Good morning. Thank you for inviting me.
The larger part of the regulations provides for the annual uprating of the various allowances and premia in the council tax reduction scheme. The Scottish Government has introduced such legislation each year in order to maintain the original policy intention of the CTR scheme, which is to ensure that nobody will be worse off as a consequence of the abolition of council tax benefit in 2013.
Historically, the entitlement criteria for housing benefit and council tax benefit were almost identical. Broadly continuing to track the United Kingdom Government’s changes to the entitlement criteria for housing benefit—even though the legislative underpinnings of the two policies are profoundly different—helps to ensure that the CTR scheme continues to fulfil that original policy intention.
That said, the Scottish Government recognises that there a few ways in which things now diverge but, in the main, the continuing alignment of the two policies also has the additional advantage of keeping things a bit easier for those who have to navigate the council tax reduction and housing benefit policies—that is, people who have to apply for either or both and those who administer them. Indeed, there is one such divergence in the regulations that are in front of the committee this morning. Regulation 7, which is on page 3 of the instrument, would allow an application by someone of working age for a council tax reduction to be backdated—if good cause is shown—by up to six months, whereas the equivalent provision for housing benefit remains one month.
The Scottish Government is introducing the change to address circumstances that seem to be arising as a consequence of the roll-out of universal credit by the Department for Work and Pensions. In essence, difficulties seem to be arising with ensuring that those who make a claim for universal credit are made aware that they need to make a separate claim for council tax reduction and informed as to how they might set about making that application. As a consequence, in some areas, and most especially where universal credit full service is being rolled out, there is evidence that the number of council tax reduction applications is lower than might be expected. In other words, there is evidence of people who have little or no means of paying their council tax not applying for the reduction to which they are entitled, and consequently their council tax accounts fall into arrears. That is in nobody’s best interests, and regulation 7 is intended to help such individuals and councils prevent that situation from arising.
The committee will also note that regulation 3 introduces a new provision for applicants who are in receipt of universal credit. The effect of the new provision is to allow local authorities to estimate a person’s council tax reduction over a period if that person’s income is subject to frequent change. That is intended to allow a local authority to be pragmatic when a person earns different amounts each week or month. A very similar provision is in the principal scheme regulations for other categories of applicant.
As the law currently stands, any change to earnings, and thus to a universal credit award, requires the recalculation of council tax reduction and a consequent recalculation of residual council tax liability. Universal credit links to Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs’ real-time information system, which means that local authorities now know far more about changes to such circumstances than they ever did before. That can result in a person’s council tax bill being recalculated and re-issued every month—and sometimes corrections are entered into the system more than once a month. As a result, it is simply unclear to that person how much they are expected to pay. If I were in that situation—particularly if my monthly finances were precarious—I am not sure that I would be content to allow my council tax to be collected by direct debit, given that I would have no idea how much would be taken be each month.
If the account falls into arrears because the person does not know what they owe, the local authority cannot initiate any recovery proceedings because the account is subject to incessant rebilling. However, if it were possible for a representative figure to be identified for that person’s earnings, a universal credit award could be estimated and thus their net council tax liability could be calculated over a certain period, enabling both the applicant and the local authority to avoid the uncertainties of the relentless re-billing and recalculation that currently happen.
That is all that I have to say, but I will be pleased to answer any questions as best as I can.