To ask the Scottish Government when it will next meet the United Kingdom Government to discuss matters relating to the constitution. (S5O-01584)
Official Report · Chamber
The Constitution
Portfolio Question Time Finance and the Constitution
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 3
- Linda Fabiani SNP 2
- Adam Tomkins Con 1
The record
6 contributionsYesterday, I met UK Government ministers, along with my counterpart in the Welsh Government, Mark Drakeford, and civil servants from the Northern Ireland Executive, in the joint ministerial committee (European Union negotiations). The meeting focussed on UK frameworks, the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill, migration and the involvement of the devolved Administrations in stage 2 of the European Union negotiations. I made it clear that the constitutional future of Scotland and this Parliament is very much at stake in the process of EU withdrawal unless there are amendments to the withdrawal bill. I stressed that all the powers of this Parliament affected by withdrawal must stay devolved after Brexit. I also made it clear that if it is possible to create a special arrangement between Northern Ireland and the European Union, recognising the special difficulties and status of Northern Ireland, there is no logical reason why Scotland should not have the same rights. Indeed, it would be unacceptable for Scotland to be placed at any economic disadvantage.
The next time that the minister meets his UK counterparts, following on from those discussions and yesterday’s debate, will he express the shock of many in Scotland at finding out that under the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill, the UK Government, along with Tory Scottish MPs who consistently refuse to safeguard Scotland’s interests, is refusing to safeguard Scotland’s devolution settlement and instead legislating for the right to amend the Scotland Act 1998?
It was disappointing to see last week those Scottish Tory MPs refusing to support the Scottish Government and Welsh Government amendments with regard to clause 1, which were carefully thought through, and then to see last night a repeat of that situation in which amendment 158 was voted down. It was an amendment that would have made sure that UK ministers could not, by secondary legislation or by action—simply by the stroke of a pen—alter legislation passed by this Parliament. It is disappointing to see that. We have made it absolutely clear that we will not bring forward a legislative consent motion unless there are those amendments or equivalent amendments to the bill. That is the nub of the matter. There can be no legislative consent motion without those significant and lasting changes to the bill.
The newspaper The Herald reports on its front page that at yesterday’s JMC, there was in fact substantial agreement between the two Governments on the repatriation of powers from the European Union to this Parliament following Brexit. However, according to The Herald, rather than share that good news with the Scottish Parliament—and, indeed, with the Scottish people—the Scottish National Party would keep it under wraps. Why? Does that not just serve to underscore yet again that the SNP would rather contrive a grievance than get on with the job of delivering Brexit for Scotland?
No, it does not. If Mr Tomkins had read the whole piece, he would have seen a significant statement from the Scottish Government that said “This is not true.” So, the “exclusive” tag on the story is for an exclusive untrue story. What is more concerning about the story is that it indicates that the Secretary of State for Scotland does not understand the process in which he is engaged, which is very concerning indeed. The process in which we are engaged is looking at the list of 111 intersections between European competence and devolved Scottish competence and making sure that those matters come to this Parliament. Then, of course—we have made it absolutely clear—we can sit down and talk about those matters that should be subject to joint frameworks and co-decision making.
Unless there has been a new declaration of intent from the UK Government, the issue is not about re-reserving powers that should be in this Parliament. However, if Mr Mundell’s briefing to The Herald is to be taken at face value, he believes that the actions that we are engaged in are about re-reserving powers and allowing the rest to come back here. That is the nub of the matter. If the Secretary of State for Scotland does not understand the discussion that we had yesterday afternoon, that bodes ill for getting a settlement. Fortunately, there are others round the table in the UK Government who do understand the discussion and are working to try to achieve that. I hope that that work will pay off, but I have to say that it is not helped by the Secretary of State for Scotland, who seems to think that his job is to brief The Herald rather than get a resolution.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 13 Dec 2017 →- The Constitution Questions · 6
- Landfill Tax (Decreasing Revenues) Questions · 4
- Local Authorities (Funding) Questions · 10
- Local Authorities (Funding) Questions · 8
- Non-domestic Rates Questions · 8
- Local Authorities (Draft Budget) Questions · 4
- Private Finance Initiatives and Public-Private Partnerships (Payments) Questions · 6
- Departmental Spend (Outcomes) Questions · 5
- Economy, Jobs and Fair Work Questions · 1
- Town Centres (Support to Attract Businesses and Jobs) Questions · 8
- European Structural Funds and Regional Policy (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Living Wage (Support for Employers) Questions · 6
- Disability Employment Gap (Targets) Questions · 6
- Workforce Productivity (Action) Questions · 4
- Seasonal Skilled Labour (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Orkney and Shetland Economies (Support) Questions · 6
- Improving Productivity (Progress) Questions · 4
- Finance Debate · 149
- Business Motions Business motions · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
- Heads Up for Harriers Project and the Role of Species Champions Members’ business · 24
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.