I hope that I will get to that issue in due course, convener.
We—the BBC—are saying that for network television including sport, children’s TV, daytime TV, quizzes, factual TV and drama, we will make 8.6 per cent of all those genres in Scotland. As a result of that, there will be a mix of network content that we make shown across the country. Some of it will be drama and some of it will be comedy, which we will talk a bit more about. Steve Carson will talk to you about how we have evolved in that respect.
The 8.6 per cent production target is an economic measure. A couple of examples might help. We can talk about Sunset+Vine: I know there have been questions asked about the women’s FA cup final. I believe that Sunset+Vine is a great company to be based in Scotland. It has a great office and it has done work for us over maybe a decade. It covers shinty, bowls, football and rugby. It is on BT Sport with award-winning football coverage. It is a great company; it makes great stuff. It has also won work outside Scotland. It makes stuff outside Scotland and the BBC has, under the Ofcom rules, to badge that as having come from a specific place. We think that the company has a meaningful base in Scotland. It has employed apprentices. It did the Commonwealth games with us, for example.
Therefore the question is—there is not a right and a wrong—what do we think of Sunset+Vine’s presence? Should we be proud of that company exporting its skills and its expertise and making content elsewhere and therefore accept that that is one of the productions that will be badged as “from Scotland”, or should we not? That is the question. It qualifies because, I think, that is meaningful production, in a sense. Other people have a different view.
On the studio stuff that you were talking about earlier, we made a big decision quite a long time ago to build a studio at Pacific Quay. To feed that studio and keep the hundreds of people busy around that studio, we have to utilise and put a regular volume of work through that studio. That means we have to use lift and shift, which means making “Eggheads”, but it also means other productions, such as “Children in Need” and “Mrs Brown’s Boys”. Again, there is a question: is that good production for Scotland, with hundreds of people gaining skills and making wages, and mortgages being paid? We think that it is a good thing. We accept that it does not mean portrayal and that it does not mean representation in some cases, but if you want to make 8 per cent of all the BBC’s network production and to play a part in that, you have to accept that there is a mix of work involved.
I think that it is the right decision for Scotland that we have a studio. I think that it is the right decision that Channel 4, STV and the BBC utilise that studio. Without that, we would not have a studio, we would not make game shows, we would not make entertainment, but it means that some shows qualify about which some people might say, “Couldn’t it be better? Couldn’t it be a drama? Couldn’t it be this? Couldn’t it be that?” We all have to accept there is a difference between economics and Ofcom measures. Ofcom only measures economics. Portrayal and representation, and finding clever ways to measure portrayal are topics that we should discuss.
On earlier questions that were asked by the convener, we do comply, both before a production is made and after. If we are asked questions, we take complaints and issues seriously. We look at the returns that production companies make. We audit them when we are asked to do so, and we do our own review of them. We have a lot of knowledge in this area. Returns that are reviewed meet, on most occasions, the criteria that Ofcom has set. Whether the criteria could be tightened, improved or made slightly better is for discussion. I think that they can, but we comply as we are required to comply. That is how the system works.
The last thing that I will say is about what I term peripatetic productions: many productions move about the country and use staff and people from all over the country. The key measure for that is the production’s substantive base—whether a company has a substantive base and where it is. That is the question that we have to answer for Sunset+Vine, or any companies such as we are talking about. We feel that we qualify what we have to qualify, but I will stop there and pause.