Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Residential Care (Severely Learning-disabled People) (PE1545)

Thursday 10 January 2019 Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:15 Petitions 45 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

45 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The second petition for consideration is PE1545 by Ann Maxwell on behalf of the Muir Maxwell Trust, on residential care provision for the severely learning disabled. This petition has also been under consideration for a number of years. It was lodged in December 2014, and was first considered by the session 4 Public Petitions Committee in March 2015.

At our meeting on 25 October 2018, we noted the petitioner’s anger and disappointment with the lack of progress on the action that she is calling for. Of particular concern to her is the data visibility of learning-disabled children and young people around Scotland, together with the lack of suitably high-quality and appropriately resourced residential care homes. We agreed to take evidence from the cabinet secretary to respond to the petitioner’s concerns.

For this session, the cabinet secretary is accompanied by Gillian Barclay, strategic lead for dementia, learning disabilities and autism, and Pauline MacDonald, policy officer on autism and learning disabilities.

I invite the cabinet secretary to provide a brief opening statement, after which we will move to questions.

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak briefly on the important matter of residential care for severely learning-disabled people.

I record my respect for and appreciation of the Maxwell family for all the significant work of the Muir Maxwell Trust in providing practical support to families raising children who have epilepsy and for widening understanding and awareness of that condition. That significant work is valued by everyone who benefits from it.

It has been a consistent policy priority across different Governments of different political parties since the 1980s that all adults with learning disabilities, including those with complex needs, should experience meaningful and fulfilled lives. That applies to where individuals live and the services that they receive. The closure of large-scale hospitals is widely acknowledged as a major step forward for the human rights of people with learning disabilities, and I am sure that no one here wants to return to having large-scale residential institutions.

Although we have come a long way since that time, I acknowledge that it has not always been a smooth road. However, from the early days of “The same as you?” and “The keys to life”, Scottish learning disabilities policy has been developed on a human rights basis and informed by listening to the views of people with learning disabilities and their families.

During that time, we have not heard a persistent call for more residential care establishments—indeed, we have heard quite the opposite. Nonetheless, finding appropriate and sustainable community placements for people with the most complex needs has proved difficult. It is true that the sector has examples of good practice in which people with complex needs are well supported and live full and active lives in their communities. However, when things have not gone so well, we find examples of individuals who have undergone multiple placement breakdowns, hospital admissions and difficult experiences and who have not received the right support at the right time in order to meet their desired outcomes.

We know that people with profound learning disabilities and the most complex health needs can be well supported with personalised care packages in their own homes and with their own tenancy agreements. In my view, that makes for better provision, and that is available around the country. All adults with severe or profound learning disabilities are entitled to that support; they do not have to live with their families unless they and their families wish that.

I will touch briefly on the recently published report that the Government commissioned from Dr Anne MacDonald. That report looked in some depth at why young people with learning disabilities end up being placed in care homes or hospital facilities that are far from their families and home communities. Dr MacDonald found that the factors influencing that are multifaceted and complex. As a consequence, solutions for young people in that situation need to be about more than individualised service changes and must instead be seen in the context of a more transformational systems change. We agree with Dr MacDonald’s conclusions and we are working with our integration authorities to take forward the report recommendations to ensure that that happens.

Support to people with learning disabilities needs to be framed in the broader context of equality and social justice and not solely in the narrower focus of service design and delivery, important though that is. Services or models of care should not be the sole focus; it is about everyone with a learning disability having access to the support that they need and, crucially, being involved in decisions.

I am committed to ensuring that we implement the recommendations of Dr MacDonald’s report. Our current work with people and their families who are directly engaged in and have personal experience of these issues, which we touched on in consideration of the earlier petition on the reform of adult social care, will help us to achieve that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. How do you respond to the petitioner’s concern and disappointment that, in the four years since the petition was lodged,

“nothing constructive and supportive has resulted.”?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I do not agree with that; I do not believe that that is an entirely fair characterisation of where we are. I certainly share what I am sure is some of the petitioner’s frustration that we have not seen enough done, but I do not accept that nothing has been done. There are examples of very good practice in which people with complex needs are well supported and live full and active lives in their communities, including Beeswing in Dumfries and Galloway, Teviot Court in Midlothian and Moray Council’s new homes. However, I acknowledge that there are examples that have not worked, and we need to do more, working with our integration authorities, to implement the recommendations of Dr MacDonald’s report.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are you aware that one of the reasons why the committee invited you to come along is that the Scottish Government did not address the questions that the petitioner was raising and that the research mentioned was not on the issues that she had identified about the needs of people in the category of having complex needs? Perhaps you simply think that it is a policy difference, that you do not believe that there is a need for long-term care for people with complex needs and that there should always be support in the community rather than in such units.

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

Part of what I have to do is to listen to a range of organisations. That, of course, includes the petitioner’s organisation, but also organisations such as Enable Scotland, which says:

“It is vital that we resist any temptation to revert to building more multi-bed, residential units.”

Different approaches can be taken in terms of the accommodation and support packages and how those are configured. I have given some examples of that. I have had discussions with Kevin Stewart, who is, as you know, the minister for housing, on some of the approaches that we might take in terms of the Government’s commitment on social housing build and the work with some registered social landlords. There is some coverage of that in our disability delivery plan, but what I do not agree with—I share Enable’s view on this—a return to multibed, residential units.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suspect that that is not what the petitioner wants, either. It would be a false characterisation to present those as the only two choices. The issue is that particular needs are not being addressed. Part of that is to do with those people not being visible in the data, which is what a lot of the conversation with the Scottish Government has been about.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Cabinet secretary, you mentioned your commitment to ensuring access to the support that learning-disabled children need. What assurances can you give the petitioner that the issues raised in her petition are being and will be given due consideration by the Scottish Government in order to deliver support for vulnerable and severely learning-disabled children, young adults and their families?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

A significant part of my answer to that is contained in the work that we commissioned from Dr MacDonald, in the recommendations of her report and in our acceptance of those recommendations and the work that we now need to do, in conjunction with the integration authorities, to ensure that we can deliver on them.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The convener mentioned data. Identifying the data sets for this young group of people is necessary in order to understand what support is required to be delivered by the Scottish Government. How do you respond to the petitioner’s comment that

“the Scottish Government has repeatedly deflected the matter to the Learning Disabilities Observatory (LDO) in an attempt to convince the petitioner that their research is relevant to the issues raised”?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

The learning disabilities observatory was set up to provide a high standard of analysis of data that is routinely collected about people with learning disabilities. It is data that we need. Of course, that does not necessarily mean that that is all that we need to do. I am happy to look further, particularly on the basis of Dr MacDonald’s report, at how we might improve not just data collection but data analysis, and at how that will inform the work that we need to undertake to improve the situation.

11:00

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

There is an apparent absence of clear data sets, so do you have an estimate of how many children and young people require long-term residential care provision? How would you respond to the petitioner’s assertion that a group of young people is “invisible”?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

My understanding, which is based on research findings, is that there are just over 5,000 children and 21,000 adults in Scotland with learning disabilities. About 1,000 children and 4,000 adults of those have severe learning disabilities; a similar number have profound learning disabilities. Those people require significant additional support. Some of that may be particular to their residential and accommodation needs; for others, it will be a combination of that and other types of support.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are you aware that, in response to the petition, the observatory said:

“We are not aware of any existing datasets in Scotland that include a marker for profound learning disabilities.”?

Gillian Barclay Scottish Government
link

The observatory figures that the cabinet secretary has quoted are an estimate.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So the petitioner is right. There is no marker and we do not know what the level of need is for profound learning disabilities.

Gillian Barclay Scottish Government
link

That is correct.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Most people here would very much support the thrust of policy on community support and inclusion, and an end to long-stay care in hospitals and so on, but the petitioner’s point is that there is no visibility for the particular needs of those who have profound learning disabilities. Should there be research in that regard? Would you make a commitment to carry out such research?

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

The petitioner states that there are no long-term residential care facilities in Scotland. She also makes the point that, although there are too few such facilities in England, there are some good-quality residential care homes, for example the David Lewis Centre in Cheshire, Home From Home Care in Lincolnshire and the St Elizabeth’s Centre in Hertfordshire. There is a different position in England on residential care. Why is England taking a different point of view from us?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I cannot answer for the approach that England takes.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

But the petitioner does not understand why we do not have long-term residential care facilities in Scotland and, naturally, she is looking elsewhere to find examples of that provision. Has any work been done that suggests that such provision has a benefit? Why would it be offered in the rest of the UK and not in Scotland? I am just trying to get an answer on behalf of the petitioner, if you do not mind.

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I understand what you are asking me. I think that a false distinction may be being made here about what is residential care and what is not residential care. The convener quite rightly made it clear that the petitioner is not looking for a return to the situation that we had in the 1980s—none of us is. Some of the examples that I gave about housing in Midlothian and elsewhere constitute a form of residential care but in individual homes.

I have not had the benefit of meeting the petitioner yet, but I would need to understand better from her exactly what she is looking for that is not represented by the examples that I am pointing to but, equally, is not a return to the situation in the 1980s. That would allow us to have a better conversation, which would be important to inform the work that we do to implement the recommendations in Dr MacDonald’s report.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

That is an extremely generous offer. The convener can take it to the petitioner. It would be helpful to distinguish the complex needs and services that she is talking about.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Cabinet secretary, are you aware that one of the arguments that the petitioner makes is that people with learning disabilities are able to live longer now, often into quite old age—which is a blessing—and are often supported by their families, but, because there is not an appropriate residential support, they remain within their own homes, with a care package that is under pressure? Do you agree that that means that we do not know the scale of the problem? The petitioner describes this group as being invisible. Do you also agree that that means that we therefore do not know what the pressures are on the carers and the community around them? Is it the case that, under a policy that we all support, we are missing a group of people who, because we are not going to do what we did in the past, are being failed by the policy approach?

The petitioner says that we must meet the real needs of this voiceless group and their families. I am sure that your offer to meet the petitioner would be welcomed, but do you agree that, at the heart of the issue is the fact that we are not identifying this particular group? How do we do that, and how do we shape the policy around their needs?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I am grateful to you for that question and for encompassing the issues in that way. Broadly speaking, I agree. I am very conscious that we are working to try to provide the right support in the right setting for a group of people who, in the past, would not be living as long as they now are. It is very welcome that they are now living as long as they are, but that places significant strain on their families, and I absolutely know about and understand the significant worry and concern that parents and families have about what will happen to their son, daughter or whoever when they are no longer there.

I am genuinely not trying to dance on the head of a pin here, but I would not characterise that as a policy failure. I think that what we are seeing is an inadequacy in the full extent of that policy when it comes to covering everyone who should be encompassed by it.

I want to stick with the core principles of the policy but do more work now to ensure that we know the number of people we are talking about. That is what the petition calls for and what you have highlighted. I want to hear from the petitioner what they have in mind when they talk about residential care and how that might differ from what I have in mind when I talk about some of the good examples that I touched on earlier.

The issue that this petition is concerned with feeds into some of the issues that we touched on in relation to the previous petition that we discussed, and particularly the issues of overall cost and charging and how they are managed. Sense Scotland and Enable have raised with me their issues and concerns about high-cost packages not being fully met. We are giving some consideration to how we can relieve local authorities of that additional burden so that they have less of a difficult resourcing choice to make over, for example, whether they fund a number of high-cost packages and, therefore, not others. There are some complex areas to work through here, but there are some clear basics that we can do more on, a lot of which come from Dr MacDonald’s report, and some of which I have touched on already.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Convener, I should probably declare an interest as convener of the cross-party group on learning disability. We very much welcomed Dr MacDonald’s report, and I welcome what I thought was a clear commitment from the cabinet secretary to data collection, because we count what matters to us.

I have been working with a number of families for more than three years now. They are exactly as you described—families with people who have profound and complex learning disabilities but whose local authority is not unwilling but unable to deal with some of the large-scale packages, which are very labour intensive for local authorities. I was going to ask whether the Scottish Government will co-ordinate some of that effort across local authority boundaries in order to bring a lot of the people who are cared for away from home in institutions in England and elsewhere back home with a collaborative approach that provides some of this small-scale, residential, supported, labour-intensive accommodation much more locally. However, you have partially answered that, based on your discussions with Enable and Sense Scotland. Will you unpack that a bit more and say when we should expect to see something? As I said, I have had families waiting for three or four years now.

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I completely understand that and I understand the degree of frustration and the impatience to see the significant improvements that people want. As Ms Baillie and others will know, I am a pretty impatient person myself.

We began discussions through COSLA in the summer around propositions on how we can look at the high-cost packages, which are high cost over a number of years, and how we can find a way through that with local authorities in terms of overall funding approaches. We have not yet reached a conclusion. We are doing some more thinking based on the responses that local authorities gave us, as are they, and we are due to come back and continue those discussions. I would not want to imply that we have not had anything since the summer. We are keeping going to refine this and see whether we can find an approach that we can afford and is therefore sustainable but which meets those needs by providing the assistance that local authorities need.

We will keep going in that direction, and that forms a significant strand in the reform of adult social care that I touched on earlier. I am keen that we reach, or get very close to, a resolution on that element by the summer, because it will then need to be something that I feed into budget negotiations for future years. We are working on that, and part of that encompasses our response to those elements of Dr MacDonald’s recommendations on—I cannot recall the exact phrase that she uses—inappropriate out-of-area placements. She has helpfully produced some analysis of those out-of-area placements and what she means by that. Some of them are out of area in Scotland and others are south of the border.

The work is under way to see what we might do in a way that is financially sustainable and works with our local authorities and integration authorities in order to shift this along significantly.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petitioner highlights the work that groups such as Quarriers do in providing excellent care for those who are less profoundly learning disabled, whereas we do not have adequate support for the group that we are discussing. Is the minister aware that there is a gap between that provision and the provision that is required for those with more substantial needs?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

Will you repeat the question?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petitioner wanted to highlight that groups such as Quarriers are doing excellent work in the community but they do not work with the group that we are discussing today. We should recognise that there is a gap between what they provide and the kind of provision that we are discussing today.

11:15

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

Yes, I think that that is fair. There are other stakeholder organisations that have a significant understanding and degree of expertise in this area, such as Sense Scotland, which has been mentioned, and Enable. It is primarily those organisations—others have done so, too—that have raised with me the point about the extent and complexity of the need and what needs to be done to meet that need, which I discussed with Ms Baillie. In practical terms, there is underprovision for those with the most complex learning disabilities and needs, but that is not necessarily because there is under-understanding of what is needed. That touches on what we are discussing and what we need to do on the basis of that understanding to improve how well we meet those needs.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have a quick addendum. We often hear that many of the issues are to do with the transition from children’s services to adult services. In your deliberations on delivering the policy, what consideration are you giving to that issue?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

That is a common area of concern across a range of levels of learning disability and needs, and it is one that I am very familiar with from the work that I did previously on the disability delivery plan. There are elements of the disability delivery plan that sit with other portfolios that look to address those transition gaps in education, employment and other areas of support. Similarly, at this more complex end, that needs to be part of the consideration that we give to how we implement the recommendations and what more we need to do.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I would like to highlight something that the petitioner said, which is reflected in the conversation about the danger of viewing the situation as one in which we have a choice between what we do now and what we did in the 1980s. She said:

“many parents believe they can cope or are wrongly stigmatised for putting their children into what may be perceived by others as ‘institutions’ ... the needs of profoundly learning disabled children can evolve greatly as they get older”.

She went on to say:

“More community care is not the answer for this group. Scotland needs long-term residential care options for this vulnerable group and the Scottish Government should provide the funding in which to make this a reality.”

She suggested that, because we do not have such facilities, the support that is provided—a couple of hours in the morning and a couple of hours in the evening—is inadequate, which puts a burden on families.

Do you recognise that, in pursuing the policy that we all support, there is a danger of implying that those who believe that there is still a need for residential care feel stigmatised in asking for such help for their young people?

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I recognise that that might well be the case, but I go back to my point that I need to understand better what the petitioner means when she talks about residential care options and to establish whether that is what we are trying to do through some of the examples that I highlighted earlier or whether there is more that needs to be done.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you accept that there is perhaps a parallel with the presumption in favour of inclusion in mainstream schooling, whereby we have ended up losing some specialist support? Parents would say that that presumption should not mean that such highly specialised provision is not available for some and that they should not feel that, by asking for that support, they are somehow letting down their young person. Do you think that there is a parallel here, in that we are closing down what parents understand that their young person needs because of adherence to a policy that somehow creates the impression that there should never be such supported accommodation? Is it the case that people are being left in the community with a bit of support from carers because of a very narrow interpretation of a policy that I believe is not narrow at all? Surely a wide spectrum of support should be available.

Jeane Freeman SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I do not believe that everyone in the group is being left in the community with inadequate support. Some of the examples that I have touched on and some of the other key stakeholder organisations would argue strongly against a generalisation of that sort. I am not suggesting that you are making that generalisation, convener, but it is important to say that for the record.

That said, I accept that there is undoubtedly more that we need to do. We need to test whether the policy—I think that we all broadly agree that it is the correct policy—has, in either its sweep or its implementation, unintentionally created a gap in provision and support that we now need to address.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. That is very helpful.

I thank you again for responding to our questions and particularly for being so responsive to the issues that the petitioner has identified. We can give you the information that will allow you to follow protocol in inviting the petitioner to a meeting.

Are there suggestions about what we should do with the petition?

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

It is fascinating to see the possible unintended consequences of the lack of markers in the data set that might identify a hidden group of people with profound disabilities. Until the cabinet secretary has met the petitioner and understood her absolute aims in the petition and until those markers are created, I do not think that we can take the petition as far forward as we would want at the pace that we would want.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

My view is that we have made more progress in the past hour than the petitioner has made in quite some time, because there has been a conversation about whether the point has simply been missed—I would not say that that has been done deliberately, because that would be most unfair. The petitioner has been frustrated about that.

I think that we want to hear the petitioner’s response to what has been heard and to hear from other people with an interest in the area. The cross-party group on learning disability or organisations that support individuals may have a view on something that in some ways is about individual needs but is also about the way in which policy is implemented and how we ensure that we have the right information. I hope that we can invite the petitioner to respond, that others with an interest will want to respond, and that we can get a further update at a later stage on how the matter has been progressed by the cabinet secretary and the Scottish Government. Is that acceptable?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I again thank the cabinet secretary very much for her attendance, which has been extremely productive. Perhaps there has been an interesting lesson about the benefits of direct conversation as opposed to correspondence. We can sometimes feel that some substantial points have been missed. I therefore thank you very much for your attendance.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank everyone else, too.

Meeting closed at 11:23.

  1. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 55
  3. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 45

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.