Under the current regulations, if a motion to annul were carried, we would revert to the previous year’s regulations, which are the 2016 amendment regulations. You are quite right that they are not time limited and they would continue to apply for the 2018 fishing season, which would have implications for a large number of rivers. For reasons that I understand, we are concentrating today on the Loch Lomond system and Endrick Water, but there are a large number of rivers that will be grade 3 this year. That was part of the public consultation that we did in September and October, and we had a lot of representations about that. The grade change was not entirely a surprise to a lot of the fishing community, because the stocks and catches of salmon have been on a downward trend for quite a while. Therefore, in the entirety of the regulations that are currently being considered by the committee, this is the right way to go.
We model the salmon on the basis of a five-year average; arithmetically, we lost the figure for 2011, which was a good, healthy year for salmon catches, and brought in the figure for 2016 which, if I remember rightly, was something like 63 per cent of the 2011 figure. There could be wide implications; a lot of rivers that would be grade 3 this year might stay at grade 2, for example, and that would allow killing of salmon. Whether that is restricted or by local arrangement, there would be management arrangements in place.
10:00
As to whether primary legislation would be required, I am not sure whether that is the case. The primary legislation and the regulations at its base require an annual review of the position for the 17 special areas of conservation around the country, and we will continue to review them year on year. There is not a requirement to make annual regulations. I believe that, when the first regulations came into place, the cabinet secretary said that there would be an annual review and, as a result, this is the third set of regulations coming forward.
In England, the Government went to a public consultation last week on similar conservation measures for the 42 principal salmon rivers in England. Those would be 10-year byelaws with a five-year review. Under the terms of the consultation, if the bylaws came into place, many of the rivers in England would go to mandatory catch and release—the equivalent of our grade 3—for a 10-year period, with very little scope for review.
As Simon Dryden and Stuart Middlemas have said, we are continuing to develop and improve our model year on year. There are hard years, and this is going to be a hard year for quite a number of river systems. We understand that, but we will continue to review the situation and to invest in improving wild fisheries, and I hope that we will see some improvements. As part of our annual review process, we will bring forward regulations again. We have already started this year to think about the regulations for 2019.