When I speak to our members—our money advisers—what I hear is that the difficulty lies not with the conventional consumer creditors that are, as Eileen Maclean has said, based throughout the UK. Those sorts of creditors, which include banks, lenders and credit card firms, have numerous approaches for dealing with customers who are considered to be vulnerable, or who are on low incomes. As advisers will tell you, dealing with those creditors is, for the most part, relatively straightforward.
Difficulties often arise when dealing with what one might refer to as public sector creditors, such as the Department for Work and Pensions, Her Majesty’s Revenue & Customs and, primarily, local authorities, which often use pretty aggressive means to recover council tax arrears. The notion that advisers have problems negotiating with consumer creditors is not one that our members would necessarily accept.
On the second question about the impact on statutory debt solutions, the evidence requirements that must be met in the financial statement can in many cases, as I have said, be onerous. We know of a case in which a father’s expenditure on train fares to visit his daughter was considered to be excessive, and we have also seen a disabled client being asked to evidence expenditure on incontinence pads. Such issues do not necessarily arise in the rest of the UK, but they arise in Scotland because of the approach to statutory solutions.
As I have said, the SFS will move elements such as transport and school uniform costs into categories that must be evidenced, which has not been the case with the common financial statement—and that is before we begin to talk about trigger-figure breaches. All that will lead to an increased workload for advisers, clients and, for that matter, the AIB, unless we get a reasonable approach to guidance, which would alleviate a lot of our concerns about the evidence requirements.