Good morning. We set out at paragraph 22 and elsewhere in the report the decision-making process that the SPA went through in respect of the ultimate early retirement and associated payments for the now former chief executive.
If I may step back a few months, the decision that the SPA took was in respect of the critical Her Majesty’s inspectorate of constabulary in Scotland report on the forensic services in the SPA and the recommendations that it included. At that stage, the SPA board decided to act on that report and, principally, it sought to amend the reporting line for the director of forensic services from reporting to the chief executive to reporting to the board. As a consequence, the board took the view that the scale and size of the chief executive’s role was reduced and, in their minds, that led to a redundancy discussion. The SPA board considered an options paper at a closed meeting on 7 June, and that was the point when it sought to recognise the change in reporting line and the change of the role. At that stage, it also sought to engage in a consultation process with Mr Foley.
There are two points about the judgment that we have made and the resulting decisions. The first is about the exchange of correspondence that took place that led to the decision making. We felt that, to reflect good governance standards, a decision of such magnitude should take place at a formal board meeting.
Secondly, as we conclude at paragraph 22, an additional three months’ salary was incurred unnecessarily. Our judgment on that point is based on the fact that the SPA took a decision to pay Mr Foley’s notice in full, for six months. What we have not seen is any evidence or any reflection of a discussion about whether it could reasonably have asked Mr Foley to work his notice period. The SPA board was very clear that it felt that it was very important to retain the services of an accountable officer and to retain access to Mr Foley’s knowledge of the organisation in respect of the accounting arrangements, and it felt that that led to ambiguity about his potential leave date from the organisation.
In our judgment, we reflected on the previous history of the organisation. In every year of its operation—some of its difficulties in concluding year-end financial reporting matters are well known to the committee—it has always met the year-end statutory deadline of laying its accounts before Parliament by the end of December. In our view, the decision-making process was not in evidence as to whether it could have sought to conclude Mr Foley’s employment with the organisation but allow him to work his notice period. We thought that there was some merit to that in gaining access for his interim successor to have some form of handover arrangement.
That led us to the judgment that we set out in the report regarding Mr Foley leaving the organisation on 30 November 2017. Had he worked his notice period, that would have taken him up to February 2018 at a point where the board reached a conclusion for Mr Foley to leave the organisation in August. Instead, six months forward from November takes us into May 2018. That is where we arrive at the difference of the unnecessary three months’ additional salary costs.