over in 2018.

I will summarise what we believe to be the situation in Tayside as we speak. Before I do that, it is right to record that the board fully accepts the audit report as an accurate description of the 2017-18 financial position and the performance that was delivered by NHS Tayside up to March 2018. I also say up front that, although we note that the Auditor General has acknowledged that the agreement that NHS Tayside reached with the former chief executive was reasonable, we accept that mistakes were made. I apologise for those errors. I confirm that the remuneration committee has met and endorsed the decision to change the former chief executive’s notice period, and that the overpayment of funds to the NHS Scotland pension scheme has been returned to NHS Tayside.

The biggest challenge that was faced by our interim leadership team was not handling the departure of the former chief executive, but bringing financial stability to NHS Tayside and developing the plans to deliver the service changes that are required to bring NHS Tayside into financial balance, while improving performance. I am sure that we will touch on all those issues as we go through the papers this morning.

The committee will note from the papers that we believe that NHS Tayside’s financial position has stabilised and that the challenge that we now face is to deliver the changes that are required to improve that position. As well as improving access to our services, we need to improve our mental health services in particular, integrate health and social care at a bit more pace and develop the workforce that is required to support that. However, those are challenges that we share with all Scotland’s boards.

As the Auditor General and the assurance and advisory group have acknowledged, so far, the interim leadership team has done a lot of work to understand the provision and costs of services in Tayside, and we are now turning that work into action plans for change. That is our priority. At its February meeting, the board will review the progress that the leadership team has made towards delivering our plans for not only next year but the next three years. The level of change that we are talking about will not happen overnight. There is a long history of problems at NHS Tayside—it goes back six years—so I think that three years is realistic when it comes to our ambition to be in financial balance and to improve our performance.

I put on record my appreciation for all the hard work and commitment that the interim chief executive, Malcolm Wright, and the rest of the interim leadership team have put into taking NHS Tayside forward. I particularly thank all the staff across NHS Tayside, who have worked so hard over the past nine months to turn things around. I make special mention of the clinicians, who have played a crucial role by getting involved in redesigning our services. It would be remiss of me not to mention our colleagues in NHS Grampian and NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, who have supported me, Malcolm Wright, Annie Ingram and Alan Gray as we have had responsibilities across two boards. Without their support, we could not have delivered on that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Mr Brown. I will open the questioning by asking about the payment that was made to the former chief executive. It would be useful to get some clarity on that. It is the committee’s job to follow the public pound. On behalf of the public, we scrutinise public spending and the effective use of their taxes.

For a number of years—this predates my convenership—the committee has been clear in expressing its concern about golden handshakes and large severance payments in the public sector. During our scrutiny of the previous section 22 report on NHS Tayside and the one that is before us today, the committee has probably put on the record no fewer than six times that it did not want enhanced severance payments or golden handshakes to be offered to any members of management in NHS Tayside. However, the Auditor General’s report makes it clear that that is exactly what happened. We have information from the Auditor General’s report and other documents that gives us a bit of insight into the situation. It is our understanding—I think that it is yours, too—that a payment was made in lieu of notice. The notice period in the former chief executive’s contract was three months, but it seems to have been increased to six months. How and why did that happen?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The best person to talk us through how we came to the decision that it was appropriate for the notice period to be extended from three to six months is probably the accountable officer, who is sitting on my right.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I acknowledge—straight up—what the Auditor General has said in her report and in the evidence that she led at the committee meeting when the issue was discussed. The key question was about whether we should have sought to negotiate a settlement, and the Auditor General has agreed that seeking to negotiate a settlement was a reasonable decision to make. As accountable officer, I need to balance risk and achieve the best possible value for the public purse. The advice that I received, which I have examined carefully and which I believe to be correct, was that there were risks facing the board that would have ended up costing significantly more money than that eventually paid out, which was about £32,000.

I am happy to go into the detail on the background to that, but I think that negotiating a settlement was a reasonable decision to take. The Auditor General said:

“given the balance of risks facing the board, to have agreed a settlement period of six months would not have been unreasonable”.—Official Report, Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee, 13 December 2018; c 6.

On the order of the settlement that was made and the balance of risks that the board faced, there was a real risk that the level of public expenditure on defending potential claims against the board would be significantly greater than what was actually settled for.

I also concur with the Auditor General that there was a fundamental misunderstanding in the board that six months was the standard notice period and that a notice period could be increased without going to the remuneration committee. That was a misunderstanding and an error. As the accountable officer, I apologise to the committee for that taking place.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For clarification, are you telling the committee that you were aware that the contractual entitlement was three months and that you increased it to six months as part of the settlement agreement?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

That is correct. That was part of the negotiation with the solicitors for the former chief executive. Hazel Craik can add to that point about what the outcome would have otherwise been.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is it normal practice to change contractual entitlements when you are negotiating a settlement agreement?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I ask Hazel Craik to comment on that. My point is that we were making a set of decisions on the basis of risk and seeking to minimise additional expenditure to the public purse. The eventual settlement of about £32,000 was significantly less than what we would have had to pay out in different ways if legal claims were to have been made.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So, it was not a mistake; it was an intentional decision by the board to change the former chief executive’s contractual entitlement from three to six months. Is that correct?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

That is correct, and—to be clear—there was a fundamental misunderstanding that six months was the standard notice period for chief executives. That goes back to a circular that was written in 2006 that laid out a standard notice period for chief executives. That circular was never actually issued. The final circular that was issued said that the period should be between three and six months and that anything over three months needed to be approved by the remuneration committee.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You wanted to settle. You looked at the contract, saw that the notice period was three months and you thought, “Well, other chief executives in Scotland have six months in their contract, so we will increase it to six.”

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

No—it was not as straightforward as that. I will bring in Hazel Craik on the legal discussions that took place.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I became involved in advising on the matter at around the time when the board was dealing with the process that might have led to termination of the contract. At that point, there was communication from the solicitors for the former chief executive. It was clear that there was not going to be co-operation with that process, and various potential legal challenges were mentioned as a possibility. There was a discussion about how that letter would be responded to, and one decision was that a telephone call would be made to those solicitors.

09:15

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could you move to the point about the three and six months? I realise that there is probably a lot of background information, but we need to use the committee’s time efficiently this morning.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

As part of the conversation between solicitors, which obviously I am not at liberty to discuss, one issue that was raised was a six-month notice period and an understanding that that was the norm for chief executives. That was fed back to the board and, thereafter, decisions were taken to conclude a settlement agreement on that basis.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am not sure that I completely follow. As the legal adviser to NHS Tayside, you were aware that the contract stated three months as the notice period, but you advised that, because other chief executives in Scotland had six months in their contracts, it would be okay for that entitlement to be increased. Is that correct?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

No, not entirely. I was aware that the contract stated three months and that various challenges were being made by the solicitors for the former chief executive. There was a discussion, and one of the proposed solutions to go to the negotiation was to offer a six-month notice period. I took back that matter to the board. There was discussion and, having weighed up the risks, a decision was made that it was reasonable to conclude a settlement agreement on the basis of a six-month notice period.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

NHS Tayside took the position that the contractual entitlement was to three months, but it was decided to increase that to six months, as part of the settlement agreement. You took advice from lawyers and that was the decision that you came to.

There are another couple of points of confusion. John Brown has been involved with NHS boards for many years and chairs the NHS Tayside remuneration committee. How did you not know that a variation in contract such as that had to be passed by the remuneration committee?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The circular that made that requirement was issued in 2006. I have been a chairman of boards in the national health service for the past three years, so it predated me. I have never been in a situation in which a chief executive has left a board in such circumstances, so I was unaware that that requirement existed.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You did not know about the rule that such a change had to go through the remuneration committee.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

No. Had I known that the rule existed, I would have taken the variation in contract to the remuneration committee, which would have considered it. When I was advised by Audit Scotland of the existence of the circular that required that matter to go to the remuneration committee, I took it to the committee, which considered it and agreed that the decision to enter the negotiation was the right step to take, and that it was reasonable to extend the entitlement period.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You wrote to me on 7 August 2018. The letter, which was copied to other North East Scotland members of Parliament, stated:

“All payments are legal and contractual entitlements and no additional payments have or will be made by NHS Tayside.”

As of 7 August last year, that statement was not correct, was it?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

It was correct.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How could it be correct when you did not get approval from the remuneration committee to vary the contract until November?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

That is because the contract settlement agreement, which you have had sight of, supersedes any previous contracts. That was agreed and became legal and contractual on 28 June, which was prior to the former chief executive’s resignation on 31 July. That is the legal advice that we have had and was the basis of the letter. The background to the letter was that there was a great deal of concern following media reports that the former chief executive had received £300,000 as a severance payment.

Because of the requirement to protect personal information, we were not in a position to put the actual amount of the settlement into the public domain. However, because of the concerns of the public and Tayside staff, I decided that we would give them some comfort by writing to the committee given that the media coverage said that the committee would want to be involved.

The intention of the letter and the intention behind copying it to other relevant MSPs was to give the public and Tayside staff the confidence that, whatever payments were going to the former chief executive, they would be subject to scrutiny.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Yes. There was a great deal of concern because there was a lack of transparency around the former chief executive’s exit. The committee had been clear, and I do not think that the public in Tayside were looking for a golden handshake for a former chief executive who had presided over severe financial mismanagement on the part of the board.

I have a final question on this. You made a submission to the committee for this morning’s meeting, which was helpful. However, I was slightly concerned by some of its content. At paragraphs 2.10 and 2.11, you seem to suggest that the error was in not putting the change to the remuneration committee rather than the error being the change from three to six months. Do you stand by that?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes. I believe that the accountable officer made a reasonable decision to enter into a negotiation, given the risks of the additional financial burden for the board if the situation lasted much longer. It was reasonable to bring the notice period for the former chief executive of Tayside in line with the norm for other territorial boards.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do you think that that is reasonable, Mr Brown? As I just said, the former chief executive presided over a board that was in financial chaos, that now owes the Scottish Government £60 million and that is way behind on all governance performance targets. I do not think that the public in Dundee and the wider region of Tayside think that that is reasonable. The increase that you put on this golden handshake is equivalent to the annual salary of a teacher in a Dundee primary school. How is that a reasonable decision?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

You have to balance the cost of going down that route against the cost of the alternative route. The accountable officer and the board have a responsibility to the public purse to ensure that public funds are spent in the best possible manner.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

On that point about risk, my colleague Liam Kerr has some questions.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I want to go back to Mr Wright on this. You have said at some length that a whole load of risk has been mitigated as a result of these decisions. As far as you are concerned, Mr Wright, when this decision was made, what was the nature of those risks? What claim did you feel NHS Tayside would face? What was the value of that claim, in your mind?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

Some of that is outlined in the business case that went to the Scottish Government. I know that there has been criticism that there could have been more information in that business case, and I apologise for that.

I will outline some of the risks that we were aware of. First, there had already been a delay in the process because the former chief executive had had a period of medically certified sickness absence. That had delayed the start of formal proceedings. Secondly, solicitors acting for the former chief executive had formally declined a request for the former chief executive to come to a meeting with the board to discuss future employment—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Forgive me for interrupting, but what was the employment tribunal claim that you believed that NHS Tayside would face? What was the value of that claim when the board took the decision to sign off on the payment?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I will ask Hazel Craik to come in on the details of the claim, but the value of the claim and the costs of defending it were in the region of £90,000 to £110,000.

Without making any comment on the merits of whatever legal case might be brought, I point out that, if it had gone to an employment tribunal, the caps would have been lifted on the value of the settlement that the tribunal could give for claims based on age or sex discrimination.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That is my point, Mr Wright. Were you facing a claim for age or sex discrimination, or was it for unfair and/or constructive dismissal, which would be capped at significantly less than £90,000 to £110,000?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

We were facing the prospect of claims. I will ask Hazel Craik to talk the committee through that.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The board started down the route of planning to invite the chief executive in to explore the fact that accountable officer status had been removed, which rendered her job impossible to perform. That meant that the board was not in a normal process—a disciplinary process, for example—but it still needed a fair process for the dismissal of an employee. The board was hoping to progress down that route when it received correspondence from the solicitors for the former chief executive, which said that she would not attend meetings about the matter, suggested that she felt that she had been mistreated due to her sex and age, and raised other matters.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Did she ever offer to resign?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

Not while I was dealing with the matter.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I am not aware of her offering to resign.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Dr Ingram, did you have any involvement in the matter?

Dr Annie Ingram NHS Tayside
link

Yes, I did. She offered to resign at the beginning, on 9 April. I was asked to contact her solicitors, and at that time she offered to resign. We then had communication through the CLO that her solicitors felt that she was unwell and unable to make an informed decision; that was when she went on a period of sick leave. After we received the letter that Ms Craik referred to, there was a conversation between the solicitors and representatives from the CLO, from which the request came that she would resign if the board would agree to payment in lieu of six months’ notice.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That is interesting. I might come back to that, but I want to reflect on what you have just said.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I want to follow up on this because, although there is nothing that we can do about turning back the clock in this case, it seems to me that there are some systemic issues to be addressed. The fact that the chair of the remuneration committee was not advised by the full-time officers about the circular in 2006 is an example of an unacceptable failure to support the chair, in my view. Full-time officers in the legal office and the finance and audit departments are there to advise non-executive directors about circulars that went around long before they took up position. That is one small example of systemic failure.

I want to probe the matter a bit with Dr Graham. You say that the chief executive offered to resign at the beginning of April. Can you give us a timeline of what happened thereafter? Did anybody accept her resignation? Was it discussed by the board or with the minister? When did you receive the subsequent letter that appears to have withdrawn the resignation unless she got the six months’ pay? What was the timeline and sequence of all that?

Dr Ingram
link

Did you mean to say Dr Ingram? You said Dr Graham; did you mean me?

Dr Ingram
link

The timeline was that accountable officer status was removed on 6 April—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

By the cabinet secretary?

Dr Ingram
link

By Paul Gray.

Dr Ingram
link

That is a matter for Scottish Government colleagues. I was asked by my lead in the Scottish Government to make contact with the solicitors with a view to seeing whether we could come to a settlement—whether she would resign, because that was where we thought it was going.

As I have just said, I contacted the solicitors, and initially there was an offer that she would resign. She was then unwell, and her solicitors gave advice to our solicitors that it would not be appropriate for her to make a decision because her solicitors believed that she was not well enough; there was a medical certificate to confirm that.

09:30

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

What was the time gap between the offer to resign and—

Dr Ingram
link

Two days.

Dr Ingram
link

She was then off sick for a long time, and following that there were discussions about whether we could find alternative employment for her. That was not possible.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Within the national health service or within NHS Tayside?

Dr Ingram
link

Within the national health service, but mainly within NHS Tayside because, as you know, we are independent employers.

Thereafter the chair, as has been mentioned, invited Ms McLay to come to a meeting on 14 June. That meeting was to consider whether we would terminate her employment. A board meeting was set for 28 June, at which point we had a paper ready to go to the board requesting that we would terminate her employment.

On 8 June, we got the letter from the legal advisers indicating that she was not going to come to the meeting, as Ms Craik has said, and thereafter there was a conversation with her lawyers. At that point, Ms McLay offered to resign if the board would consider the six months’ pay.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

There is loads in there. A lot of this is absolutely new to the committee, which is, to be frank, totally unacceptable.

I will ask two questions given what has been said. First, how many porters in the NHS who are sacked because of their lack of performance then get offered another job in the health service? This is something that has always angered me about the health service. There are jobs for the boys at the top but the people at the bottom are not treated in anything like the same way. Why was somebody being offered alternative employment given the circumstances surrounding the case and the history of what would appear to be financial mismanagement?

I think that my second question is for Ms Craik. It goes back to Liam Kerr’s point. A clear calculation was made that, if the case was allowed to go to an employment tribunal, you would lose. You are shaking your head and saying no. In that case, why did you cave in? Why did you settle so quickly? It was public money that you were dealing with.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to that. A process was on-going but there was definitely a lack of engagement. I know from my experience of dealing with a lot of disputes involving not chief executives but health service employees that it often takes some time—weeks or months—for matters to move on. At the end of the day, we need a fair process to terminate somebody’s employment, so it can take time. That was one consideration.

An option can arrive whereby it is possible to conclude matters at a particular date—at a particular time. If we do not do that, we still need to pursue the process, and it may be that that will take some time. I think that it would have taken some time to do that. There is a risk that the process will take some time, and that costs money.

The second risk was that the solicitors for the former chief executive said that they had challenges in relation to sex discrimination and age discrimination as well as the process that we were proposing to adopt for termination. It is correct to say that we do not know the detail of what those claims would have been. I see that Mr Kerr is looking at me in relation to that—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Well, quite. If I may, I will come in here. I presume that you signed off the business case. I think that Mr Wright had a figure in his mind that was presented to him, but you had not assessed what the claim might be.

I am hearing that there was a possibility of a resignation, so I am thinking, “Okay—constructive dismissal, with a cap at 80-odd grand.” However, then I hear that the business case came forward and people talked about discrimination, so the cap was removed, but you did not assess whether there was a discrimination claim. Am I correct, Ms Craik?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

From the statement that was made by Lesley McLay’s solicitors, we know that she had concerns and thought that she was unfairly treated due to her sex and age. She questioned the process that we were adopting to terminate her employment. In my mind, that raised the risk of three different types of claim being raised: one for sex discrimination, one for age discrimination and one for unfair dismissal.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

With respect, I think that Mr Neil’s point is that it is the CLO’s job to assess the strength of such claims. A claimant’s solicitor will, of course, say that the claimant has the strongest claim in the world and therefore they will win all this money. Is it not the job of the CLO to assess the claim and say, “Actually, Mr Wright, this isn’t the strongest claim ever—I don’t think you’re in the hole for north of £100,000. We could proceed in a much more sensible way”?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

You are right that the job of the CLO is to weigh up the risks. The risk that I perceived there to be was of a claim, or claims, being raised. Whatever the merit of those claims, they would be defended, so time would be taken in defending them and costs would be incurred in doing so.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Does that not send out completely the wrong message? The message that you are sending out is that anybody who is vexatious in the health service—there are very few of those people because the vast bulk of people in the health service are dedicated servants who would not behave in such a way—should just cry foul and say, “I was sacked because of my gender”, “I was sacked because I was late for work” or “I was sacked unfairly, so the CLO will settle and double my contract in order to prevent a scandal.” That is absurd. Surely you must demonstrate to people that, if anybody makes a false claim, you will go to the tribunal and fight the claim. If you lose it, you lose it, but you should not be a soft touch. You are using public money.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

Every year, the CLO fights at tribunal a number of claims that are thought to be without merit and for which there is thought to be a good reason to fight them. The CLO does not settle all claims—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

However, those cases tend to involve people who are below chief executive level. In this case, everybody was breaking their backs to settle. Was there a cover-up? From what you have seen, would there be any justification to a claim? I know that that will be subjective, in some ways, but have you seen any evidence that Ms McLay lost her accountable officer status and was, in effect, fired when the time came because of any reason other than alleged incompetence and financial mismanagement of NHS Tayside?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I do not have the detail around that.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You do not have the detail, yet you made the decision not to pursue the matter. Surely you should have asked whether there was any evidence of sex or age discrimination. Surely you must have asked those questions before you made the decision not to continue to fight such claims.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

First, it is not my decision whether to continue or not continue—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Did you ask those questions, Ms Craik?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I did not go back and ask for the details—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So how could you assess the claim?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I was not assessing the claim; I was assessing the risk of a claim being raised.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

How could you assess the risk if you had not even checked whether there was a prima facie case of sex or age discrimination?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

From time to time, cases are raised that have no merit. Cases having no merit does not stop such cases being raised, and it does not stop money and time being spent on defending them.

My view was that, for the additional money that was being sought, it was a way of bringing certainty and conclusion to matters and that it was good value, given the money that would be spent, either getting to a termination of employment or defending claims that would be raised. I think that that has been agreed by the auditor.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I do not see why, before reaching that decision, you did not check some basic facts, such as whether there was any merit in the claim. If there was no merit in the claim, surely you should have given much more weight to the possibility of taking the case to an employment tribunal and proving to people that the NHS will not be a soft touch. Every penny in the NHS is very valuable indeed. You should not send out the message that people just need to cry foul and you will not even check whether they have a case against you but will just pay out and change the rules retrospectively to make sure that it does not appear as an ex gratia payment that the person is not entitled to. That is what it was all about—it was covering up.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

Not from my perspective.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Mr Neil makes a valid point. Am I right in thinking that you signed off the business case, Ms Craik?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

No.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Does the CLO not sign off the business case?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The business case is always signed off by one of the board members. The CLO is asked to put in figures at section 5 of the business case.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So the figures that were inserted in section 5 of the business case that Dr Ingram put to the board, which signed it off, were inserted by the CLO.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The CLO is asked to put in a figure for the percentage risk of a claim being raised, and it puts in 50 per cent—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Forgive me, but did you just say that it automatically defaults to 50 per cent?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

No—I said that that was the figure that was inserted. The business case says that, if you do not know for sure whether a claim is going to be raised, you should put in 50 per cent. That is Scottish Government guidance.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Again, that is new information to me. When the board saw the business case, it saw a 50 per cent chance of losing or winning—

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

No. It saw a 50 per cent chance of a claim being raised.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But you had inserted that not on the basis of any information on the chances of a claim being made but simply because the Scottish Government says that, in the guidance that you give to the board members, you should stick in 50 per cent and they will be good with that.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

No. When there is a suggestion that a claim might be raised but a claim has not at that point been raised, the guidance is that 50 per cent should be put in as the likely chance of a claim being raised.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Am I right that there is a section that gives the CLO’s estimate of the chance of winning whatever case you have decided the person has? If so, what figure do you put in there as standard?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I would not say that there is a standard figure. In this case, the figure that was put in was 50 per cent.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So you had assessed whatever claims had been raised—I think that you said that they were on sex discrimination, age discrimination and some form of unfair dismissal—and despite the fact that, as you have just told Mr Neil, they had not been sufficiently investigated, you assessed her chances of success at 50 per cent.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The figure was put in as 50 per cent.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Interesting.

I will move on, although it is on the same point. The submission, which I think Dr Ingram prepared, says at paragraph 2.10 that the business case did not refer to the notice period change. How did that omission come about? Dr Ingram said that there was a deal on the table, there was an offer to resign and then perhaps later an offer to resign with some kind of payment. Should not the board have been fully aware of that notice period change?

Dr Ingram
link

Everyone was fully aware of that, including the Scottish Government. We had discussed the change to the notice period with the accountable officer, the chairman and colleagues in the Scottish Government, and it was explicitly agreed—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But it was not in the business case.

Dr Ingram
link

Can I finish? I must apologise to the committee for not making that explicit in the business case. I have certainly learned and will make sure that I do not do it again but, by the time that the business case was submitted, that was the contractual position, because we had a legally binding agreement.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Just help me to understand how that omission could take place. That notice period change is the most material aspect of the case, yet, at the point of sign-off, the people who signed off the business case were not aware of it.

09:45

Dr Ingram
link

I am sorry—they were aware of it. There had been full discussions—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But it was not in the business case.

Dr Ingram
link

I have apologised for not including it in the business case—

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The business case is the document that mandates the payment. Is that correct?

Dr Ingram
link

I have answered your question.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I have a final question on the pension reclaim. I will provide a bit of context. An overpayment of the pension was made, in accordance with the agreement that was concluded, but it was later found that that payment should not have been made. The money from that payment has now been brought back.

Ms Craik, I believe that legal advice was provided that said that it would breach the agreement to do that, but NHS Tayside has done it anyway, in breach—it would appear—of your advice. Do you maintain the position that the reclaiming of that overpayment of pension is a breach of the agreement that was concluded?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The settlement agreement specified the sum that was to be paid over to the Scottish Public Pensions Agency. That was not qualified in any way, so it was my advice that that payment should be made. That payment was made. When the error was identified and it was asked whether the money should immediately be recouped or clawed back, I advised that, because the agreement was unqualified, to claw it back would not be in accordance with that agreement. I understand that, since then, as part of the reconciliation that happens periodically—I think that it is done on an annual basis, but I am not terribly sure—it has been identified as an overpayment made by the board and it has come back through that route.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Has that breached the agreement?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

The money was paid in and it has come back as part of a broader reconciliation.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

You advised that it would breach the agreement to do that. Has the agreement been breached?

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

I advised that to pay the money in and to immediately claw it back would be a breach.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So there has been no breach of the agreement, against your advice.

Hazel Craik NHS Scotland Central Legal Office
link

If the money has come back as part of a broader reconciliation, that is not the case.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am sorry, but we need to move on. I think that we are agreed that this situation is an utter guddle. It is astonishing to the committee that even though we have—at high cost to the public purse—human resources expertise and legal expertise, we still ended up in a position in which a chief executive who was leaving the NHS has been overpaid to such an extent. I feel that the people of the NHS Tayside area, whom we serve, have been let down.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I turn to performance. All that patients care about is getting their treatment on time and getting adequate treatment and support. Do you recognise that the performance on treatment waiting times is simply not good enough? I know that there is a slight disparity between Audit Scotland’s figures and the latest figures that NHS Tayside has provided but, broadly, the two sets of figures indicate the same issues. On the treatment time guarantee, the target is 100 per cent, but delivery is at 71 per cent. The standard on the 12-week wait for a first out-patient appointment is 95 per cent, but delivery is at 58 per cent. The standard on cancer treatment is 95 per cent, but delivery is at 79 per cent. Most shocking of all, on child and adolescent mental health services, where patients are meant to be seen within 18 weeks, the standard is 90 per cent, whereas delivery is at 39 per cent, which means that six out of 10 children are not getting mental health treatment in time. That is not good enough, is it?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I agree with you entirely—it is not good enough. The health board’s performance is the major concern of the board and of everyone who works at NHS Tayside. That is why we have taken such a fundamental look at what the underlying problems are. By analysing how the organisation is structured, funded and resourced, we have sought to develop a programme of change that will deliver the services in a different way so that we can improve access. On top of that, in recent weeks, £2.74 million of additional funding has come in from the Scottish Government to improve waiting times performance in particular, including on CAMHS.

I will hand over to the chief executive, who can give you more detail about the work that we have done on waiting times, specifically on cancer and CAMHS waiting times. However, I can say that I agree that the performance of NHS Tayside needs to be improved.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Before you do that, I would like to emphasise the figures. We are not talking about a handful of individuals; we are talking about thousands of people in Tayside. For example, according to NHS Tayside’s figures, at the end of September 2018, 10,414 people were waiting longer than the 12-week waiting time target, and, with regard to the 84-day treatment time guarantee, almost 3,000 people were waiting too long. Again, that is simply not good enough. Thousands of people in Tayside are owed an apology.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I would like to apologise to the people of Tayside who have not received their treatment within the period of the treatment time guarantee. I would also like to reassure them that the health board has recovery plans in place and that we have additional funding coming in to resource those recovery plans so that we can improve the service. I want to reassure the public in Tayside that the board is closely monitoring the situation through its performance and resources committee, and through the main board. We have a recovery plan and we have a trajectory that has been set for the recovery. That is being monitored. We have governance in place in the executive team, which takes a hands-on approach, on a weekly basis, to considering the figures and trying to improve them. Nobody could suggest that we are accepting the situation and are not doing our utmost to change it.

I will hand over to Mr Wright.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I very much agree that a number of aspects of the performance of NHS Tayside are not good enough. In some aspects of the service, performance is good, particularly in our emergency medicine department, which continues to perform well. However, as you rightly say, the waiting times figures for CAMHS are among the worst in Scotland, and that is simply not good enough. The board has taken proactive action to call in help on the redesign of CAMHS. We are working closely with Dame Denise Coia and her review of CAMHS, and the neurodevelopmental pathway has been actively redesigned so that space can be freed up for children who are in need of more acute CAMHS intervention. Across a range of performance areas, we have sought external help and are looking to improve.

The latest figures that I have seen, which are from the end of November, show that we are starting to see some improvements. The money that we have been able to get from the Scottish Government under the waiting times improvement programme will also help with that. However, you are absolutely right to say that we have a lot of work to do on performance.

I would like to add a couple more points, but I will perhaps do that when I answer your next question.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

With regard to the responsibility for the failure to deliver the treatment standards as expected, what is the balance between a failure of leadership and governance, a failure in terms of adequate resourcing—you mentioned the money that is coming through—and failures around workforce issues? Surely some issues are bigger than others.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

A number of those issues are connected. Over the past nine months, the chairman and I have been trying to tackle some of the underlying systemic issues that face the NHS in Tayside. One of the major things that we have put in place is a clinically led system of management and leadership. For example, in the acute sector, a new clinical leadership structure is now in place that is led by a senior clinician who is supported by a senior nurse and by management. The mantra is, “clinically led, managerially enabled”. The report of Sir Lewis Ritchie points to issues around the clinical care groups, the devolution of budgets and the need to put clinicians in the driving seat, supported by management. We are starting to see a number of improvements as a result of having a clinically led organisation.

The issues of finance, best use of workforce and getting the best outcomes for the population of Tayside are all linked, and a number of those indicators are starting to move in a positive direction.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

People will be interested to know what makes Tayside particularly challenging in relation to certain issues—CAMHS is a perfect example. I accept that leadership, finance and resources and workforce are challenges. For Tayside, which of those three is the greatest challenge? Can you put them in order?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

Some of the workforce issues are challenging, but most important is clinical leadership, involving staff and patients, particularly in regard to CAMHS, which is one of the highest priority services for the board right now.

The chairman and I have sought to introduce systemic changes. Among the committee’s papers is our paper on the governance changes with regard to the board, the committees of the board and levels of scrutiny, and on the changes that I have made to the senior management system. We are now appointing a head of performance management for the whole system—that post was not in place before—and a head of planning and transformation to do the transforming Tayside work. We are getting in senior HR advice and there is also Alan Gray’s role in stabilising the finances. All those things are interconnected. With the fundamentals in place, we are starting to see some changes.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I accept all that, but a lot of it will mean nothing to patients in Tayside. For them, it will still feel as though they are not getting the standard of service to which they are entitled.

Tayside’s mental health services have had a huge amount of attention from within and outwith Parliament and, in particular, in Dundee. Given how high profile the issues are, the campaign work that has been done by the lost souls of Dundee group, for example, and the fact that there is now an inquiry into mental health services in Tayside, it is unfathomable that we have a situation in which—despite all the attention, hard work and reassurance that we have given to families—only 39 per cent of CAMHS referrals are seen in time. I cannot understand it.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

Those numbers are starting to improve, but you are absolutely right that the 39 per cent figure is not acceptable and it must continue to improve. We have the systems and processes in place with the right clinical leadership, managerial support and improvement support, which we got in from outside, and, with the redesign of the services, we are now starting to see some of the benefits coming through.

With regard to the performance of the board and the impact on the population of NHS Tayside, my proposition is that the key to getting improvements is getting the fundamentals and the systemic changes in place, which they now are.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Do you know how many people have lost their lives while waiting for mental health service referrals to treatment?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

Off the top of my head, I do not know that number. I know that there is significant morbidity and distress in the community with regard to the ability to access mental health services.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Can you accumulate that figure and provide it to the committee?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

We can try to get a figure for you—I am happy to do that. The setting up of the independent inquiry under David Strang’s leadership was a sign from the board that we take mental health services extremely seriously.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

Will that inquiry consider the number of people who have lost their lives while waiting for referral to treatment?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

The inquiry is considering, and has taken, a wide range of evidence from all community and user groups, including staff groups. We have engaged the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland, which has acted as an interface with the public. A huge amount of evidence has been gathered and David Strang and his colleagues are working on it. The board is absolutely committed to implementing the outcomes of the review.

In parallel, we have put in place new clinical leadership for mental health services in Tayside. We brought in Professor Keith Matthews, who commands a good degree of clinical respect and confidence, as well as a senior manager and an experienced senior nurse to support him. The work is in place for that triumvirate to lead the redesign of mental health services, as is the notion that we will really develop mental health services across Tayside. That has been a step forward and we are looking forward to the results of the review.

Anas Sarwar Lab Glasgow
link

I have a final question, which I know is relevant to Tayside families. What is the current status of the review? What engagement have you had with local families, and what is the timetable for publishing the review and implementing its recommendations?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

David Strang came to the board in December to present an update on the review. We have had a report from the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland, which the chairman might want to say a bit more about.

10:00

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

It is an independent review. David Strang has set out his plans for gathering and reviewing the evidence. In the update that he gave us in December, he said that he had the first lot of evidence from service users and their families, through the work that the alliance had done. He is now capturing evidence from the staff, and that review is being led by the trade unions. The themes that are starting to emerge are not surprising—they are about access and waiting times. Once David Strang has reviewed the evidence, he will come to us with proposals. I do not have a date for when that will be, because he is still considering the evidence, but he will come back to us within the next month or so with a clearer timescale for when he will report.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I have a small supplementary question on that. Malcolm Wright talked about having clinical leadership in place for mental health. I think that, when I visited CAMHS in the summer last year, of seven consultant posts, four or four and a half were full. Clearly, the nuts and bolts that you have talked about involve having doctors in place to see patients. Has that figure improved?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

I do not have the most up-to-date figure in front of me, but I know that one of the challenges that the board has faced has been in the ability to recruit consultant psychiatrists. Part of that is to do with the reputation of the service and how well the board supports it. It is about making it an attractive service that people want to work in. With the clinical leadership that is in place, we are seeking to create an attractive environment for people to come to.

I do not know whether any of my colleagues can comment on that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Will you get back to the committee in writing on the number of vacancies in CAMHS?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I want to comment on that issue. You said that the board and leadership team are taking the issue seriously now. One of the reasons why we are so upset about payments to the former chief executive is that various issues, especially to do with mental health services, were raised time and again by many politicians but were never taken particularly seriously. The issues have to be seen together.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I want to ask about the internal audit function in the health board, which has featured in the committee’s discussions on several occasions. First, what is the situation with the internal audit process in NHS Tayside?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The internal audit in NHS Tayside is currently delivered by an organisation called FTF, which delivers internal audit services to a number of health boards and is hosted by NHS Fife. As you will have seen from the governance paper, as part of my review of governance I wanted an independent review of the effectiveness of our internal audit, so I commissioned the Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors to carry out a review. It has a standard review that it carries out across the public sector and, with some tweaks, the private sector, although the approach is the same. The institute’s report confirmed that our internal audit processes are fit for purpose and that our internal auditors have the right skills and experience, but it said that the problem in the past with internal audit has been with the organisation’s response to audit findings.

To resolve that issue, the board’s audit committee commissioned a piece of work on the process for handling recommendations from internal audit, to ensure that the executive team delivers audit recommendations within a reasonable timescale, and on how we can be assured that that work has the outcome that we are looking for. That process has been approved by the audit committee and is now in place. As the chair, my view is that we have an effective internal audit function and that it now has the right impact on the organisation.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

The view that the internal audit function should have picked up on a number of issues that members have raised over a period of time has previously been expressed at the committee. Is that your view, too? If so, have you looked at the scope and the role of the internal audit function in order to address that?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The evidence shows that the internal audit function has picked up a number of issues relating to NHS Tayside’s financial management and accounting that have caused concern. However, its actions and recommendations were not properly implemented. In some cases, they were not implemented at all.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I am not in a position to answer that. You would need to ask the previous leadership team that question.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

While the discussion has been taking place, I have had a look at the minutes from the board’s meeting in December, which consist of 240-odd pages of material. I am surprised that anybody gets any work done if the minutes are so substantial. The chief internal auditor was not even at that board meeting, but the minutes say that the previous role of internal audit was purely about assessing risk and that the audit committee’s role is being extended to include assurance. This is 2019. Why on earth is it only now that the board thinks that the audit function should include an assurance role?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I think that the minutes refer to the function of the audit committee rather than the internal auditors. As part of the governance review that was done when the new leadership first came in, we looked at all the terms and conditions, the standing instructions and the terms of reference for all the committees, including the audit committee. The audit committee was not an audit and risk committee, so we have changed that. The governance of risk has been managed across NHS Tayside by the sub-committees, but the governance had not been brought together under the audit committee. That is the change that we have introduced. As Willie Coffey said, that is the modern way of ensuring that there is governance around the internal audit function. I cannot say why that was not the case previously.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

NHS Tayside spends roughly £900 million a year. What is the size of the internal audit function? You have talked about skills, but are there sufficient skills across the whole range of responsibilities for the board to have assurance that any issues that crop up will be spotted and acted on in the future?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The review by the Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors looked at whether the internal audit team has the right skills and the right resources available to carry out its function. The institute has assured us that the audit team does.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

I will refer that question to Alan Gray, who might have a figure for the number of auditors in that team.

Alan Gray NHS Tayside
link

Including the chief internal auditor, there are five staff members who work as part of that team.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I have tried my best to find mention of any audit discussion, material, recommendations or actions—I am only at page 70 of the 240 pages of minutes. There does not seem to be a primary focus on audit material, recommendations, actions and so on within the barrage of text in the minutes. Do you plan to change that so that greater priority and focus is given to the audit function?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

As I said, we have changed the terms of reference for the audit committee so that it now covers audit and risk. In addition, the chief executive has introduced a senior role that will look at how effectively the risk management system across NHS Tayside has been managed by the executives and how effective the governance by the sub-committees, the audit committee and the main board has been. We have increased our focus on that and increased the resource that we are putting in to do that work.

Mr Neil raised the question of governance earlier. There has been a systematic failure of governance, and one of the challenges that the new leadership team had was fixing that problem. It could be argued that one of the reasons why I, as the chair, was not given advice on what was in the 2006 circular was that the board did not have a discrete board secretary function—there was not one individual who, for a living, looked after the board and the governance, and provided a centre of excellence, expertise and advice. As the committee will have seen from the governance review, we now have the system in place to counter that systemic problem.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

How will we and the Tayside public know and be assured that audit recommendations that may emerge from now on are given priority, are visible in the board minutes and are acted on? You said that recommendations that were made in the past were not seen or acted on. Can you assure us that that will no longer be the case and that recommendations will be taken seriously?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The evidence of that will be seen in two places: in the audit and risk committee’s minutes on the action plan, when it reviews the outstanding audit recommendations and the progress towards them, and in the updates that the chair of the audit and risk committee gives to the main board in the bimonthly board meetings.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

But that was always the case. That reporting mechanism was always there.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

It was not, actually.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The process was not complete. Not all the outstanding audit recommendations were followed up by the audit committee. Mr Wright and I discovered an approach when we went to the first audit committee meeting. The committee considered what were described as the “priority outstanding actions” but not the totality. There was an acceptance that there was a lack of capability and capacity in the organisation to deliver all the recommendations, so it had become acceptable that recommendations were carried forward from one year to the next.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You should be very brief, and the answer should also be very brief, please.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

If issues—serious or otherwise—arose that the audit committee, the internal audit team or whoever wished to make the board aware of, would that happen now?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Do you get sight of internal audit recommendations?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Is there evidence that they are acted on? They were not in the past.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We have that assurance. Good stuff.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

The “Corporate Governance in NHS Tayside” report talks about skills, experience and diversity as being enablers of the governance system. Do you now have the audit committee that you want? Does it have the right skills, experience and diversity? What are the right skills, the right experience and the right diversity?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

We have an audit committee that has the right range of skills as far as the business of NHS Tayside is concerned. What we lack in its membership at the moment is financial experience. That is limited because of resignations. Two of the members who resigned were experienced financial professionals. We are recruiting, and the specification in the recruitment process is for board members who have financial experience. We are not waiting to get that because, obviously, the board and the audit and risk committee need to be assured of the effectiveness of the audit, so we have co-opted as advisers to the committee two experienced audit chairs, both of whom are chartered accountants and experienced finance directors in the public sector. The audit chairs from Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board and the Golden Jubilee national hospital will act as advisers, attending the audit committee meetings and reviewing the papers. They have committed to supporting NHS Tayside’s audit function for two days a month. We recognised that, with the resignations, we had lost that particular experience.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Time is running on, so it would be helpful if the answers were kept as concise as possible.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

You said that you are recruiting. Are you having any difficulty in that?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The recruitment process has not reached the point of the adverts going on, so I do not know whether we will get a great or a limited response.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Do you not think that the circumstances of the history of recruiting consultants, as you mentioned, will put people off?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

It might.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Do you have an action plan for that, as well as for recruiting consultants?

10:15

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

In our recruitment, we have specified the skills that we want, but the board does not have responsibility for recruiting board members; that is done by the public appointments group in Scotland. We do not really have control over the process, which applies to all public bodies.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

One issue is the attractiveness of the board for people coming to be a non-executive. The message that we are trying to get out is that this is a board that is on the road to recovery. Over the past nine months, we have tackled some fundamental issues in the running of the board and its governance and management. The run rate on the overspend is now coming down and we are getting that to a better place, and I can report to the committee that we have repaid the £3.6 million of endowments. We have got to the bottom of some long-standing issues and there are good prospects ahead for the board, which makes it attractive to serve on as a non-executive.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

On one of Willie Coffey’s points, if there are financial secondees or temporary appointments, it would be helpful to see some of their comments coming through in the board papers, which we do not see just yet.

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

Will you take that away to consider?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes, I will take that away, but the minutes reflect what happened at the meeting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I will continue on the governance issue. How many vacancies are there on the board at the moment?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

We do not have any. The board has 20 members, but in the discussions that I had with the cabinet secretary when I was asked to come into NHS Tayside, I said that I wanted to address the question of capacity. In addition to having responsibility for the board and the board’s sub-committees, I am responsible for providing health board members to the three integration joint boards in Tayside. The cabinet secretary agreed to increase the size of the board by another two members, and it is those two posts that we are currently recruiting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Comments have already been made about the question of financial experience on the board, which you are trying to address, but there are wider issues about the diversity of skills on the board. Are you satisfied that the members you have now have a sufficient mix of skills to be able to adequately carry out their functions?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes, I am. Of the three recent recruits to the board—two in December and one in January—one has a detailed background in the NHS, another has a lot of experience in transformational change and managing organisations through change and the third new member has a long track record of leadership through change. That adds to the experience that we currently have on the board, which is a good mix of people from the NHS, other parts of the public sector and the private sector and from different aspects of organisations.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given that you now have 20 members and that there will probably be 22, having the right structures in place is important. How do you ensure that the board functions efficiently? Will there be an on-going form of assessment or appraisal of members? How will you do that?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

NHS Scotland boards have always done self-assessment, which we will continue with. We have revised that model and there is a new self-assessment process coming into play next month across NHS Scotland. Tayside will obviously be one of the boards involved.

We are also introducing an external assessment of boards to ensure that self-assessment picks up on all the issues.

We have developed a clear blueprint for what good governance looks like and there is now a lot of clarity not only on what the board’s functions are and what resources it needs but on the flows of information, the audit requirement and the admin requirement. That blueprint is being rolled out at present. I co-chair the NHS Scotland steering group for corporate governance with Christine McLaughlin, the Scottish Government health finance director.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I presume that you have an induction process for new members. Are you satisfied that it is sufficiently robust that members fully understand what their responsibilities are, so that the self-appraisals and external appraisals can be useful?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

Yes. The induction process is on two levels. There is a general induction that everyone receives, which is based on who we are, what we do and what is expected of us, and there is a customised induction for individuals depending on their background. We also have four development sessions each year at which we bring to the board any new areas in the legislation and any issues that we feel it needs to be updated on.

Obviously, there is training. All board members receive the on-board training that all public sector board members in Scotland receive. In addition, the audit committee members are provided with specific training on their responsibilities that builds on what is in the on-board training, so they all go through that process as well.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Brown, would you accept that, given the considerable difficulties that NHS Tayside has faced over recent months and some of the quite extraordinary revelations that have appeared this morning, the public might find it difficult to have confidence in the decision-making process in NHS Tayside about clinical matters? I represent Mid Scotland and Fife, so a lot of my constituents are NHS Tayside patients. Do you accept that they may feel uncomfortable about the decision-making process for their treatments? Are you making any changes to improve the transparency for patients about who makes decisions about which services are delivered in local communities?

John Brown NHS Tayside
link

The change programme that is looking at what services we deliver, how we deliver them and where we deliver them is clinically led. It is the clinicians, who understand patients’ needs and the services that we deliver, who are working to develop the first-cut proposals and options, and those will then go through the engagement process. We are developing a process for engaging with local communities to give the service users and patients a voice on which services they want, which services they expect and where they expect them to be provided. We have started that process by having a number of events with some of the groups that represent groups of patients. We have taken them around Tayside and had public events on that. As the work of the clinical alliance progresses—it comprises the clinicians who are leading on the design—we will ratchet up that work and do even more of it.

At a development session on 31 January and 1 February, the board will review the progress to date on the redesign work and the work on developing the capability and capacity to deliver the new design. For one of the sessions, the board has asked for updates on the engagement strategy and the plan.

That engagement will also include engagement with elected representatives and, as you know, we meet the MSPs and MPs about every six weeks.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I understand that those decisions and the investigations that you are making at the local level are clear to you, although personally I doubt that they are clear. The NHS Tayside patients and others who come to our surgeries are concerned about the decisions that are being made. In particular, when services are transferred or cut, they do not understand the reasoning behind that. As somebody who represents those people, I am interested in how that can be made clear to those people who are using NHS Tayside.

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

The process of engagement with the public and being transparent about the challenges that we face is very important. The information that we communicate to the public and the openness and transparency of our board and our committee system are very important. There is the work of transforming Tayside and the public events that we have had—I know that you led a public event that I spoke at, convener. All these things are very helpful in engaging with the population about the choices that NHS Tayside faces.

The Auditor General has made the point about an expensive service model. The board and the Government will need to make a series of strategic choices about the future of that model. We have given strong commitments about the future of Stracathro hospital, Perth royal infirmary and Ninewells hospital. That transforming Tayside process, with the integrated clinical strategy and with public involvement in what we do where and the potential capital investment on the back of that, is important.

Public engagement and involvement are essential and that is what we have been seeking to do.

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

After your time overseeing NHS Tayside, are you comfortable with the IJB structure in NHS Tayside, given that there are concerns about the transparency of decision making between social care and healthcare? It is not clear to members of the public how that IJB structure works. Are you comfortable with it, having seen it in operation?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

We need to make improvements in how the IJBs are working—

Liz Smith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Could you say what those improvements would be?

Malcolm Wright Former Chief Executive, NHS Tayside
link

—and how they are working with partners. One thing that I have set about doing—I know that the chairman has set about doing this as well—is to build the strategic relationships between the board and the three local authorities.

Certainly, during my time in Tayside, I have put considerable time and effort into working with the local authority chief executives. The local authority chief exec, the health board chief exec and the integration board chief officer have been working together. Towards the end of my tenure in Tayside, the chairman and I hosted an event that brought together conveners from the council, locally elected representatives, IJB representatives and health board representatives to look at how we are going to work together.

From a Government perspective, there is a commitment by the cabinet secretary to increase the pace of integration. That is very much dependent on the relationships and the joint working at the top of these organisations. It is not necessarily about the structure of the IJBs; it is about how IJBs work with the health board, local authorities, local communities and voluntary bodies.

That picture varies around the country, from what I have been able to see. There are opportunities for improvement. I must say that in my time in Tayside, I was warmly welcomed by the local authority chief executives on visits to local authorities and I think that local authorities have been asking for a much improved strategic relationship.

It is a job for the board to make sure that we have those strategic relationships in place and that we have strong partnership working so the signing of the new agreement with the University of Dundee has been really good and very important. I also want to pay tribute to the staff side in NHS Tayside and the leadership that they have given in all the changes that we have gone through.

My conclusion, at the end of my nine months in Tayside, is that we have done a lot to address some of the fundamental, underlying systemic challenges facing the board and put things in place to try to get some of those issues right, and I think that the board is on the road to recovery.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 275

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.