Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2016/17 audit of the Scottish Police Authority”

Thursday 25 January 2018 Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee About 09:00–11:00 Committee business 505 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

505 contributions · showing 1–200
Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Agenda item 2 is an evidence-taking session on the Auditor General’s 2016-17 audit of the Scottish Police Authority. I welcome Andrew Flanagan, former chair of the Scottish Police Authority; John Foley, former chief executive of the SPA; and David Hume and Dr Nicola Marchant, current board members of the Scottish Police Authority.

Although the purpose of today’s meeting is to take oral evidence on the Auditor General’s 2016-17 audit of the Scottish Police Authority, some members might also wish to ask questions about other governance issues that have emerged since the audit report was published. However, I should point out that the investigations of the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner—or PIRC—into senior police officers are still on-going under a statutory process and committee members and witnesses should not say anything that could compromise them.

I will start the questions. Mr Flanagan, much has been said in public about your meeting with the cabinet secretary in early November and the cabinet secretary himself has made a statement to Parliament on it. Can you give us your account of those events?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

It surrounded the situation at the end of October and the beginning of November. The chief constable’s leave was under consideration. The leave had been agreed in late August or early September and was subject to a four-weekly review that was coming up at the beginning of November; the chief constable had indicated that he was fit and able to return to work, and he had requested permission to do some work for the National Police Chiefs Council. Some of the other things that had been agreed at the start of his leave with regard to the stress that he was under and his health issues seemed no longer to be the case; the distraction created by the complaints seemed to have abated; and the SPA board had to take a view as to whether the terms of the leave conditions had been satisfied and whether he should return to work.

That was the discussion that we had, and we concluded that the temporary leave conditions had been fulfilled and that the chief constable should be considered for a return to work. In that situation, we also had to consider whether suspension would be appropriate, because we would have to face that issue on his return to work. We talked through those decisions. Only three options are open to the SPA in such a situation: the individual can remain in post; they can have restricted duties; or they can be suspended.

I should emphasise that suspension is no indication of wrongdoing or guilt. As far as suspension is concerned, there are only two considerations for the SPA: whether there is any risk of interference with the investigation and whether it is in the public interest to suspend the person. We discussed the issues and came to the conclusion that suspension was not applicable at that time, so we took the decision to invite the chief constable to return to work. I should point out that the leave of absence was at the chief constable’s request. It was not the SPA that put it in place, and the terms of the agreement with the chief constable were that he could elect to return to work. It was not just a decision for the SPA.

I decided to advise the cabinet secretary of the conclusion that we had reached, and I met him in early November—I cannot remember the exact date—to explain the circumstances. He told me that he thought that it was a bad decision, and it was clear to me that he did not want the chief constable to return at that point. We also had a discussion about the stability of the senior team, which was one of the SPA’s considerations. However, I had to attend a meeting of the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, so we had only a short time and I did not extend the conversation.

When I came out of the committee meeting, I was asked to see the cabinet secretary again. At that point, three officials were present. It was clear that the cabinet secretary was still very unhappy, but he changed the discussion to the process instead of the decision itself. I reminded him of his earlier comment about it being a bad decision; he told me not to bother with that, and we went on to discuss the process.

Two particular points were raised, the first of which was the PIRC’s position on interference. We had made our own assessment of that position, but the cabinet secretary wanted a more formal, written response from the PIRC. We also discussed the wellbeing plan for those directly affected by the chief constable’s return, and the cabinet secretary said that the process was deficient without those things. I thought that “deficient” was an odd word to use, because it sounded as though something was missing instead of there being something wrong. In addition, interference is only an issue for suspension and was not connected to the leave conditions. We could have got the PIRC’s position on that—there was no reason to think that it would be anything different. Indeed, I believe that the PIRC has already come back to say that it had no thoughts at that time that there would be any interference. That took that out of the way.

As for the wellbeing plan, we had already discussed how, as a board, we would approach that. In order to progress the matter and come up with the robust plan that had been requested, we thought it important to involve the senior team at Police Scotland, the individuals who had made complaints and, indeed, the chief constable. We could not really start those discussions until the cabinet secretary had been informed, but it was always our intention to put that in place. In any event, if the chief constable had not taken leave at the end of August or early September, we would have had to put a plan in place at that point. From my point of view, dealing with the issues that the cabinet secretary had raised should not have taken a great deal of time, so I left the meeting and put the chief constable’s return on hold.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

At what point did you change your mind?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I thought that, if the cabinet secretary was unhappy, it would be better for all parties to try to resolve that before the chief constable returned. Based on that meeting, therefore, I changed my mind.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Was your change of mind based on both meetings? You said that there were two that day.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Okay. You said that you made the decision because the cabinet secretary was unhappy and that, in your first meeting that day, he made it clear that—I think that these are the words he used—it was a bad decision. Did you feel that you were being directed to change your decision?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, not at that point. I thought that there was a point of disagreement, but when I went back for the second meeting, the discussion was about process rather than about the decision itself. As I have said, he deflected the question whether he still thought that it was a bad decision.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would like to look at the board meeting of 7 November. I presume that, as it was taken in private, there are no minutes. Are there minutes for that meeting?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

There would be, yes.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

I am sorry to come in here, Mr Beattie, but I certainly would have taken a note at the meeting. However, I might have left the Scottish Police Authority before the thing had been typed up, so I cannot give you a 100 per cent answer.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

I would have them in a notebook in my office—or what was my office.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Would they have been passed on to anybody else to create a minute?

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

I would normally have created the minute from it.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So you created a minute from it.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. Actually, when I think about it, I do not think that I did.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

But there was a note. There are minutes of the meeting that took place up until that discussion. At that point, I took a separate note, because the minute taker was asked to leave. After all, it was a confidential matter relating to the chief constable.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You were still active in the SPA until the end of November.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

That is right.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

And in the period between 7 November and the end of November, you did not create a minute from your notes.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

Not that I recall. I was on leave for part of that time, too. I would have to ask someone in the SPA to confirm that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

And the notes were not passed on to anyone else to create a minute.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

Again, I would have to ask someone in the SPA to confirm that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So, effectively, there is no record of that decision.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

There could be a record of the decision.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But we do not know where it is.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was there an agenda for that meeting?

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, there was.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Did it include the discussion about the chief constable?

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

My recollection is that the discussion about the chief constable was taken under any other business.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

If it was not on the agenda, no one would have known that it was coming up at that point.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

Other than the members, no.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So the board members would have known. How?

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

The chief constable’s leave was reviewed broadly every four weeks, but there was a timeline on which these things had to be reviewed. Because they had discussed the matter approximately four weeks prior to that, the members would have known that they had to come back and discuss it again.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But they would have had to remember that it was coming up to the time when there had to be another discussion on the matter.

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

No, because the members are in and out—I keep using the wrong tense, because I have not quite got used to not being there.

The members were regularly in and out of the office, so there was dialogue going on between them in relation to various subject matters. That had always been the case. The members would have been aware that there was a requirement to discuss the chief constable’s leave and the chair would have been in frequent contact with the members in relation to some of those matters, too.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given the importance of the item, was there full attendance from board members?

John Foley Former Chief Executive, Scottish Police Authority
link

I think so. I cannot remember any absentees on the day.

09:15

Dr Nicola Marchant Scottish Police Authority
link

I apologise for butting in, but I wanted, on behalf of the current board members, to support what Mr Foley is saying. We have a minute from 7 November that was subsequently produced on the basis of Mr Foley’s notes and which was circulated to board members. Our records show that the issue was brought up under any other business, and we as board members were aware that the discussion was going to take place, as we had had a previous discussion—which is also minuted—as part of the closed board meeting on 31 October. At that meeting, we considered the case and requested further information, which was brought to us on 7 November.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It might be interesting to see a copy of that minute, convener.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Is that something that you can provide to us, Dr Marchant?

Dr Marchant
link

I would have to go back to the Scottish Police Authority to confirm that; because of the nature of the discussion, it is a restricted document. However, I will ask, and if we can, we will supply it.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We will certainly explore the matter with the SPA following this meeting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Coming back to the question of who attended the meeting, was it a full board meeting? Were all the board members there?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

They would certainly all have been invited.

Dr Marchant
link

My records, which are still in draft form, confirm that there were two apologies but that the rest of the board members were there.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Given that two members were not present, is the reference in the documentation to a unanimous board decision correct?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was unanimous among the members who were there. That would have been a normal position to take. I would probably have had discussions with the other members who were absent, to inform them of what had taken place at the board meeting, and if any objections had been raised, I would have taken those back to the board.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Outside of the board members, did anyone else know that there was going to be a discussion on the chief constable’s future? Would any other stakeholders have been consulted prior to the discussion?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I believe that they would have been aware that the chief constable’s review date was 4 November and that we had not extended the period at that point. I do not recall whether we told anybody else, but it would have been evident to those close to the situation that it must have been a topic of discussion.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

A lot of assumptions seem to have been made that people were somehow keeping a record of the possibility of the discussion coming up. The handling of the matter does not seem to have been particularly strong.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I think that it was reported in the press that we had still to decide on it. People do take note of those things.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So people are expected to look at the press reports and the hope is that they can pick it up from there. The system really does not seem very robust.

On 8 November, you decided that the chief constable would return to his duties, and there was advice on and discussion about press releases in that regard. However, I am curious about the following sentence that was part of that discussion:

“Mr Gormley has now confirmed to the Chair of the SPA, Andrew Flanagan, that he has had sufficient time to prepare himself for the conduct allegations made against him at this time”.

Was that the criterion on which you decided that he should return to duty?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

It was one of the conditions that were discussed at the time when he asked for temporary leave. He considered himself to be significantly distracted by the intensity of the press activity and by dealing with the issues that had given rise to the complaints in the first place. He had to go through a process of documenting his own response to those complaints, and what he had said—

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I must interrupt you, Mr Flanagan, to remind members and witnesses that we must not stray into the details of any of the complaints that the PIRC is investigating. Members and witnesses should be careful in their questions and responses.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Thank you, convener. Because it was one of the things that the chief constable cited as a reason for the leave, we responded in those terms in the press release.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Did the board consider the situation of the complainants?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, we discussed wellbeing arrangements. It is worth noting that none of the complainants reported to the chief constable; only one of them was physically located in Tulliallan, where the chief constable is based, and all the others were in different locations. If there are complaints, it is not unusual for a wellbeing plan to be created to cater for the people who have made complaints and those who have been complained against.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You took the decision to go to Mr Gormley. Would it not have been wise to have discussed the matter with other stakeholders such as the Scottish Government or others with an interest in it? After all, it is a matter of great public concern.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

The first step was to have a discussion with the chief constable to see whether there were any other issues preventing his return. I had that conversation, and we had his agreement that he was prepared to return. The next step was to talk to the cabinet secretary about it.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

At what point did you determine that you would advise senior police officers of the decision?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I decided that we would do that as soon as we had spoken to the cabinet secretary.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

As late as 9 November, you were preparing press releases and so forth. At that point—the day before the chief constable was to return to duty—had you contacted any of the senior police officers? Clearly, arrangements would have had to be made and consideration given to how complainants would be protected, which would not have been an overnight job.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

As soon as it was clear that the cabinet secretary was not happy with the decision, I stopped the process.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was it on 8 November that the cabinet secretary expressed dissatisfaction with the decision, because, I presume, of process?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I would have to consult my diary for the exact date, but I do not have it with me.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The period within which that took place seems incredibly compressed.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Actually, I am not sure that it is. It is no more compressed than the time that it took for the chief constable to go on leave in the first place.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Mr Flanagan, having read the various documents that are before us, I have to say that we seem to be talking about a continuation of what the committee has discussed with you in the past: extremely poor governance and poor process. I can see nothing that shows that any sort of open and transparent process was followed.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

You must recognise that, although we are talking about the chief constable, he remains an employee. As an individual, he is entitled to the same personal protections—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am more concerned about the board’s procedures—how the board handled the situation and how you handled it. The decision seems to have been rushed through without stakeholders being properly informed and engaged. I find that quite extraordinary, given the sensitivities.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

At the first step of that engagement process, which was planned, a problem arose and therefore the process was halted.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But surely you should have engaged stakeholders prior to the board meeting to take that decision so that the board was fully informed of the position of different parties who were involved in the matter—I am not talking only about the Scottish Government; other parties were involved as well—from the point of view of governance.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We have rehearsed that argument. Do you want to answer that briefly, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

There was an engagement plan in place, and the cabinet secretary was the first person to be engaged. As soon as we had an issue, the board was informed that there was a problem.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But actions were taken before stakeholders were advised. Press releases were being agreed and letters issued to the chief constable. It was a fait accompli.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

You need due process to go through that, and it has to continue. Again, though, the position is that, ultimately, this is a decision for the SPA, and it is therefore advising those stakeholders.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Good morning. Following on from Colin Beattie’s line of questioning, I want to take you to the meeting with the cabinet secretary on 9 November. Am I correct in saying that, at the first meeting, there was just you and him?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Is it also the case that neither of you took any notes at that meeting?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. It was a very short meeting—it lasted only about 15 minutes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

As far as you are aware, neither of you noted anything down at all.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The cabinet secretary has made it very clear that the SPA had no plan to protect the wellbeing of officers and staff who had raised complaints or who had played a role in the investigation of those matters. Is he correct in saying that? Did the SPA really not have a plan for the wellbeing of officers?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. We had discussed the matter in some detail, but as I said in my earlier comments, our view was that, to get the robust plan that the cabinet secretary requested, we would have had to involve the participants, and they could be involved only once they knew of the circumstances.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So your view is that you had a welfare plan.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

We discussed how the issues might be resolved, but as I have said, if you want a formalised plan, the best way of getting it is to engage with and have the input of those who will be affected by it. That would have included the senior team at Police Scotland, the complainants and the chief constable himself, and we could have engaged with him only when he was back in place. It would also have involved the human resources director, who had experience of similar situations.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Dr Marchant, is the cabinet secretary correct to say that, at the time of his meeting with Mr Flanagan, the SPA had failed to put an appropriate plan in place?

Dr Marchant
link

I think that, as Mr Flanagan has said, there was a process of follow-up discussions that were going to be had that day. The start of the process was the discussion with the cabinet secretary, but the process itself was paused at that point. There were plans to have those additional conversations and to put the detailed plans in place.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Were those plans written down anywhere?

Dr Marchant
link

There was a list setting out the process for that day.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

That is not quite what I asked, Dr Marchant. Were the welfare plans that the cabinet secretary says that the SPA failed to put in place sufficiently at that point actually in place? You said that some plans were in place. They must have been written down, or were they just in Mr Flanagan’s mind?

Dr Marchant
link

No, I actually said that a process had been written down that would have led to the establishment of detailed plans. The process was about the conversations that were to be had with stakeholders to seek their input in putting together a detailed plan.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Can we have a copy of that?

Dr Marchant
link

The process?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Yes—what had been written down.

Dr Marchant
link

I did not call them plans. Let us be clear: I said that a process was in place.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

In that case, can we have a copy of what had been written down?

Dr Marchant
link

Again, I will take that back to the SPA.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Thank you. Mr Flanagan, I believe that you said earlier that in your first meeting with the cabinet secretary he told you that the board—I presume—had made a bad decision. What exactly did he say to you?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Well, that was the key point. He then asked how we had arrived at the decision; I started to explain the issues that we had and how we had come to that point, but he still felt that it was the wrong decision. As I have said, it was a very short discussion, because I had to leave for a committee meeting.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But he made a value judgment about the substance of your decision.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I believe so, yes.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Did the cabinet secretary tell you either at that first meeting or, indeed, at the second meeting to change your mind?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. It was not that explicit.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So why did you change your mind?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

As I said earlier, in order for the chief constable to return, it was best for that to happen in the most conducive situation possible. If the cabinet secretary was unhappy, for reasons that I did not understand, I thought that it was best to try to resolve the issues before he returned.

09:30

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

The cabinet secretary must have been incredibly persuasive if you changed the unanimous decision of the board.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

He had asked for two things, and I thought that they could be fulfilled relatively quickly. Therefore, I thought that that would not lead to an extensive delay.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

On the question of the second meeting, which was a much more planned meeting—

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Not from my point of view.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But you were aware that it was going to take place.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No. I was approached when I came out of the committee meeting and I was asked to go back to the cabinet secretary’s office.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

In that office, there were three officials.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, there were three officials.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Do you recall who they were?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

There was the director, the deputy director and one official whom I did not know.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

So there were five individuals at the meeting, including you. Did no one at any stage make any notes of what was transacted in the meeting?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not recall seeing notes being taken. That said, I have had many meetings with the cabinet secretary with officials present and I do not remember any formal record being made of those meetings.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

Could you qualify that? Does that include the keeping of informal records, such as people just noting stuff down as it is transacted?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

As in the normal course of things, they might have had notebooks in which they might have noted something for follow-up or something like that.

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

But you did not notice anybody doing that.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I did not notice anything specific.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Would you expect minutes to be taken, Mr Flanagan?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Mr Flanagan, I would like to follow on from Liam Kerr’s questioning about how we got from the morning of 9 November, at which point the board had made a unanimous decision, to the end of that day—I am not sure of the exact time—when that decision had been reversed, de facto, and the chief constable was asked not to return. Mr Kerr went through the two meetings, and I would like to ask at what point after you came out of the second meeting you decided to stop the return of the chief constable. To what degree was anybody else involved in that decision—specifically, other members of the board?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

It would have been that afternoon. I think that I emailed the board to say that there had been an adverse reaction from the cabinet secretary, and I phoned the chief constable and said that we should postpone.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Dr Marchant, as a member of the board, when do you recollect hearing about the change and the nature of that message?

Dr Marchant
link

I concur with what Mr Flanagan said. I recollect that the board received an email to say that we were pausing the decision.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

But that email did not involve you in the decision; it was a communication to you from Mr Flanagan of the decision that he had taken.

Dr Marchant
link

Yes, that was the communication from Mr Flanagan.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I cannot remember the details, so I am going from memory, but I think that I said that I recommended that we pause the situation. I do not recall anybody coming back to me with a differing view.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Did you give the members of the board time to return to you with a view? You recommended that approach, but then you acted on it. Did they have the opportunity to come back to you, or would they have had to have done that instantaneously?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I believe that a number of them got back to me, but I do not know that everyone did.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

In answer to Mr Kerr, you said that you were pausing the decision and that you felt that the difficulties or concerns that the cabinet secretary had expressed could be readily resolved. For example, you talked about getting a view from the PIRC. If that had been the case and you had been right, one would imagine that there would have been a short pause and you would have continued with the board’s plan of action, which was for the chief constable to return. Why did that not happen?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

For me, of course, it was the last couple of weeks before I stood down. We had further discussions—I had discussions with Dr Marchant and officials the following day. My feeling or impression was that it would perhaps have been better for the new chair to take the issue forward, rather than me. The view of a fresh pair of eyes might have been more convincing to the cabinet secretary than mine.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

If we look at what happened on that day—9 November—you went into it with a unanimous board decision. You met the cabinet secretary, who indicated to you that, in his view, the board had taken a bad decision. You met the cabinet secretary later, when he expressed a number of concerns about the process and the way in which the decision had been reached. Quite quickly after that, having informed board members by email of what you intended to do, you stopped the process that was under way of the return of the chief constable.

Earlier, the convener asked whether you felt that the cabinet secretary was directing you to stop the process. Do you accept that if you look at the situation objectively, it is quite difficult not to conclude that you felt that the cabinet secretary was telling you to stop the process?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

“Direction” is a more formal term, and I could not say that I had been directed to do that. However, I felt that I was not in a position to move forward with the decision.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

So you felt that you had no choice but to pause the decision.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Let me follow on from that briefly, Mr Flanagan. What would have happened if you had left the building that day and had not changed your mind?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

First, I would still have had to brief my colleagues on the board and gain their views on what we should do and whether or not we should press ahead. I would also have wanted to consult the chief constable to hear his view. Again, we need the parties to be comfortable and happy with the circumstances that arise.

Jenny Marra Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

My question was about how the cabinet secretary would have felt about it if you had not changed your mind.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

If we had not changed our mind, as a board, and I stress again that it is “we”, not “me”, and if we had agreed that it was important to press ahead—again from recollection, some members raised the question whether we should press ahead—I think that we feel independent enough as individuals that, if that had been our considered position, we would have continued with the process.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Correct me if I am wrong, but in the earlier remarks I think that Dr Marchant referred to a board meeting on 31 October that first considered reinstatement of the chief constable. Is that correct?

Dr Marchant
link

No, not reinstatement—at that meeting we discussed the continuation of a leave of absence.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Right. We have heard that that vital item was taken under the agenda item of any other competent business at the board meeting on 7 November, but were the board members informed that a proposal to reinstate the chief constable would be tabled at that meeting? Were they given advance notice that that specific proposal was on the agenda?

Dr Marchant
link

I cannot recollect whether that is or is not the case. As the deputy chair, I had had discussions with the chair and was aware of it. I do not have records to show whether other board members were or were not aware of what was going to be discussed on 7 November.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You are the deputy chair of the organisation and you are telling me that, on the most vital decision that you have had to make in months, if not years, you cannot recall whether board members were informed in advance of the meeting that a proposal would be tabled to reinstate the chief constable. Are you seriously expecting me to believe that you do not know that?

Dr Marchant
link

What I am actually saying is that I do not know whether there was a formal communication to the other board members on the 31 October meeting discussion that was proposed around—I am sorry, I am just trying to be very careful with the words that I am using.

Dr Marchant
link

I apologise. The discussion on 31 October was about the continuing leave of absence. We also discussed the welfare issues of complainers and complainees.

At that meeting, there was then a discussion around the NPCC and the redeployment opportunity. We discussed what information we required to make a more informed decision regarding that and the continuation of the leave of absence. There was an expectation that that would be brought back to a future meeting, which would have been on 7 November.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You say that it would have been brought back to a future meeting, but were board members not told that it would be brought to the meeting eight days later?

Dr Marchant
link

Yes—they were advised that it would be at the meeting on 7 November.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It would be tabled at that meeting.

Dr Marchant
link

Yes. The responses to the questions that had been posed would come to the meeting on 7 November.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was the chief constable given any advance notice of what was to be discussed on 7 November?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

He was not given precise details of when the board would come to a conclusion but, at the earlier meeting, I had been asked to seek the chief constable’s position on whether he was open to returning to work.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was the chief constable told that that would be, or might be, tabled at the meeting on 7 November?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

He was not told about the details of the 7 November meeting. We wanted his views on whether he was willing to return to work, so he would have been aware that we were to discuss and consider that.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The chief constable was aware but the acting chief constable was not aware, PIRC was not aware and the cabinet secretary was not aware, and we are not absolutely sure that the board members were aware that they were going to be discussing that on 7 November.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I believe that all the board members were aware that they were going to discuss that on 7 November. All the board members knew that we had to arrive at a decision either to extend the leave or return the chief constable to work. There was no doubt or dubiety in the minds of the board members about what the discussion was going to be about.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

How many board members were there at that time? I know that there has been recent recruitment to the board but how many people were entitled to turn up as board members on 7 November?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I think that it was 11.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

The minutes show that there were two apologies, so nine turned up.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

It is a majority of those present.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

A majority of those present cannot be the quorum. If two folk turn up—

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes. The quorum is six.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

After the meeting, the chief constable was informed. At what stage was he informed of the board’s decision to invite him to start work again on the Friday?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

He was informed on the Wednesday.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

He was told on the Wednesday.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Was that before or after you had your conversation with the acting chief constable, Iain Livingstone?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I did not have a conversation with the DCC designate until the Thursday.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Mr Livingstone gave evidence to the Justice Committee on Tuesday, and he said:

“I had no conversations with the cabinet secretary ... I had some communication with the then chair of the SPA. On the evening of Tuesday 7 November, I asked Andrew Flanagan for an update on the Police Authority’s meeting. I knew that there had been a meeting and I felt that it was important to get that update because I had a responsibility to the men and women, officers and staff within Police Scotland, should there be a change in Phil Gormley’s circumstances. I did not get a reply to that, and on the Wednesday I was told—”

by you, and on the Wednesday, not the Thursday—

“that deliberations were on-going.”—Official Report, Justice Committee, 23 January 2018; c 24.

Is that correct?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

As I said, for me, the first step was to advise the cabinet secretary. I would then have spoken to the DCC designate.

09:45

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Would it not have been more appropriate and accurate to have told the acting chief constable, when he asked you on the Wednesday morning, that you needed to speak to the cabinet secretary first and would then contact him?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Perhaps.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To say that deliberations were on-going at that stage—

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I had not spoken to the chief constable at that point to confirm that he would return.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So what was the sequence? You said that you had not spoken to Iain Livingstone until the Thursday. Iain Livingstone said that you spoke to him on the Wednesday. Do you now accept that you spoke to him on the Wednesday?

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

Yes, I accept that.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

So what was the sequence? Did you speak to Phil Gormley before you spoke to Iain Livingstone, or did you speak to Iain Livingstone before you spoke to Phil Gormley? I bet that you do not remember.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I do not remember in what order—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

There is a surprise—you do not remember. The amnesia that surrounds the Scottish Police Authority is beyond belief. We discovered that the last time, about nine months ago. The acting chief constable is basically saying that—in words of one syllable—you lied to him.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

No—I do not think that I did.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is what he is implying.

Andrew Flanagan Former Chair, Scottish Police Authority
link

I did not have a firm conclusion at that point.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Deliberations were not on-going at the board; the board had taken a decision. Surely the honest thing to have done would have been to tell the acting chief constable, who, as he rightly says, is responsible for the welfare of all those who work in Police Scotland, that you could not tell him what the decision was until you had spoken to the chief constable, Mr Gormley, and to the cabinet secretary, but that you would call him back in the afternoon once you had done that. Surely that would have been the professional way to handle that.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 505

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.