Good morning, convener and committee members. I look forward to working with you for many years to come.
Thank you for inviting me to today’s meeting and for the opportunity to contribute to the committee’s discussion about the draft Police Act 1997 and the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 Remedial Order 2018. I thank Parliament, the committee, officials and business managers for their support in timetabling Parliament’s consideration of the remedial order and the amendment order to follow.
The remedial order will further refine the higher-level disclosure system that applies when someone wants to work or volunteer with children, vulnerable adults or in certain professions, for example, in the financial services. It deals with what the state—that is, Disclosure Scotland—will disclose in response to a higher-level disclosure request, such as an application for a standard or an enhanced disclosure, or a PVG scheme record.
The order builds on the reforms that we made in September 2015 following a United Kingdom Supreme Court ruling in June 2014 that disclosures that were issued under the Police Act 1997 in England and Wales were incompatible with article 8 of the European convention on human rights on the right to respect for private and family life. Subsequently, a judicial review in the Court of Session challenged the operation of the PVG scheme. In the case of P v the Scottish ministers, Lord Pentland declared that, insofar as they required automatic disclosure of the petitioner’s conviction before the children’s hearing, the provisions of the PVG act as amended in 2015 unlawfully and unjustifiably interfered with the petitioner’s right under article 8 of the European convention on human rights. The effect of the court order, except in relation to the petitioner, was suspended until 17 February 2018 to allow ministers to remedy the legislation.
A 60-day consultation period on the proposed draft remedial order finished on 26 November. Ministers have taken account of the observations that have been received, and published a statement responding to them. The statement was laid in Parliament on 15 December 2017, when we advised that only minor changes would be made to the draft remedial order.
In proposing the order, we recognise that safeguarding must be balanced with appropriate protection of the rights of the individual to a private life, and with allowing people with past criminal backgrounds to move on. We believe that the proposed amendments to the system of higher-level disclosure strike an appropriate balance.