Global Witness picked up on the issue in our submission. In our view, the model that has been proposed in the draft regulations is not particularly user friendly. The situation is further complicated by the fact that the draft regulations exclude certain entities that are currently involved in land, because of the fact that they already provide beneficial ownership information to other registers—for example, the register of people with significant control, or PSC register—at United Kingdom level.
The consequence is that a member of the public who wants to access information about who owns a particular piece of land will have to go through a number of steps. First, they will have to access the land register or the register of sasines to find out the name of the entity that is registered as the owner of the land, then they will have to work out where they can find the beneficial ownership information for that entity, and then they will then have to go to the correct register to access that information—the new register of controlled interests or the PSC register, for example.
A third layer of complexity has been introduced by the UK Government’s proposed new regulations on foreign entities, which will create an entirely different register that will also be managed by Companies House at UK level.
That is not a very easy system for people to navigate—especially people without legal knowledge or advice. We have been supportive of the fact that it is free, and we certainly think that that reduces one of the barriers, but it is not the most straightforward way of accessing the information.
We are struggling to come up with simple ways by which the situation could be simplified, given the route that the Government has chosen to take, which involves the creation of a separate register and the exclusion of certain entities from the registration requirements. Those two elements inherently create complexities. It is difficult to see ways of simplifying those things within the draft regulations that are before us.
One element that needs further consideration is whether the balance between the need to avoid the problem of double reporting—which was the justification for the exclusions—is balanced against the extent to which the public interest purposes of the regulations are being met.
Another consideration that I expect we will come to later, but which I want to mention now, is that there is a difference between information that is required by a register and information that is publicly disclosed. For example, at UK level, the PSC register requires some information to be registered, in that case by Companies House, but not all the information is publicly accessible. We could consider using such a two-tier system here, to address some of the concerns that Ann Stewart raised about commercial confidentiality. That is another possible solution, but without knowing the details of how the register will work—we do not yet have that in the regulations—it is difficult to know the extent to which that is a potential route for simplification.