Item 3 is a report on the committee’s fact-finding visit to Brussels last week, during which we explored how common frameworks operate in other countries and, in particular, how they relate to trade negotiations. We will shortly publish a note from the clerks summarising the discussions that we had with the non-governmental organisations that we met and representatives from Germany, Norway, Switzerland and Canada, and we have also commissioned some research on these areas, which will also be published. For the moment, however, I will quickly give my own feedback on the visit, which I thought was very successful. It was highly educational, certainly for me, and I ask other members to reflect on their own findings.
First of all, I thank those who commented on these matters yesterday in the Government’s chamber debate on future trade negotiations. I realise that some reflections have already been offered; I am not looking for them to be repeated, although I suppose that some of that will be necessary. For me, the common theme that came through from all of the countries to whom we spoke was the early and deep engagement that there was between the state and the sub-state and which involved the Parliaments, stakeholders, NGOs and so on, and the way in which they went about their business in their own countries. I thought that that was something that we could learn from.
Moreover, the fact that engagement happened not just at the beginning but continually helped build a level of trust and understanding of the various positions of the sub-states. The framework that was provided as a result ensured more co-ownership of the final position by the state and more collective understanding of why a particular position had been reached and agreed. That probably strengthened the state’s own position in negotiations, because it knew that everybody was behind them and that the rest of the country was well in tune with the nation state’s up-front position in those circumstances.
Clear, formal structures were also very helpful in making sure that discussions actually happened. Obviously a lot of informal discussion was going on, too, but there was also a formal process that I think helped everyone clearly understand the remits and roles of the various bodies.
My own reflection is that, because of where we have come from, our default position in Scotland has been about finding ways of improving the dispute mechanisms instead of ensuring that we reach consensus and agreement and thereby front-load the process. That was quite a useful learning point for me. It is certainly clear that having such an in-depth process from the beginning and ensuring that general agreement had been reached resulted in less use of dispute mechanisms and fewer costly court proceedings. Indeed, as Willie Coffey said in the chamber yesterday, the Swiss were quite surprised to hear us talk about disputes, because of the way in which they involved the cantons in discussions. That was very useful.
What do we need to learn? It is pretty obvious—it is the need for devolved institutions, civic society, NGOs and other organisations to have meaningful engagement in the development of the common frameworks and for us as a committee to find out how we go about that as part of our job. Obviously there is a relationship between common frameworks and how future trade arrangements will work, but having early and on-going discussions in order to reach better agreements and have fewer disputes was, I think, an important lesson for us. We need those kinds of well-understood structures, but I think that the biggest and most important lesson is how we build trust and confidence for the future.
Those are some of the things that I learned from our visit. Do others have any reflections to offer?



