Welcome back, convener. I wish all members of the committee a happy new year.
My report today is on the 2016-17 audit of the Scottish Government’s non-domestic rating account, under section 22 of the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000. Stephen Boyle is the appointed auditor responsible for the audit, and his independent opinion on the account is unqualified. That means that he is satisfied that the account properly presents the receipts and payments for the year ending 31 March 2017 and the balances held at that date.
The purpose of my report is to support the Parliament’s scrutiny and understanding of non-domestic rates at a time when Scotland’s public finances are becoming increasingly complex with the arrival of new financial powers. In particular, I will draw the committee’s attention to issues that are highlighted by the audit relating, first, to the financial position and, secondly, to the transparency of the account.
The first point to make is that the operation of the non-domestic rating account is complex. In simple terms, the account is prepared annually to show the amount of non-domestic rates collected by councils and pooled by the Scottish Government and the amounts that are distributed back to councils by the Government as part of the annual local government financial settlement.
The balance on the account will always be in surplus or deficit at the end of the year due to forecasting and timing differences. At the end of 2016-17, the account showed a deficit balance of £297 million, which means that, in recent years, the Government has paid out more to councils in non-domestic rates than councils have collected. This is the third consecutive year in which the account has had a deficit balance. In February last year, the Government signalled its intention to bring the account back into balance over a number of years, but, as my report highlights, there is not yet a formal plan to do so.
The second area to emphasise concerns the transparency of non-domestic rates, which form a significant component of the Government’s annual budget and its funding to local government. I have recommended that the Government should increase the consistency and transparency of financial information on non-domestic rates as part of its commitment to longer-term financial planning. That includes publishing details of how the amount that is distributed to councils each year is calculated and how the Government expects the non-domestic rating account balance to change over time. That will help the Parliament to better understand how non-domestic rates contribute to the wider Scottish budget and its long-term sustainability as well as the impact on local government. The establishment of the Scottish Fiscal Commission provides an opportunity to increase transparency in the area.
We are happy to answer the committee’s questions.