The final petition for consideration is PE1680, by Angela Flanagan, on private water supplies in Scotland.
As members will recall, at our previous consideration of the petition, in March, we agreed to seek the Scottish Government’s views on the action that is called for in the petition. The Scottish Government’s written submission explains that the Private Water Supplies (Scotland) Regulations 2006 were reviewed and updated as recently as last year. The Government also states that regulatory powers over the drinking water quality of private water supplies should remain with local authorities and that it does not support the petitioner’s call for an equal right of appeal in the planning process.
In her written submission, the petitioner expresses her dissatisfaction with the Scottish Government’s position on the action that is called for in her petition.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
We should close the petition. I was in Ayrshire the other day, with NFU Scotland, and we had a water expert from one of the Ayrshire councils present. It was clear that the councils have a really good grip on the matter and are now implementing the updated regulations. Although that is causing some concerns for farmers in relation to their own springs, the general feeling was that there is a clear direction of travel with the local authorities implementing the regulations, so that approach clearly has some traction.
Given the fact that the regulations were reviewed and new ones introduced last year and the fact that the Government has made it clear that it will not go beyond that, we should close the petition.
It is clear that the Government is digging its heels in when it comes to a third-party right of appeal. There does not seem to be any appetite in the Government to introduce such a right into the Planning (Scotland) Bill, but we will have to wait and see. That is one aspect of the petition that is unlikely to move forward.
I have no doubt that a community right of appeal, as I think it is being called, will be debated during scrutiny of the bill, and the petitioner might be able to influence that. The Scottish Government’s position is clear, but how the parliamentary arithmetic works out is another question. That is where that matter would be resolved.
I can see the argument for centralising the regulation of private water supplies, but it would probably mean that the people who were responsible would be less aware of the localised nature of some of the issues, which are very different in different parts of Scotland. It is one thing to monitor closely what local authorities do and how well they understand some of the challenges that the petitioner has identified, but it does not feel to me that the solution would be to take that regulation to the centre, because the geography of Scotland is so diverse.
I agree. The drinking water quality regulator for Scotland has been delivering training to local government environmental health officers to ensure that they are up to date on the rules and regulations. The key point is that all local authorities are up to date with their training and know what they are doing. They have a good handle on the situation. As you say, convener, if the system was changed, perhaps the people responsible would not have a handle on the local issues.
That was demonstrated in the Ayrshire hills. We were standing at a spring and the head of water engineering from the council explained what happens. I was impressed with him. He was absolutely on the ball. The council has done it for years.
There will be local issues. One of the problems that came up in Ayrshire concerned a farmer fertilising a field and the fact that the water catchment area might change from year to year. That involves local knowledge, so one size does not fit all. There is strength in the system that we have.
There might be an issue about the capacity of local authorities to continue. Perhaps we need to underline to local authorities the fact that the issue is really important so that, when they manage their budgets—we know that there are massive pressures on them—they realise that it matters to the health of local communities.
I have a clarification to make for the benefit of the Official Report. I should have referred to the equal right of appeal rather than to the third-party right of appeal. That issue goes back too many years.
Absolutely. As I was the planning minister at the time, I recall that issue very well.
I think that we agree that we will close the petition under rule 15.7 of the standing orders on the basis that there is no support from the Scottish Government for the action that the petition calls for. On balance, we feel that the important regulation and the protection of people’s water are probably best done at a local level.
I thank the petitioner very much for engaging with the committee and highlighting issues of concern to her community.
I wish everybody a very good and enjoyable recess, and I thank you all very much for your support in the committee’s work over the past year. We can be proud of a lot of what we have achieved. If nothing else, we have allowed people across our communities to raise issues that really matter to them and that we might not have thought of otherwise. I thank everybody who has engaged with the petitions process, our clerks and members.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.