I will start by addressing your first question, which was about what are the current challenges regarding what can be delivered. A key element is the agri-environment climate scheme and its delivery. It changes every year, but at the moment we spend approximately £40 million a year through the scheme, which goes to farmers and land managers. The RSPB did some work a few years ago about what the budget would have to be to allow us to do all the things that we wanted to do. The RSPB will correct me if I am wrong, but it was in the order of more than £400 million, so we are spending only a fraction of what would be required. That is the first point—the amount of money that we spend is not enough to do what we would want to do.
The second point is on how the scheme works and whether there are challenges there. My understanding is that the number of applications and the amount of funding that has been spent in the most recent year are smaller than they have been in previous years, so they are going down.
The issues that we start to get into in the delivery of that sort of scheme are around design—there are ways in which we could do them better—and the uncertainty around Brexit. People do not necessarily want to make big commitments about going into schemes when they are not sure of what the broader framework will be when things change. There is therefore a big question about what more we could do on agri-environment.
I have to agree that there is an issue around integration. In a previous role, I was involved in trying to implement the Scottish biodiversity strategy, but I then moved from working in conservation to working in land management and found that there is a different way of approaching the big issue of integration. That brings me to the associated issue of conflict, because there are land managers who are suffering from the consequences of some of the successes. We have done well in protecting some species in biodiversity, but some land managers feel that that has become a problem. If we want to get more people on side on integration, we must be conscientious in dealing with conflicts to ensure that we do not create another reason for there not to be integration—and that also costs money.
We should therefore put money into the proactive stuff to protect and enhance biodiversity, but we also need to ensure that we invest in those areas where there are issues that need to be dealt with. We do that, but our members are knocking down our door about conflicts, because they are not being sufficiently resolved.
On your question about how things can be built for the future, Brexit is obviously the key issue that overshadows everything, and we do not know how that will play out. However, if it transpires that we create our own agricultural policy in the context of the UK, NFUS has suggested that a different payment regime should be introduced. The idea is that there would be a base financial stability payment and, on top of that, additional payments for undertaking environmental measures. Those could be non-competitive, in that farmers could say that we would do something and, as long as we did it, we would receive a top-up. There would also be competitive schemes on top of that. We can therefore build into a future policy regime an emphasis on delivering for biodiversity. We think that that is entirely consistent with where we would like to go.
On the emphasis on delivering for the public good, we would probably end up in a conversation about exactly how we do that, because we would get into questions around how we would do payment mechanisms and conditionality. However, delivering for the public good is possible.
I am not so sure about licensing, because there is already a licensing regime that is very specific on different things, as guided by different legal instruments—for example, there is quite specific licensing for dealing with species, water or any form of operation. However, it is a different question for broader funding schemes.