I suppose the Irish example is unique in that, prior to the enfranchisement of prisoners, there was no law on the statute book that debarred prisoners from voting—it was simply that they could not access polling stations on the day of elections, referenda and so on. For that reason, no legislation needed to be repealed in order to enable prisoners to vote. In a court case in the early 2000s, the Supreme Court of Ireland said that prisoners were entitled to vote under the Electoral Act 1992. There was no facility to allow them to vote, but the court said that, if an individual happened to be on temporary release on the day of an election and they were registered in their home constituency, they were legally entitled to exercise their franchise.
In 2006, in response to the Hirst judgment, with which I am sure many committee members are familiar, the Irish Government decided to introduce legislation to enfranchise prisoners, for a number of reasons. There was some discussion about whether a case would be brought to the domestic courts and possibly up to the European Court of Human Rights to allow prisoners to vote or to force the Government to introduce legislation. The Government pre-emptively decided to introduce legislation, which would become the Electoral (Amendment) Act 2006, to enfranchise all prisoners regardless of their sentence or their crime, so the legislation was quite wide in its impact and effect. The first election following that act took place in 2007.
What was somewhat unique about the Irish experience was the lack of controversy surrounding the discussions and debates in Parliament. In the first instance, no member of either house—the Dáil, the lower house, or the Seanad, the upper house—spoke or voted against the legislation, and much of the discussion in the parliamentary debates was about the mechanics of how it would happen. There was an argument that prisoners should be enabled and encouraged to vote in order to engender a sense of responsibility.
Another key aspect was that there was no media opposition. In my research, I found only one reference in a national newspaper to the debates, and that was when the legislation was passed. That is in stark contrast to the research that I have done in the United Kingdom, where the media have tended to report on the issue as a matter of acute controversy, and they have generally come down against allowing prisoners to vote.
Another important element was that the legislation was introduced as an electoral reform—by the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government—rather than as a penal or criminal justice reform. It was put forward as an idea to modernise the electoral system. In contrast to what has happened in the United Kingdom, there was a much more positive outlook on and idea about the concept of Europe. In the United Kingdom, especially in England, in the Westminster Parliament, the issue has been caught up in the debates about Europe, even though it is the European convention on human rights and the European Court of Human Rights—and not the European Union—that have raised the issue of prisoner voting. It has been caught up in the general milieu and debates on the impact and powers of the European Union, and what has been considered European interference.
Therefore, a number of key elements distinguish the Irish case from other jurisdictions and enabled the passing of what was, in reality, a very minor piece of amending legislation, but one that made a major impact in enfranchising all prisoners regardless of their sentence or crime.