Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Schools

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 4 October 2018 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 8 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

Presiding Officer,

“When you visit schools, people are most likely to tell you what you want to hear, through fear of repercussions.”

That is the message from a primary school teacher in today’s press to the education secretary, speaking anonymously, because she fears being disciplined for speaking out.

How does the First Minister think that that reflects on her Government?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Teachers, parents and sometimes older pupils email me regularly—I am sure that that is also the case for the Deputy First Minister—to openly tell me their views on schools. Often, they talk about the many positives of school education; at other times, they point out things that they think we should be doing better.

I have read the letter that Ruth Davidson refers to and my message to any teacher is that nobody should feel unable to come to me or to the education secretary to raise concerns at any time. I encourage that, I have always encouraged that and I always will encourage that.

It is important that we remain focused on making sure that we are investing properly in our schools, reducing where we can unnecessary workload for teachers, and taking action through, for example, the pupil equity fund and the governance reforms in our schools to do what is a driving priority for this Government, which is to raise standards and close the attainment gap. We will remain absolutely focused on doing exactly that.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

The First Minister talks about reducing workload but if that work is being undertaken, why do international studies show that our teachers are among the most overworked in the world?

I will just read out a little bit more from the letter to Mr Swinney, which we all saw a copy of last week. In it, the teacher says:

“the ... Scottish Government are not tackling the real underlying issues in education but are rather just putting a plaster over a gaping wound”.

Speaking directly to Mr Swinney, she adds:

“The most concerning thing that has happened so far, is that one of my colleagues arranged to meet with yourself, to discuss issues that were of great concern to them. However, this person was ‘warned’ by their manager, that if they went ahead with the meeting, they would be disciplined”.

Could either the education secretary or the First Minister say whether they knew that that had happened, what action they took and whether they will end this culture of fear right now?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

First, it is important to be clear on this and I want to be crystal clear on this. I would say not just to people across the chamber but perhaps particularly to local authority employers in this regard that, in the case that Ruth Davidson has mentioned, the Deputy First Minister agreed to meet the teacher. It is not the Deputy First Minister who said that that meeting could not go ahead.

To be clear—it is not acceptable for local authorities to say to any teacher or any member of staff, whatever job they are doing, that they will be disciplined if they approach or raise concerns with Government ministers. I cannot be any clearer about that. I will go on being clear about that and I hope that that message is heard loudly and clearly by local authorities across the country. I hope that Ruth Davidson would agree with that and join me in sending that message.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

I am not sure that the First Minister fully gets this. It is her Government that is decreeing to local authorities. We are not talking about a political opponent here; this teacher is not point scoring. We are talking about a teacher who, in the letter, makes it clear that she is a Scottish National Party supporter and voter and yet now feels that she is not being listened to and has to speak out under the cloak of anonymity in order to avoid being stamped on.

What has it come to when public servants with experience and knowledge of their area are being strong armed to keep their mouths shut because it might embarrass the education secretary? Can the First Minister answer me that?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Having read the letter that Ruth Davidson opened with in her question, I would say that there are many serious issues in that letter that Ruth Davidson could have raised today—issues that the Government is working hard to address with the teaching profession and others. On this issue, however, she is on extremely weak ground.

Let me recap for Ruth Davidson’s benefit. In this case, the Deputy First Minister agreed to meet a teacher. The local authority advised the teacher not to meet. We do not decree that local authorities should do that. On the contrary, if there is any decree coming from me to local authorities today, it is that that is unacceptable, and that teachers should be free to contact me as First Minister, the Deputy First Minister as education secretary, or indeed any member of my Government.

I am not sure how I can make that any clearer for Ruth Davidson. Perhaps she would be doing teachers a greater service if, instead of standing here and pretending that there is some other policy on the part of the Government, she underlined the fact that any teachers anywhere in the country are perfectly free to approach any member of the Government. She would be doing a greater service to teachers if she got that message across loudly and clearly.

Ruth Davidson Con Edinburgh Central
link

I think that the transparency and openness of Government is a serious issue, which is worth highlighting. As the teacher says in the letter, their issue is not just about resources, but about workforce planning, a failure to implement policy properly and a failure to listen to people on the front line—a charge that is made front and centre. It is about a culture of fear and secrecy, which is stopping people from speaking out because of the repercussions for their careers.

We need an openness in government in Scotland—one that welcomes transparency and scrutiny, and not just because a letter was written—and a Government that asks teachers to tell it what is happening, not one that forces them to keep their mouths shut. Does the First Minister not agree?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Let me issue this message to teachers or any other public sector worker across the country, “Come and tell the Government how you feel about your job and your public services, whether that is good or bad, and whether it is about positives or things that we want to do better.” Ruth Davidson would be better advised to join me in putting that message out there.

Openness and transparency is hugely important. That is why the Deputy First Minister is in schools every single week, and that is why he and I talk to teachers regularly, not just in my capacity as First Minister but in my constituency surgeries, of which I do many. That message is one that we should all convey to teachers.

For the third or fourth time, let me be clear to teachers that they can come and raise anything they want with the Government. Let me be very clear to every single local authority, of every party administration, across the country that it is unacceptable to say to any teacher that they will be disciplined for doing so. I think that I have made that pretty clear, and I hope that is widely understood, not just by Ruth Davidson but by everybody across Scotland.

  1. Water and Sewerage Charges Exemption (Islands) Questions · 4
  2. Flags (Criminal Offences) Questions · 6
  3. International Transport Connectivity Questions · 4
  4. Railway Stations (Accessibility) Questions · 6
  5. United Kingdom Immigration Minister (Meetings) Questions · 4
  6. Fire Services (Staff Shortages) Questions · 4
  7. Universal Credit Questions · 4
  8. Schools First Minister’s Questions · 8
  9. Child Poverty Targets First Minister’s Questions · 7
  10. Pentland Film Studio (Scottish Land Court Judgment) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. Buccleuch Estates Ltd (Tree Planting) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  12. Moffat Church Place Surgery (Closure) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  13. Scottish League Cup Semi-finals First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. Brexit (People’s Vote) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Golden Jubilee Hospital (Trials) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Amazon (Living Wage) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  17. Carers Allowance Supplement First Minister’s Questions · 2
  18. NHS Ayrshire and Arran First Minister’s Questions · 2
  19. Domestic Abuse (Disclosure Scheme) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  20. HIV Infection First Minister’s Questions · 6
  21. Harassment Complaints (Scottish Government) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  22. Challenge Poverty Week Members’ business · 44
  23. Health and Care Update Statement · 26
  24. Women and Girls in Sport Week Debate · 40
  25. Scottish Fiscal Commission (Appointments) Debate · 1
  26. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 1
  27. Decision Time Decision time · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.