Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2016/17 audit of NHS Tayside: Financial sustainability”

Thursday 29 March 2018 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–11:15 Committee business 465 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

465 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item 2 is on the 2016-17 audit of NHS Tayside. I welcome our first panel of witnesses today. Professor Sir Lewis Ritchie is chair of the NHS Tayside assurance and advisory group, Caroline Lamb is the chief executive of NHS Education for Scotland and chair of the NHS Tayside transformation support team, and Alan Gray is the director of finance at NHS Grampian, who has, I understand, served on the assurance and advisory group and on the transformation support team.

I will open with the first question. We have invited you today to explore the detail of the second report of the assurance and advisory group. Sir Lewis’s covering letter states:

“The rating assigned by TST to the current financial position has moved from red to amber, reflecting the progress that has been made in reducing the actual and projected level of NHS Tayside’s financial shortfall.”

It goes on:

“At senior executive team level, we are encouraged by indications of improved organisational grip of the financial situation.”

Since then, there have been revelations that £5.3 million of e-health funds have been misrecorded in NHS Tayside accounts, and that the 2017-18 financial outturn is likely to deteriorate further. Can you please tell the committee why we should have confidence in the rest of your report, under those circumstances?

Professor Sir Lewis Ritchie NHS Tayside Assurance and Advisory Group
link

I thank you, on behalf my colleagues and myself, for inviting us to attend today.

We were not made aware of that financial misreporting, or of the position, during the organisation and conducting of our review, or in the subsequent assessment of progress. The matter came to light only when the committee was informed about it. As far as I am concerned, that was the first time that I heard about it. Our assessment of progress was based on what had been reported to the board up until the end of January, and on what we saw.

In our report we talk about improved grip, about evidence of better team working and about leadership. That is detailed in the transformation support team report—the second report—which Caroline Lamb led on. That is why we felt that the tide was turning, although there was much further to go on the matter.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You have said that you were not made aware of the position; I think that there were also other people in that situation as regards the funds. Are you confident that you were made aware of enough of what was going on to complete your report?

Professor Ritchie
link

My view is that it is a work in progress. Transformation takes quite some time. When I decided to accept the commission, I felt that although it was important to address immediate financial concerns around grip, and the gap between budgeting control and operational performance, it was also important to take a root-and-branch look at how services were being delivered in NHS Tayside.

Transformation takes time, ownership and leadership. Correction of the financial position of NHS Tayside, which has been in progress for some years, will require massive transformation. To set that process in place, it was important for us to know what was happening with service delivery and what was being done under the transformation programme.

Our report pointed out that there was insufficient grip and insufficient clarity on the details of the transformation programme as it stood, and that further external assistance was required—both through financial support, which has been provided by Mr Alan Gray and others, and regarding the gap in strategic planning. In other words, unless those deficits were corrected, any financial movement in the short term would be about transactional change rather than transformational change. That is what is required, and will be required on an on-going basis, to deliver sustainable budgetary and financial control in NHS Tayside.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What was your scope, and how far into the organisation of NHS Tayside did you go? Transformational change in any organisation requires team leaders on the ground to buy into the transformation programme and to deliver it in their areas. How far did your team go into the organisation to speak to lead clinicians about their specific projects and about how transformation was happening?

Professor Ritchie
link

You will see the number of visits that I made set out in the annex to my first staging report. I set aside all my other work for the three-month period when we conducted the initial work for the staging report. I and my colleagues undertook many site visits, we met many groups and we met many individuals at the coalface. We met committees and the board, both collectively and individually. I, myself, met each executive team member of NHS Tayside as part of our initial fact-finding exercise.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We can come to the management later. On the ground, what was the sense among the doctors, nurses and health professionals to whom you were speaking of how transformational change could happen, whether it was happening, whether they were being enabled to make it happen, whether it was worth while and whether it was going to yield results? How was morale among them?

Professor Ritchie
link

As we stated in our report, my feeling was that there was lack of buy-in to the transformation programme, in particular on the part of front-line staff. The transformation programme board, which we visited and whose work we witnessed, had clearly held much of its business in camera at the outset, so there was a feeling that engagement was not as early or thorough as it should have been.

Along with my colleagues, I spent many hours discussing the need for transformation, in particular with clinical colleagues, because clinical leadership, with support staff behind the clinicians, is essential for transformation. Transformation is a common endeavour. It is not something that you do once; you have to keep on doing it, and that requires a high degree of ownership across the system.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You got a sense from some front-line staff that there was not complete buy-in. Did you get any sense of why that was?

Professor Ritchie
link

There is a misperception that transformation is something that can be done in a short space of time, and that what is planned in a boardroom is made clear and shared at ground level. There is also the question of when engagement should occur. We said that it did not occur early enough, and that that had to change.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is that changing now?

Professor Ritchie
link

I understand from my observations and from those of others that the tide is turning.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I read your report before the revelation about the £5.3 million came to light.

Professor Ritchie
link

Indeed.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How does something like that affect team leaders, with it being such a glaring omission or mistake at management level? How does that affect the confidence of the people who have to deliver the transformational change?

Professor Ritchie
link

My feeling on the day when I and the committee heard about the matter was disappointment, and not only about the financial hole that had opened up. I support your point—that will affect morale. Having a workforce with high morale is key to effective transformation. My reaction, when I heard about that was, quite simply, disappointment.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Good morning, everyone. I wish to continue to tease out the issues that the convener has introduced. Why has this taken so long? You said yourself that the issue with the overall financial position has existed for some years in NHS Tayside. Why has it taken so long for it to dawn on the organisation that transformational change may be required?

Professor Ritchie
link

That is a good question. My answer is that, when the tide is coming in as regards development resources, as happened in the national health service for many years, it is easier to carry on with incremental change—in other words, to move a service here, and do a little bit there. When the tide of resource begins to go out, however, people will begin to say that such change is not sufficient. It is not possible to improve the financial position just by improving the financial processes; service redesign needs to be considered. The tide has not been so generous—development moneys have not been flowing in so much, which means that the financial position and the service are more exposed.

You will know that NHS Tayside has more sites and more personnel in most categories, and has greater energy expenditure. That has been the case for some time and was the subject of a previous task force and Audit Scotland review in 2001. Clearly, insufficient attention was paid in the intervening years to what was needed to redesign services in NHS Tayside to make them sustainable, and in order for them to continue to be high quality and safe. Such characteristics are absolutely essential.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Would you say that those kinds of questions have never really been considered or posed within the organisation to date?

Professor Ritchie
link

I fully believe—as we found out during the fact-finding stage between April and June last year—that the board is now fully sighted on the need for transformation. Recommendations were made last time on the moment and on the year, but as business went back to usual, sight of the issues was lost. There is now a concerted effort: I do not believe that NHS Tayside and its partners—which are important for effective transformation—are anything other than sighted on and committed to making that change.

However, transformation will be neither quick nor easy; difficult decisions lie ahead. It requires taking not just the public of Tayside with the board and its partners, but political representatives in Tayside. Leadership of a very high order will be needed for that, and it will need to be concerted and continuous for some time. This is not the work of a year, let alone six months, which is what we were given to report progress to you at this point.

As regards my view and the view of my colleagues on the assurance and advisory group, we have recommended that external scrutiny by the Government of the activities of NHS Tayside should continue accordingly at a high level, and that progress further out from the recommendations that were published in the first place should be reassessed. There should no let-up on the matter.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

There is a reason for my dwelling on this point. We hear such messages fairly regularly at this committee, and have done over the years. Is the situation pointing at capacity and skills issues, at governance issues or at guidance and regulation? What suite of skills should be introduced to, or brought to bear on, the organisation in order to prevent something similar happening a year or so down the line?

Professor Ritchie
link

I will make several points on that. I might want to bring in Caroline Lamb in relation to her assessment and support, and on the workings of the transformation support team.

I preface what I will say by mentioning that all the aspects and items that Willie Coffey has mentioned will be important. The nub of the matter is that transformation depends on many things coming together. It is not just one thing. In the past, there would be a focus on this, that and the other. That is not peculiar to NHS Tayside. Transformation depends on a global perspective, however, and on many people doing things together that they might not have been doing before. It requires mutual understanding, effective leadership and adequate support.

09:15

As you are aware, we made 14 recommendations—10 for NHS Tayside and four for the Government. We recognised almost from the get-go of our assessment that external support would be required, and that NHS Tayside could not go it alone. That is the difference between our assessment and previous assessments, where financial adjustments were made and some local leadership was changed. We needed external support—with Mr Gray on my left and Ms Lamb on my right. Colleagues have tried to provide that since the staging report was published.

I invite Caroline Lamb to comment.

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

The assurance and advisory group, which was referred to by Sir Lewis, issued 10 recommendations for NHS Tayside and four for the Scottish Government. The role of the TST has been very much to provide support and constructive challenge to NHS Tayside in implementing the recommendations. It has not been a matter of our going in and doing the work for the board; it has involved supporting the team in situ to deliver on the recommendations.

The recommendations cover the various elements that need to be in place for transformation. The most immediate recommendation—recommendation 1—is about the need to get an urgent grip on the in-year financial position and the ability to manage that.

There is a longer-term recommendation about the importance and absolute centrality of the integrated clinical strategy and the work that is being done on that to deliver medium-term and longer-term financial sustainability and quality services across Tayside. Linked to that are the recommendations that address key areas of financial pressure—as were identified by the assurance and advisory group—around workforce, prescribing costs and improved business planning.

You might categorise the second half of the recommendations—on delegation, engagement, corporate structures, scrutiny and, in particular, leadership development—as being fundamental to creating the conditions that are required to support transformation. That is not an overnight activity, and it is not something that we might set off to do today for it to be done by the end of the week or the end of the month. It is a long-term activity that requires the building of relationships, confidence and trust. It takes some time.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you for that. It still worries me, however, that we have waited six years or so to begin the journey towards real transformational change in NHS Tayside. I am not quite sure that I can take any comfort from what you are saying, but I am certainly assured that we are now thinking along those lines, and that it is now our intention and purpose to bring that to bear within the organisation.

Can you give us a brief glimpse—a practical example—of the transformational change that is required of NHS Tayside and that you see, so that people who are watching the meeting can understand? We have been speaking in general terms.

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

It is important to recognise that progress has been made. It is important to recognise that, although—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Can you give us a specific example?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

Absolutely. The board now has improved information and data on its workforce and where it is deployed. There is improved partnership working with the vacancy management group, which means that the staff side and management are sitting down and talking about how to manage the staffing establishment. That has started to show evidence of reductions in spend on nursing agency staff in particular, which we know is not just expensive but is not the best way of providing services to patients. It has clearly been difficult to sustain that during the winter period, but the foundations have been laid for that to continue.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Clearly, a key element of this whole transformation is the bottom line. It is all about bringing NHS Tayside back into some sort of balance. To what extent are you satisfied that the information that is coming from the finance area, particularly given the revelation that we have discussed, is accurate?

Professor Ritchie
link

We have looked at what we have been given. With the support of EY initially, we decided to take a—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Just for the public’s information, that is Ernst & Young.

Professor Ritchie
link

It used to be known as Ernst & Young; it is now called EY. In order to do the work initially, we had to approach it in a parallel way. EY—formerly Ernst & Young—was commissioned to do a deep dive on the financial situation in Tayside in relation to the board’s budgets and so on. When we came to our review in June, we had the benefit not only of our own views but of an audit that was undertaken by EY on our behalf.

Professor Ritchie
link

The Scottish Government commissioned it at the outset.

Professor Ritchie
link

I am not aware of that—I was not informed of that. I did not commission that audit; it was commissioned at the outset by the Scottish Government.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

That is correct. It was commissioned by the Scottish Government, and we relied on it for part of our findings for the first report in June. We did not commission it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We can check the cost of it with Paul Gray.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Yes, we can do that, and you can ask that question.

Professor Ritchie
link

I am always sceptical about what people tell me about finances. I have served on boards for a number of years, and it is always good to be sceptical in relation to any response, in particular in relation to money. Therefore, it was important that NHS Tayside received external financial support rapidly. That support has come largely in the form of input from Alan Gray and from other colleagues. Alan is of course lead financial director for the north of Scotland, and has been helping NHS Tayside directly. Alan may wish to comment.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I recognise the point about the clarity of the financial information that was presented to the board and to other users within the organisation for managing the budget. Some revisions have been made so that the financial reporting is clearer on the underlying financial position and on how the overall financial position has been managed. Some steps have been taken to change the quality of the financial reporting that is going to the board.

My colleagues from NHS Tayside who will be on your second panel might wish to talk about what they have done in recent weeks to improve clarity. We presented the revised format to the board on Monday of this week, and we received positive feedback.

Part of the aim is to ensure that the users of the information understand the financial position. Some of the information could have been presented in a different way previously so as to make it easier for a non-financial person to understand the financial position and be able to ask questions.

Part of the role of non-executives is to scrutinise and challenge. If they are not provided with information in a format that allows them to do that, it makes their job that bit more difficult. The current format of reporting should make it much easier for non-executive members with no financial background to ask questions about and challenge the financial position of the board.

Professor Ritchie
link

When I said “sceptical” I was referring to the important scrutiny and challenge role, not to an unhealthy scepticism about what people are telling me. We need to look very carefully at the evidence, listen carefully to what people say and challenge them accordingly. That is a process.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You are clearly very reliant on the reliability of the information coming to you. From the review that was done, it seems that there was a lack of control over part of the process. Given that EY did a deep audit or took a deep look at the financial situation, how it was being managed and so on, are you surprised that the revelation came to light only now, rather than as part of that audit process?

Professor Ritchie
link

No, I am not, because a forensic analysis of the financial systems within NHS Tayside was not part of our remit. EY was there to consider how NHS Tayside was financing its transformation programme, and it reported accordingly. In other words, it did what it was asked to do.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So, EY was not reporting on systems, approvals and all the rest of it.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

No. That would be the role of the external auditors. Audit Scotland, in its role as external auditor, would be considering the systems and processes through which the financial information was produced. Ernst & Young’s remit was to examine the overall financial position, the underlying deficit and the factors contributing to that. It was not a financial audit.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I think that the term that was used was “in-depth”.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

It would be in depth. It was in depth in analysing the drivers for why the financial position was as it was and the factors contributing to that. That was EY’s role. The external auditor’s role would be to examine the systems of control, process and governance within the organisation and to report back on that to the board.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Coming back to the core element of this, how satisfied are you now that the reporting that you are receiving and the information that you are relying on is accurate? A few weeks ago, it was not.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Some further work is still going on to clarify the financial position. A series of questions have been asked about review and challenge to ensure that we understand all aspects of the financial position and what has contributed towards it. We have now re-forecast the year-end position for NHS Tayside to reflect some of that review. That work will take a few more weeks to conclude.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I want to be sure that I am not misinterpreting what you are saying. You are saying that, at this moment, we do not actually know what the financial position will be. There are still elements being worked out, and there are still uncertainties.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

What we have done—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Could I just ask: was the revised projected deficit to be reported to the board meeting on Monday? Is that correct?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Yes, indeed. That is correct.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The minutes of that meeting are not yet public. Can you tell us what that figure was?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

The deficit position at month 11 was just over £11 million. On the re-forecast position, based on information that we know to date, we are forecasting an outturn of £12.1 million for the end of the year.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

That was reported to the board on Monday, was it?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Indeed it was. It was also reported as part of the return to the Scottish Government. That was part of our financial reporting. We are asked to do an in-year, end-of-month position, but also an end-of-year position. Clearly, we are getting close to the end of the year, so we should be able to clarify that position in the coming weeks.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Has the issue that has arisen created any doubt in your minds about the accuracy of the information that you are getting? I am a little bit worried about this situation. We have had problems continuously for some years. We think that we have got our hands round it, but suddenly a revelation pops up. That of course creates doubt as to whether there is something else there.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I guess that that is why we are asking lots of questions—on every line and all areas of the financial position—to ensure that we understand all the component parts of that position. We will see where we get to in confirming things over the next few weeks. I can only know what I know just now. The finance team and I, along with other colleagues, are asking as many questions as we can. We have an external audit coming up in the next few weeks, and I am hoping that that will also contribute to improving the understanding of the financial position.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What about the role of internal audit? Are you making use of that?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Internal audit has been very helpful in identifying control weaknesses and improvement. We are working with that team to understand how many control actions have been taken forward and implemented. There are on-going discussions with internal audit about the role that it can play.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Internal audit did not pick this matter up.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Internal audit flagged the use of the deferred expenditure as a means of managing the financial position. To be fair to those conducting the internal audit, they highlighted that there was an area of weakness within the financial controls of the organisation.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Who did they flag that to?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Our assurance and advisory committee highlights a number of instances where the internal auditors have highlighted the use of deferred expenditure to the audit committee and the board. We also referenced that in our report.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are you telling us that the internal audit team had flagged that use of e-health funds to the board previously?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

No, no. I will clarify that. Within the category of funds that we call deferred expenditure, of which e-health money was one component part, they did not identify that. It would have been difficult for them to flag that up.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So, what had the internal auditors identified?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I will explain how the board’s financial position is managed. We are asked to work within a single revenue resource limit in any financial year. That comprises the core board allocation under the NHS Scotland resource allocation committee—NRAC—formula and the money for general medical services, as well as covering what is called earmarked funding. Earmarked funding is allocated to boards all the way through the year. The earmarked funding will often require to be spent over more than one financial year.

As for what had been happening in Tayside, the earmarked funding that had been allocated to the board had not been spent as quickly as it should have been. It was building up within the financial position. At the end of last year, £23 million of earmarked funding had not been committed in year, and would be carried forward into future years. Within that £23 million of allocations was the £5.3 million of e-health allocations.

It would not have been easy for the internal auditors to pick out what the allocations were. I suspect that, given the way that the information was reported, it would be difficult for them specifically to pick out the nature and the source of the funds.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It would have been difficult for internal audit to pick that out.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Yes.

09:30

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am curious about why that would be difficult for internal audit. The internal auditors have the right to look into anything that they have a concern about. It is not a small sum. You may say that it is a small sum in relation to the overall budget of the board, but it is still £5 million-odd. To me, that buys an awful lot of goods for the hospital.

I am thinking about what the board actually received. Is there anything there? If something had been highlighted by internal audit, do you think that the board would have been concerned about it? Would it have investigated?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

The board was concerned. The board had taken steps to reduce its dependence on that level of deferred expenditure. Last year it was £23 million, and the board was taking steps to reduce that. The board was taking all the steps that it felt were right to improve the position and to reduce reliance on that type of money, ensuring that earmarked funding was getting used much more quickly to support the professional services. The board had taken on board the findings from internal audit and was taking them forward in implementing actions.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Coming back to the money, from your perspective, do you have a timescale within which you believe that you will have satisfied yourself that the finance side is 100 per cent in order and that we can rely on the figures coming out?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Coming back to the particular issue that has arisen, that creates a doubt, does it not?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I would agree that there is an aspect of building trust and confidence again regarding the financial information and the quality of the information that we present to the board—there is no doubt about that.

It will take a bit of time to do that. We have reassigned responsibility in the finance function, and a number of reviews are on-going to identify what further action needs to be taken. We will get internal audit in to help us.

The board is minded also to commission an independent review, as was highlighted in a letter to Paul Gray.

All those factors should help us to come up with a clear action plan to improve the controls within the finance function and the quality of the financial reporting. I cannot give you a final timeline for that, but my aim would be to get as much of that done as possible by the end of June so that you can have confidence going into the next financial year that the information that is being produced is reliable and so that the board can make decisions on the basis of that information.

Professor Ritchie
link

That is another reason why we continue to recommend regular scrutiny by the Government of the financial affairs of NHS Tayside, as well as the undertaking of a further review in the next financial year at a suitable point. The answer is that the situation requires continued scrutiny, and it is a work in progress.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Have you taken any steps to hold discussions with internal audit in particular about the scope of its audit, and about whether it needs to be beefed up or is adequate as it is, at least for the interim period and until you are satisfied?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Yes. I am due to have a meeting next week with the chief internal auditor to understand what is in the programme of work for the remainder of this year and next year and to see what we can do to reprioritise the work in order to address some of the issues that have been highlighted in the Grant Thornton report and that were widely internally audited in previous years.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Good morning. We have heard quite a bit about clarifying the financial position, reforecasting requirements and scrutiny of NHS Tayside’s financial affairs. In late February, the director of finance decided to retire after some 35 years. That was confirmed—I think there was a letter from Lesley McLay to Paul Gray in which that was referenced in one line. Are you able to tell us why the director of finance suddenly disappeared, and in what circumstances?

Professor Ritchie
link

The answer to that is no. I only became aware of the findings of financial misreporting at the same time as your committee. I have certainly had no part whatever to play in the circumstances, or indeed in any corrective actions following our report, which was submitted a month ahead of this particular item coming to the attention of the Government and NHS Tayside.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Does that not rather concern you?

Professor Ritchie
link

It does, but it is not within my remit. You ask whether it concerns me. Yes, it does. Is it within our remit, and was it within our remit? The answer to that is no. I suspect that you may wish to tease that out further with the next panel.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Forgive me—I have been a bit blindsided here. You are in there to look after the transformation. The director of finance, who has apparently presided over a situation that we have explored in some detail, has just disappeared. If I am hearing you right, you are not asking questions about that. Is that correct?

Professor Ritchie
link

My role has been completed with the presentation of a second report. However, I have since been asked to go in to do a further assessment of progress in September, with Caroline Lamb.

That may change in the light of circumstances that I am not fully aware of.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Mr Gray, do you have any view on that?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

No—I cannot comment on it. All I can say is that I have been asked to provide some interim financial support to the board, and I am doing that to my current capacity, but I was not involved in any discussions about the retirement of the previous director of finance. All that I can confirm to the committee is that I have been tasked with giving some support to the finance team and to the board at this particular point in time. That remains my focus for the next few weeks, until I am happy that we can move forward.

There is a paper coming to the board today regarding the appointment of an interim or permanent director of finance to take on that responsibility for the foreseeable future.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

On that note, is any cost being incurred for your own services as a result of the resignation? I understand that there has been a realignment among the finance team.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I can confirm that there is no payment for my time. I am part of a regional structure now, for the north of Scotland region. I have agreed with my board that I can be released from part of my current duties to support the Tayside board. I have been doing that for some weeks now, with the blessing of my board. There is no cost incurred by Tayside.

We are not bringing any additional capacity into the finance team at this point in time. I am looking at the capacity and capability in the finance team and, if we determine that there is a need to improve the capacity in that team, I would take that to the board as a recommendation. However, at this stage, there is no additional investment of resource in the finance team or cost being incurred by NHS Tayside as a result of the retiral of the director of finance.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Is appropriate financial leadership in place at NHS Tayside? Perhaps more importantly, has there been appropriate financial leadership in the past, and will there be in the future?

Professor Ritchie
link

During my initial review, I met all of the executive team, as I mentioned earlier. I asked, “Are you confident that you have the necessary skills and leadership in all the areas that are required for effective transformation going forward?” Primarily, it is for the board to satisfy itself that that is the case. However, as you are aware, we immediately suggested to the Government that additional external support was required, particularly in relation to finance and strategic planning, to make it more granular and to see what detail was required. The transformation support team was established to do that.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

In the papers that we are looking at today, there is reference to a report by KPMG. I remind members that my entry in the register of members’ interests says that I was a partner in KPMG, but of course I had no part to play in any of this work.

I have a question, Professor Ritchie. You have spoken a lot about the importance of leadership at the head of NHS Tayside for its future transformation. Who is the leader on whose shoulders that burden now falls?

Professor Ritchie
link

Leadership is required at all levels in NHS Tayside, not just at board level. Transformation has to be led primarily by the board, but not only by the board. The clinical leadership will be very important in relation to transformation, which will not happen without buy-in or without the clinical leaders in Tayside continuing to rise to the occasion.

Bill Bowman Con North East Scotland
link

You are saying that there is a group of leaders. Who is the leader of that group of leaders?

Professor Ritchie
link

The chairman of the board leads the activities of the board, supported by the accountable officer, who is the chief executive. That is where it starts, basically. However, leadership has to be evident among non-executives, and it needs to be evident throughout the organisation.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Mr Gray, when Colin Beattie asked you about internal audit, you said that the board was aware of the deferred expenditure, including the £5.3 million.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

No. To clarify, the board was aware of deferred expenditure generally. The board was not aware of the £5.3 million, nor was internal audit. None of us was aware of that situation, which has been known about only in the last few weeks.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

But that deferred expenditure included the £5.3 million.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

It did indeed—that is correct.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You have said that the board was aware of the deferred expenditure. In what way was it aware of it? Was it reported at a board meeting? Can you clarify that for us?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

It would be reported at audit committee meetings. Internal audit reports would go to the audit committee. I cannot clarify whether that information went to a board meeting, but it certainly went—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Sorry—could you speak a little bit more slowly?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I beg your pardon. The internal audit reports would go to a number of audit committee meetings, in which references were made to the use of deferred expenditure as part of the financial position. I cannot comment on whether that information was reported at a board meeting, but it certainly went to an audit committee meeting and the matter was considered there. It was also referenced in our assurance and advisory report, which went to a board meeting. We make references to the use of deferred expenditure in that report, which came out in June 2017.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

This is quite puzzling. There was a sum of deferred expenditure—

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

It was £23 million.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

The audit committee and the board were aware of that. I think that Sir Lewis said that they had expressed a view, or the view had been expressed, that some grip had to be taken of that situation. In other words, the failure to spend money in time, and therefore the need to defer it, had to be improved. Is that right?

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

Indeed.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Surely, in that process, the audit committee and/or the board must have asked, “What is this deferred expenditure? What is the activity for which we have allocated funds that are not being spent in-year?” If the committee or the board did that, how can it possibly be that they were not told that £5.3 million, almost a quarter of that sum, was the e-health money? I do not see how that is possible.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

I cannot comment on what the audit committee may or may not have asked. I was not at any of the audit committee meetings. It is a fair question.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I take it that it is a reasonable question.

Alan Gray NHS Grampian
link

It is a reasonable question to ask, yes. I have no doubt about that.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, Mr Gray.

Sir Lewis, I would like to drill down into one of the specific areas that I am particularly concerned about, and which the Auditor General for Scotland has been particularly concerned about—prescribing in NHS Tayside. It has been identified for years now as one of the key things that the board needs to get a grip of. I spend all my time in Dundee and in the locality of NHS Tayside, and I continually hear stories about people’s repeat prescriptions not being checked for years and years, the stockpiling of medicines and so on.

I have read the parts of your report on prescribing. When is that issue actually going to be solved? Are general practitioners in control of it? There is also secondary prescribing in hospitals. Is sufficient progress being made?

Professor Ritchie
link

That issue was identified in recommendation 5. We said that efforts “should continue unabated”, as we recognised that there were discrepancies in prescribing across the piece in Tayside. Caroline Lamb can comment on that specifically.

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

Indeed, that was clearly identified as a recommendation. We recognised that we did not have any particular expertise in prescribing within our core membership as a support team, and we therefore engaged with the effective prescribing division at the Scottish Government. Alpana Mair and Simon Hurding provided us with advice on that. They engaged closely with the Tayside team.

In our second report, we identified that some improvements had been made. That was down to putting in place processes to enable improved prescribing practice. One of the areas where progress has been made is the number of polypharmacy reviews that have been undertaken—reviewing what medications are being prescribed to people. That process is on-going.

In September we had a red rating on that. We moved that to an amber rating, based on the advice, as we could start to see some developments. It will still be some time before that progress starts to show in the financial savings.

09:45

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are the developments that allowed you to move the rating from red to amber the polypharmacy reviews?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

There were improvements in polypharmacy reviews, improved clinical—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

For the layman, can you explain exactly what those reviews involve?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

I will try—I am not an expert in this area.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am sorry, but that concerns me as well. The Auditor General has identified prescribing as having been a problem in NHS Tayside for years now, but there was nobody on the review group with specific expertise in that area, and you had to refer back to the Scottish Government on it. Is that right?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

That is exactly what we recognised early on, from the first week: that we needed expertise in that area. We were able to access that within the Scottish Government so, in effect—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Sir Lewis, should you not have had somebody on your team who was able to drill down into that?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

In effect, Alpana Mair and Simon Hurding became members of the team, and they were part of the review.

Professor Ritchie
link

Prescribing has been a long-standing interest of mine in relation to my clinical practice. You will see in the first staging report that we extracted a bit of a board minute in relation to prescribing.

During the subsequent period, between September and December, I attended a prescribing management board meeting to look at and witness the progress myself. Am I satisfied with the progress? The answer to that is no.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

But the rating has moved to amber in your staging report.

Professor Ritchie
link

It has moved to amber on account of processes that have been put in place, in particular that of reviewing repeat prescribing. Prescribing happens in two ways—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is there any evidence that prescribing has reduced?

Professor Ritchie
link

The rate of increase in prescribing in Tayside has been less over the past year than the rate for Scotland.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The rate of increase has been less, but there is no evidence that it has reduced.

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

I think that what Sir Lewis is explaining is that, in general, prescribing has increased over the whole of Scotland over the past years. The fact that the rate for Tayside has increased by less indicates that the board has made some progress in reducing it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I understand that.

Professor Ritchie
link

Could I clarify that?

Professor Ritchie
link

There was a 0.7 per cent year-on-year reduction in medicines volume last year, versus a 0.3 per cent increase for Scotland. Those figures were provided to us by NHS Tayside.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The evidence for moving the rating from red to amber is not all that convincing. There have been more polypharmacy reviews. I think that Caroline Lamb is about to explain exactly what that means.

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

Polypharmacy reviews consist of reviews of patients who are on medication, to check that they are being prescribed the right things. There is a process of rolling through or working through the delivery of those.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Did you speak to any GPs about prescribing during your review process?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

There was engagement through the prescribing management group. Alpana Mair and Simon Hurding were engaged with that group, which involves both pharmacists and clinicians, including general practitioners.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It seems to me that there is not much evidence to support the movement from red to amber. The rate of increase of prescribing in Tayside might be slightly less than the rate for the rest of Scotland, but there is not a real weight of evidence that big improvements are being made. Would you agree with that?

Caroline Lamb NHS Education for Scotland and Transformation Support Team, NHS Tayside
link

That is why we would not go any further than amber. When we gave the amber rating we recognised that processes had been put in place, but they were yet to deliver an impact.

Professor Ritchie
link

We particularly tested that. When the AAG met the TST, that was the particular rating in relation to which I had concerns that we were perhaps being overgenerous. I understand where you are coming from in this matter.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you were more inclined to keep the rating at red.

Professor Ritchie
link

We accepted the rating and the rationale for it. However, tangible progress and substantive change on the ground have yet to emerge. That is why I would support your view.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So, referring to the people who are telling me that their prescriptions have not yet been reviewed, in your view it is probably the case that that has not yet happened.

Professor Ritchie
link

I cannot comment on that, but I know that there is a great deal of commitment among those at NHS Tayside to get things right. They recognise that they have much more to do. From my perspective and from the perspective of the AAG and the transformation support team, I want them to continue in that regard.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Let me ask you about transformational change on this level. I believe that public services must constantly be reformed and refreshed to meet the demands of our population and our citizens. Have you seen transformational change on the scale that is required by NHS Tayside? Have you seen it happen anywhere else before? I do not just mean in Scotland, but anywhere.

Professor Ritchie
link

I have not been a world traveller in observing transformational change, but transformational change can happen and does happen in other health systems.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

In Scotland or elsewhere?

Professor Ritchie
link

Worldwide—referring to the literature. I became particularly interested in transformational change in Scotland in relation to the out-of-hours review that I led three years ago. I quickly recognised that to achieve it would require a whole-system approach, which had never been attempted before.

There is not yet a massive amount of evidence of transformational change in Scotland, but there is a clear recognition that it needs to happen.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does the NHS Tayside management have the requisite skills or experience to deliver that transformational change on the scale that is required?

Professor Ritchie
link

At our staging report assessment from March to June, we took the view that NHS Tayside required urgent and additional skills to help it expedite that journey.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

When is your next report due?

Professor Ritchie
link

Along with Caroline Lamb, I have been commissioned by Paul Gray to examine the situation again in September this year. In the light of the recent circumstances that we have been discussing today, that may change in terms of tempo and intensity. That is something that I am sure will be discussed following this committee meeting. I am personally open, as are my colleagues, to continuing to support NHS Tayside through its journey.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So we should expect the next report in September at the latest. Is that correct?

Professor Ritchie
link

Paul Gray will need to agree the timing of that with you. That is an indicative timing at the moment. As I have said, in the light of recent events, I would need to consider very carefully how that work might be conducted as regards change methodology and so on.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I wish to follow up on something that the convener has just said. Recommendation 11 says:

“The Scottish Government should ensure that necessary skills, expertise and support are … made available”.

Professor Ritchie
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

At the point when that recommendation was made, did you have—or do you now have—a clear idea of what skills were missing and from which positions, either from the people who got into this situation or from those who were lacking in their ability to get out of the situation?

Professor Ritchie
link

Two particular areas were identified: first, financial skills, which is the reason Alan Gray became involved; and secondly, a gap or omission in strategic planning. That has been made good in the form of an interim director of strategic planning. As we say in the note on the report we submitted at the end of December, we believe that that needs to be looked at in permanence. In other words, there should be a substantive director of strategic planning in Tayside. That was a notable and early finding in relation to our staging report work.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you all very much indeed for your evidence this morning.

09:54 Meeting suspended.

09:58 On resuming—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I welcome our second panel of witnesses: Paul Gray, who is director general for health and social care at the Scottish Government and chief executive of the NHS in Scotland; Gordon Wales, who is chief financial officer at the Scottish Government; and, from NHS Tayside, Professor John Connell, who is chair of the board, and Lesley McLay, who is chief executive.

I will open the questioning. Ms McLay, how often do you go through the accounts of NHS Tayside?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I will take part in a number of activities as a core member of the board. I am a member of the finance and resources committee, which meets monthly to undertake a detailed review of our financial plans, and I am involved in the financial planning process in leading the director team.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How often would you sit down and go through the board’s accounts?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

It is less about going through the board’s accounts. Part of the role involves building the financial plans and reviewing progress against those plans. That is a regular feature of my role on the board, from a governance point of view, and in the review process at our monthly finance and resources committee.

10:00

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you would say that you are very familiar with NHS Tayside’s accounts.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I think that I am very clear on the progress of the budgets and the make-up of the budget overall. However, as chief executive, I have a director of finance, just as I have a medical director and a nursing director, and that accountability and professional role is delegated to and undertaken by them.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How often do you sit down with the director of finance and ask him about what is in the accounts?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

In my board, as would be the case in any board, I have weekly director meetings, in which we look at a range of aspects of the board’s performance and governance. Financial reviews are certainly a feature of that, but the formal review happens at our finance and resources committee, which is a sub-committee of our board, and a finance report goes to the board at every single board meeting.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We heard from Alan Gray that the board knew about the deferred expenditure, and we know from the Grant Thornton report that your director of finance, who has since retired, knew about the e-health funds. Did you know?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

In terms of the issue that we are discussing today? No—I was not aware.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

You were not aware.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I was not.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If the board and your director of finance were aware, why were you not aware?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The Grant Thornton independent review indicated that the board, the director and the executive team were not aware of the e-health allocations that had come in. I believe that Alan Gray, in discussing the board’s knowledge and my knowledge, was referring to the size of our deferred expenditure budget. He referred to the fact that the budget was bigger than we would have liked it to be. I was aware of the size of the budget, and I was part of the board meeting in which we instructed that we wanted a reduction in the size of the deferred budget and we agreed, through our audit committee into the board, that we would have a five-year plan to reduce the size of the budget.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you were aware of the size of the deferred expenditure—the £23 million.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes, I was.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Did you ask what that was made up of? I refer you to Iain Gray’s question to Alan Gray.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The finance director produces reports, which he provides to the financial executive team, the finance and resources committee and the board. The deferred expenditure total was in there, but it was in groupings. The size of the budget was £22.3 million, but there was not line-by-line detail on every single item.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Did you ask for that detail?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No, I did not ask for that.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Given the size and scale of the reports that the finance director produces, it would not be appropriate for me to ask for a single line. The budget for our board is approximately £800 million; I do not have a line-by-line account, and I would not expect to have one.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

But you are the chief accountable officer for NHS Tayside. You sign off the accounts.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes, I do.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Why would you not ask what that sizeable sum included?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

As the accountable officer, I have a director of finance whom I rely on to provide the financial information that comes through me and into the board.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

So you simply trust your legal, financial and clinical advice, and you do not ask further questions.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

No, of course not. Of course there is a level of governance and scrutiny in the board, which I conduct as chief executive, but there is also a level of accountability on those individuals to bring forward the relevant information, and to identify the risks and raise them, through me, with the committees and the board.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Ms McLay, I think that most people would expect that level of accountability to rest with you. It strikes me that, if you did not ask what the deferred expenditure included, you were not asking the right questions.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

As I said, you will see from the Grant Thornton report that they were small sums of money, and a review was undertaken—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Sorry—what were small sums of money?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

The allocations, as they came into NHS Tayside, did not come in as one figure of £2.53 million or £2.63 million. They did not come in like that. On reading the review, it was clear that the e-health allocations to NHS Tayside came in as small amounts.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

But that process has been on-going for six years.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

Yes. The first time that I was made aware of it was on reading the review. Obviously I was made aware of it, but I and the board were first made aware of the detail on receiving the Grant Thornton independent review, which said clearly that the practice had been followed since 2012.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

What questions do you ask? If you do not ask your director of finance what the deferred expenditure includes—if that is not a question that you ask of him—what questions do you ask?

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

I think that your question was whether I ask for detail line by line. I do not ask for a line-by-line—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I did not use the phrase “line by line”—you used that phrase. My contention is that you are the accountable officer for NHS Tayside, and £5.3 million has been misaccounted for. There was clear knowledge. According to the Grant Thornton report, your director of finance knew about that, and we now discover that the board knew about it, but you are telling us today that you did not know about it, nor did you see fit to ask about it.

Lesley McLay NHS Tayside
link

My understanding is that the independent review includes the statement that the board was not aware, and neither were the executive team or the leadership team. What we were aware of was the size of our deferred expenditure budget, which the board was taking steps to reduce.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 465

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.