Item 2 is on the 2016-17 audit of NHS Tayside. I welcome our first panel of witnesses today. Professor Sir Lewis Ritchie is chair of the NHS Tayside assurance and advisory group, Caroline Lamb is the chief executive of NHS Education for Scotland and chair of the NHS Tayside transformation support team, and Alan Gray is the director of finance at NHS Grampian, who has, I understand, served on the assurance and advisory group and on the transformation support team.
I will open with the first question. We have invited you today to explore the detail of the second report of the assurance and advisory group. Sir Lewis’s covering letter states:
“The rating assigned by TST to the current financial position has moved from red to amber, reflecting the progress that has been made in reducing the actual and projected level of NHS Tayside’s financial shortfall.”
It goes on:
“At senior executive team level, we are encouraged by indications of improved organisational grip of the financial situation.”
Since then, there have been revelations that £5.3 million of e-health funds have been misrecorded in NHS Tayside accounts, and that the 2017-18 financial outturn is likely to deteriorate further. Can you please tell the committee why we should have confidence in the rest of your report, under those circumstances?

