I listened to last week’s evidence. At the moment, the scope has deliberately been left quite broad. The idea of the register is to ensure that anyone who may be considered to have a controlling interest over someone who owns land is in scope, subject to the fact that some types of organisation are out of scope because they are already covered by other types of register.
There was a helpful suggestion last week about the use of examples to help people to understand whether they should be in or out. Once we have started to publicise the fact that the register is coming in and to deal with questions from individuals asking us to clarify whether they should register, it may be possible to add to those examples.
Last week, a helpful suggestion was made about cases in which someone who should have registered has inadvertently not done so. If it is brought to my attention that someone should have submitted a registration, I can alert them to the fact that we would consider them to be in scope and advise them of the process to register. In that way, people would not be caught out and inadvertently criminalised by not having quite understood which side of the line they are on.
Until we start testing, there are potentially grey areas. If necessary—if it becomes apparent that we are getting a lot of questions from people who are not clear about the definition of the terminology—we will invite the Lands Tribunal for Scotland to rule on whether a certain category of individual should be in scope.
I agree with colleagues from last week that it is hard to get a precise definition without then creating loopholes that allow people to say, “I’m definitely not in that category and therefore I don’t need to register.” Leaving the definition broad helps to meet the policy intent.