Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

In Care Survivors Service (PE1596)

Thursday 24 May 2018 Public Petitions Committee About 10:15 Petitions 7 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

PE1596 is from Paul Anderson, James McDermott and Chris Daly.

When we last considered the petition in March, we agreed to seek the views of members of the cross-party group on adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse. We have since received submissions from Health in Mind and Wellbeing Scotland.

The clerk’s note summarises the differing views in the submissions. It notes that Health in Mind is part of the future pathways alliance, which is tasked with oversight of the operation of the future pathways fund. Health in Mind sees future pathways as a

“gateway to a wide range of flexible, person-centred support and services, which complement the more limited choices available through conventional funding”.

It states that cognitive behavioural therapy treatments that are used by NHS providers follow

“a biopsychosocial model, not a medical model”.

Wellbeing Scotland, which was formerly called Open Secret, provides the in care survivors service. Although it acknowledges the additional support that is offered by the future pathways fund, it is concerned that it is in

“a subservient power dynamic with Future Pathways”.

Wellbeing Scotland adds that it considers that the model of support, whether that is biopsychosocial or medical,

“has caused further confusion and concern”.

It suggests that many survivors do not identify with mental health services and adds that anxiety has increased among some survivors because they feel that the future pathways fund is working towards a model of time-limited support and that

“the promise of lifelong support … has been withdrawn”.

I declare an interest as a member of the cross-party group on adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse. I have met the future pathways alliance, the petitioner and Wellbeing Scotland. I had a very productive meeting with the future pathways alliance and was interested to see how that model works. There is a backlog—there is an eight or nine month waiting list. The issue is that if a person who is not registered with future pathways cannot access the services, they are just waiting, even if the service is provided by Wellbeing Scotland. That is a concern.

When I met one of the petitioners and Wellbeing Scotland, the questions that they raised were about the process of future pathways. For example, there was a suggestion that a survivor would have to have a consultation with a clinical psychologist. Many survivors do not want to do that because of their previous experience and because they do not want to have a clinical diagnosis of something that has happened to them, because that could have an impact on their lives. There is a fear that people might not go to the future pathways alliance because of that.

The petitioners and Wellbeing Scotland are also concerned about whether—a group-work model is used—individual counselling over a longer period will be available, and think that that should not be time limited. When I met the future pathways alliance, it said that support does not have to be time limited.

We also discussed the issue briefly at a meeting of the cross-party group, at which it was not possible to reach a unified view. However, there is no doubt that everyone wants to ensure that people get the support that they require. The argument is really about whether organisations should—as other support services do; for example, Women’s Aid—get core funding and be accountable for how they spend it, or be given money by the people whom they treat. Some folk, including Anne Macdonald, who initially petitioned the committee on a strategy for survivors, feel that the brokerage model is not right for people who have experienced that kind of trauma.

I am struck that the debate is now not as much about the specific issue in the petition on funding of Open Secret, as it is about whether we are doing the right thing in terms of how we support survivors. It is a very interesting issue, given the pivotal role of the Public Petitions Committee in getting the Scottish Executive—as it was at the time—to produce a strategy.

Would it be useful to gather evidence on whether the models that are being developed are the ones that people feel the most comfortable with? It is such a live issue because of the current inquiry and because adults are speaking out. We need to ensure that there is support for them. I am sure that we all, including the Scottish Government, agree about that.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

There is, of course, the additional issue, which Wellbeing Scotland has highlighted, of the nine-month waiting list and the requirement that survivors must be registered within three months. Clearly, there is disparity and there is a funding issue for Wellbeing Scotland, if it is funded through a brokerage model. The submission from Wellbeing Scotland certainly makes for interesting reading. For someone looking in, at first glance it seems that the brokerage model is working; however, it is not working for Wellbeing Scotland, to the extent that the future pathways alliance claims.

I declare that I had dealings with Open Secret before it became Wellbeing Scotland, so I am fully aware of the issues that it has been facing. Of particular concern to me is the statement from Wellbeing Scotland that the promised lifelong support does not exist. I remember that that was promised way back at the start, when the new model was being considered. It is extremely concerning if the alliance has gone back on that.

There is a strong argument for asking the future pathways alliance to give us evidence face to face, so that we can get to the bottom of the matter. The issue needs to be addressed once and for all; it has been dragging on far too long.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

It is exactly as the convener said: we are now considering whether the model and the framework are correct. It is a big issue, so we need to hear directly from the organisations.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be fair to say that the Scottish Government has put quite significant funding into the future pathways fund. The extent to which that is channelled towards support is, in itself, interesting.

I made an analogy when I met with Wellbeing Scotland. I said that you would not fund an accident and emergency department on the basis of how many broken legs came in; you would provide the service, and if nobody came in with a broken leg, so be it. I am concerned that the service in question is being funded differently, and I am interested in the argument for why that is the case.

As I mentioned, the original petitioner, Anne Macdonald, said to me that she did not feel that that model was in line with the original view of how to support people. I am not saying that the cross-party group would have taken a completely unified view on that, and I would not want to represent it in that way.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I do not know whether we will go into this kind of detail, but mental health has taken on a much more prominent role in Parliament during the short time that I have been here. I am interested to see how that model fits into our mental health approach, which is still evolving. I am keen to hear evidence on how that model aligns itself with the current mental health strategy.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Certainly, the desire is to have a trauma-informed approach. Survivors often say, “Actually, I am okay; what has caused my problem is the trauma that I have gone through”. That touches on the argument about whether it is a medical model or a social model.

It has been suggested, and I think that we all agree, that we would look for a session with the future pathways alliance, Wellbeing Scotland and petitioners—if they feel able—which would afford them the opportunity to hear that evidence and respond to us. We might want to have another session, after that.

It is also the case that there is among survivors generally a sense that much of the abuse that they experienced was in their own homes and communities rather than in care. That raises the broader point that how we support people who have lived through trauma is important.

Do members agree to give the clerks authority to work out how best to run such meetings?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We thank all those who responded with submissions. I want to thank, in particular, the petitioner, Paul Anderson, for meeting me.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 17
  3. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 19
  4. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.